Why East Germany moved to the right CONDOME SCHUTZE
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Five months ago the Berlin Wall was opened, and at a rally in West Berlin celebrating this victory, Chancellor Kohl was booed when he led the singing of the German national anthem. Many of those who had gone on the streets in East German) to bring down the old Stalinist regime called for a 'better socialism' there.
Today Kohl's East
German allies have wo a big election victory a the promise of quick unification with West Germany and no messing around with any socialist experiments. The small pioneer free trade union groups in East Germany remain very small. -Why? We have translated and abridged this article by Thomas Klein from the election broadsheet of the East German 'United Left'. We do not agree with its assessment of the SED (the old ruling party, now renamed PDS), nor with its attitude on German unity, but we print it as a contribution towards helping socialists in this country understand the debates on the German left.
Is late as November 1989, A the process of transformNation then underway was defined by all the apparently united political currents as "revolutionary":
A broad campaign emerged under the slogan, "We are the people!" , against the corrupt political bureaucracy whose days were finally numbered as a result of the growing mass pressure from below.
A broad consensus on fundamental questions of democracy and human rights bound together the opposition of the "period before the turning point" in a community of solidarity, and left-wingers, who had been persistently persecuted in the GDR, were an important part of this movement, in the sense of Rosa Luxemburg's sentence about freedom being freedom for people who think differently.
With the slogan "We stay here!" , the majority of the protest movement was determined to counterpose collective commitment for a renewed socialism to departure from the GDR, regarded as an individual solution to heightened social conflicts. There was clearly no decision in favour of capitalism in the GDR.
And today?
The people of October 1989 are no longer on the streets. New demonstrators with completely different slogans dominate the scene. Now the slogans are: "Germany, one fatherland!" and "We are one people!"
Why have the voices of those in the GDR who cry out for reunification become ever louder? Why have the people who dominated the streets in September and October given way to those who wave the German flag and agitate in favour of reunification? Why are we now seeing violence again against people who think differently and in particular against the left?
What is the cause of the rise of xenophobic, far-right, and even fascist currents in the GDR? What has happened between November and February?
Here are the stages:
As a result of the vain at1 tempt to keep the collapsing SED in control by deceiving and placating the population in revolt, from November onwards the impatience of the population, which again feared manoeuvres, grew. Verbal pledges of reform by Krenz's Politbureau remained without any results.
The resignation of the Polit2 bureau, which had been forced through by the indignation of the SED rank and file, and the creation of a new government, led to a tug of war between hardline SED-PDS apparatchiks and that section of the party rank and file that was pressing for a real renewal.
Those forces of renewal, and the hesitant party executive of the SEDPDS, missed the last chance to put themselves at the head of the anti-Stalinist movement in the name of a future socialist alternative. Instead of drawing the only correct conclusion - to support the resolute party rank and file in the occupation of party buildings and in locking out the party apparatus - the various currents of the SED-PDS exhausted themselves in a wrangle about the profile of the future party. limited nited atselex to manoeuises att, preserve the assets and existence of a party in the process of dissolution, at a time when it was a question of making political decisions.
The Modrow government adopted the profile of being the political arm of a technocratic reform current, pursuing a course which was politically acceptable to the ex-satellite parties.
Its creed was a commitment to a market economy, and its politics came to no more than the announcement of far-reaching measures of economic reform based on a thorough rationalisation directed by managers and, above all, on aid from West German capital.
No impulses for a comprehensive implementation O T 60determination, let alone of selfmanagement, by the workforces in their enterprises, came from the government. Nor did it take its bearings from the concept of a wide development of self-government organisations and bodies of popular sovereignty. It very soon became clear that such a thing was not to be expected from this government.
The tempo at which independent trade union initiatives and factory council initiatives were formed as self-help organs against the arrogant actions of factory and combine bosses, alongside the painfully slow process of the reorganisation of the ofticial trade unions, was too slow to prevent economic and political collapse.
Instead of speedily implemented package of economic the selling-out d preparations for reforms, we had economic functionaries who were converted with breathtaking speed from advocates of the command economy to "pioneers of the free market" lined up for the starter's gun.
With this continuing uncertainty, the condition of the GDR economy continued to grow worse, shaken by crisis and further destabilised by the United Lef protect... bitant rent UN : t poster in the t Ger out who will p st yo s, and attacks socia continuing emigration.
This period coincided with the second about-turn by the parliamentary parties which were gradually breaking out of their bloc with the SED-PDS: the abandonment of Stalinism which had been forced on them by the people also imposed on them the first about-turn "away from the old SED"
After a short moment of horror this was continued by the old parties, and taken immediately to the point of distancing themselves from socialism in general, in order finally to be able to seize the initiative again. Linked to this, of course, was the hope (false, as it turned out) of thereby throwing off at a stroke their own past and the burden of their shared responsibility for the past.
In an atmosphere of growing anger about the siow rate at which the party was cleaning itself up, the SED-PDS. was afraid to profess the socialist perspective which had been discredited by the SED.
This led to the flight of the SED PDS to a woolly parliamentarism which lacked any precise shape, and to new mass resignations and attempts to rally forces outside the SED-PDS.
The profile adopted by the old parties — "away from socialism"
Stalinism and socialism which was accepted by broad layers of the population. distance unions.
The negative attitude of the 7 Modrow government towards abolition of the Ministry for National Security as the successorinstitution of the unconstitutional Ministry for State Security strengthened the distrust of the population and its lack of confidence that a break with the past could really be achieved with this government and with the party from which Modrow came.
After the link-up of the conservative and liberal parties with their West German sister parties began the capitulation of the government to their political demands, principally on the question of reunification.
Under cover of a "government of national responsibility" Modrow was able to execute his ultimate manoeuvre, the three-point plan for German unity. From now on it was no longer at all clear for broad layers of the population that sovereign alternative was still achievable in the GDR.
Inside the organised citizens"
8 movements it had already long been clear that the rupture between the different currents could no longer be repaired.
The conservative "Alliance" consisting of the CDU, DSU, and "Democratic Upsurge" ', adopted a profile of hackneyed anti-socialist cliches drawn from the electoral campaign of the Western CDU against the SPD in the 1970s, not even acknowledging that the SPD. East had already, as a precautionary measure, renounced any propaganda about socialism.
The citizens' movements adopted proposals which ruled out any alliance with the United Left, without giving any reason for this apart from the danger of such an alliance being less attractive in the yes of the voters. Thus occurred he failure of the broad democratic coalition of the citizens' movements which had been sought by the United Left.
At present the social fear of the consequences of a "reunification" in the sense of a policy of immediate annexation to the Federal Republic on the conditions laid down by the D-Mark is growing throughout the population. Neither the Modrow government nor the SPD, and certainly not the liberal or the conservative alliances, show themselves to be particularly interested in working out an alternative to the Kohl plan.
In the Federal Republic capital is deeply divided over the road to reunification.
The social and economic consequences of an immediate economic and monetary union have been soberly outlined by the representatives of big capital: as a result of the enormous gap in productivity we will have to reckon with structural mass unemployment, largescale bankruptcies, and a substantial cut in social services.
If, on the other hand, the process of unification takes place slowly, in line with the progress of GDR economic reforms, in conditions of an evening-out of the gap in productivity, and through the stages of monetary assocation and economic coperation, then as far as capital is concerned there exists the danger that, on the one hand, a diversification of the economic cooperation of the GDR with Western countries will occur in opposition to the interests of Federal Republic capital, and, on the other hand, with the process of unification consolidated GDR will not only be inclined to defend social and economic achievements but also determined to introduce political achievements (perhaps even self-managed economic units and direct democracy!)
----- pull-quotes -----
- was meant to express in a popular way the equation of