The American hero as mad dog
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Belinda Weaver reviews 'Black Rain' There is something pathetic about a country whose propaganda movies only help the other side. American movies so often do.
Either they exaggerate the evils of the enemy so grossly that the 'peril" begins to seem funny, or the American heroes are so unappealing that sympathy swings towards the enemy' Anti-communist movies of the witch-hunting fifties were often hilarious. Equally pitiful are the cop films of today which tell us only that Americans are violent, xenophobic, and embarrassingly ignorant.
Far from helping America's image, these films are a gift to the so-called baddies, even when the crooks are drug dealers or crazies. Films like Rambo, Year of the Dragon and now Black Rain go so wildly over the top in their portrayal of evil Asiatics that our sympathy rushes straight towards the supposed bad guys.
In films like this, democracy seems to mean the unassailable right of Americans anywhere to be as violent as they like to anyone they like, to ignore liberal nambypamby stuff like civil rights and fair trials, and to insist on English as the language of insult, even when in a foreign country, in fact, especially in a foreign country.
Anything less would be wimpish and unAmerican. John Wayne would be proud.
Black Rain is a pre-emptive strike in America's propaganda war against the Japanese. The US is sore about Japan's economic dominance, hence films like Black Rain which help ease the blow to American pride.
The film is meant to show the Japanese as mindless conformists who don't have the vigour or bravery of even one lone American. Ghastly as the film is, it doesn't achieve its goal; we feel only sympathy for the Japanese who have to deal with possibly the vilest cop ever to come out of America - Michael Douglas's Nick.
The image of cops in American movies has long been on a downward slide, but Black Rain probably marks Hollywood's lowest assessment yet of cops. NIck is simply a mad dog, a guy who becomes a policeman to find a legal outlet for his violence. He's also thoroughly dishonest, so dishonest that he can see nothing wrong in bribes or money on the side. Cops deserve it, he thinks; it goes with the territory.
He has no scruples, no qualms, no redeeming features at all. With his motorbike, his shades, the perpetual cigarette dangling from his mouth, he's almost a caricature of a tough guy. He's trying too hard to prove himself; his complexes can be spotted a mile away.
This is not an enjoyable movie, but it's interesting in its further debasement of the cop, and in its racist depiction of American's newest enemy, the Japanese, whose booming economy has replaced the Soviet Union as American bugbear.
In Black Rain the Japanese are to blame for everything. When Nick signs a fake form in good faith, it's their fault: the form was in Japanese for Christ's sake! Nick sees the determination of the Japanese people to speak their native tongue (in their own coun try!) as some kind of congenital weakness. Nick's English would be no help to them anyway, limited as it is to insults and swearing.
The Japanese actor who plays Nick's reluctant partner has one speech where he abases himself before Nick's "individual" approach; this is utterly offensive.
All Japanese customs are ridiculed, from chopsticks to indoor golf, from ritual politeness to sticking to the rules. Good manners are signs of sinister intent, playing by the rules absolute proof of decadence.
Honour, honesty, courtesy, they're for dummies, is the message; America didn't become great by saying please. Well, er, no.
Director Ridley Scott seems to have recycled his Blade Runner set to stand in for Osaka. The Japanese are just a new set of sinister Orientals, living cheek by jowl in a perpetually steam-filled environment.
Why all the steam? In the countryside where the final showdown is set, and where steam would be implausible, small fires have been lit to provide smoke, second-best substitute for steam. Mystifying.
The film offends on so many levels that it's hard to single anything out for special mention, yet it has a strange innocence about it. Can Scott or Douglas anybody really think Nick is a positive image of American values? Or is the film really a veiled threat to the Japanese that the gloves are off.
Black Rain is really the cry of a whipped cur. The Americans can't admit they're beaten, so they ridicule the winning team. The treatment of the Japanese is so awful that we end up feeling increasing sympathy for them, even for the Osaka police who keep trying to send Nick back to New York.
Japan's greatest crime in American eyes may not be their economic health after all, but their returning Nick to his old stamping ground, the US of A. the wonderfully named Hallucigenia, with its bulb on one end and a tube on the other, with its seven pairs of struts and seven tentacles.
It was difficult to relate these to known groups of animals, though the discoverer of the fossils some 80 years ago tried hard to do so. More recently, palaeontologists have reassessed the Burgess hoard and it is now clear that while more modern animals fall into four types of body plan, the ones in the Burgess shale fit into some 20 types. There was in fact about five times the diversity of living things in the oceans of that time that there is today.
Gould believes there is nothing special about the body plans that survived, including the one that gave rise to our line. Given an unfavourable change of environment, not all types could survive. Some had to go, and it could quite easily have been our ancestor as much as Hallucigenia.
Gould writes as well as any popular science writer of the day, without oversimplifying or patronising. The story of the Burgess shale is one of dis-covery, not only of the fossils from their rocky covering but of their nature from the covering of preconceptions.
*Hutchinson, £14.95 can't find the sex which the Whitehouse brigade finds unacceptable", lamented Chris Dunkley, TV critic of the Financial Times He was speaking on Channel Four's "Right to Reply". They had chosen the weekend of the National Viewers' and Listeners' Association's AGM to present the results of a poll of public opinion about sex on TV These days you might be afraid of being thought some sort of monster if you said there should be more, not less, sex on TV. In fact, Channel Four's poll, commissioned from Gallup, showed about half the people questioned in favour of more sex on TV, so long as it's shown after children's bedtime.
The figure was 59 per cent "for" among the 16-44 age group. However, bearing in mind that older people are more likely to rely on TV for entertainment than younger people, it wouldn't be fair to count their wishes as mattering less than those of younger people.
"Right to Reply" drew the conclusion that Mary Whitehouse is out of touch with what viewers and listeners actually think. It seems that she promulgates an opinion which she thinks people should hold. —William Cash, one of the Conservative MPs who agrees with her, spoke of "a shift in attitudes which needs to be rectified". In the view the Whitehouse faction, people have been brainwashed into accepting more sex in the media, although who is corrupting the nation's morals and to what purpose they never explain.
Most people, sensibly, do •NOL see more openness about sex as the result of some higher unidentified authority pandering to their baser instincts. Rather, it is the reflection of more honest and less repressive public attitudes generally - although, sadly, the average viewer is not so ready to accept the portrayal of homosexuality on TV or to accord it equal status in public life.
Does Mrs Whitehouse actually want to force people not to see sex in the media? She does submit to debate the issues. But she tends to consider only that evidence which supports her case.
When asked to comment on the obvious public approval for at least some sex on TV. she spoke about people's responsibilities to protect children, and of the common belief that seeing pornography leads people to commit sexual offences.
However, *Right to Reply" had been very careful to pose their survey so that people knew they were being asked about portraying not sexual violence but "sex in the context of a relationship" (whatever that means). In effect, Mary Whitehouse chose not to answer the question at all.
Meanwhile her Association is pressing the Government to reinforce the legislation against obscene publications, and to extend its effects to television. And it is finding an echo among many Tory MPs.
So, how should people lobby to defend our right to see sex on TV? And sex in what context? (I don't mean, should it be the kitchen, living room, or plain old bedroom?)
One viewer responding to the poll suggested that there should be a national station given over to sex... It would be a very strange programming schedule, where the criterion was only that there was some sex somewhere in every programme.
That probably wasn't what the viewer meant, but most purely pornographic programmes or films made now probably wouldn't pass on technical quality, let alone taste, to make it on to our screens.
In fact sex on TV is far less likely to be kinky than in its other formats, precisely because it is seen by so many people of differing tastes, and is open to public opinion and censure.
I hope it stays that way, and that we don't have a few MPs goaded by vociferous minority curtailing our right to see programmes with sex in them, because sex is, after all, a part of most people's, even MPs', lives, in some way or another.
And it would be gross irresponsibility to allow prurience to end discussion and education about related issues like contraception and sexually transmitted diseases.
----- pull-quotes -----
please TV