Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Wonderful life

Socialist Organiser no. 442, 5 April 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 565 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Despite our best inD tentions, scientists (including the scientific socialists who write and read this paper) find it difficult to stand outside of our experience and situation and look objectively at our place and significance in the universe.

Wonderful life*, by palaeontologist Stephen Jay Gould, which has just joined Stephen Hawking's Brief History of Time in the best seller lists, helps us to do just that.

Many scientists, and not just religious ones, see the history of lite on Earth as a steady growth in complexity and diversity, culminating with ourselves, the first (and last?) intelligent life form. The tree of life, starting from a slender shoot, burgeons upwards and outwards. Modestly, we place ourselves at the top.

Naturally, the religious world view sees all existing for our benefit. Unfortunately, this flawed outlook is shared by many scientists.

Scientists, such as astronomer Fred Hoyle, with brilliant insights and hard work, have laid bare the conditions which allowed: • the stars to produce enough carbon for life to exist; • dust to form balls of rock orbiting around medium-sized stars; • atmosphere and oceans to accumulate around this ball of rock; • the right temperatures etc. for the carbon atoms to combine in various ways, resulting in the selfperpetuating sunlight-driven set of reactions we call life.

But Fred Hoyle has said of the conditions for the synthesis of carbon in stars that he could not conceive of these arising by accident. The universe exists for us. We are not just one species but the species.

Non-scientist Mark Twain introduced a more realistic perspective with his comparison of the history of the Earth with the Eiffel Tower. On this scale, the human era would be the skin of paint on the pinnacle knob. And was the Eiffel Tower constructed for the benefit of that layer of paint?

So, is the history of life one of organisms growing more diverse and better adapted to their environments? If we were to rerun a film of life, would it always have the same ending?

Gould's model is one of blind chance acting to decimate more or less at random the species existing at particular times. According to him, the rewound film could have all sorts of endings — and we might not feature in many of them!

Gould's theory is a testable one. Just look at the fossils from various periods, and see whether diversity increases over time or whether it sometimes increases, sometimes decreases.

Unfortunately the fossil record is notoriously incomplete. Dead things usually get eaten or decomposed. Only the teeth, bones or shells tend to survive, so we are particularly short of the earlier softbodied animals. However, there are a few examples where special conditions prevailed and creatures were preserved in astounding detail.

One such is the Burgess shale deposit of British Columbia, and it is this that provides Gould with his subject matter. Here, some 530 million years ago, a mud slide down an underwater cliff buried a collection of bizarre (to us!) sea animals. And the soft fine mud allowed an incredible amount of detail to survive inside as well as outside the fossils.

There was Opabinia, with its five eyes and frontal nozzles; Yohoia, with its unique grasping appendages; Marrella, with its headshield with backward pointing spines, its antennae. many gills and legs; and

Scan page 11

ister benefits

----- pull-quotes -----

LES HEARN S COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 442

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →