Conference forced to cancel
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
About-turn on unity The Constituency Labour T Parties Conference planned for 7 April in Wakefield Town Hall has been cancelled because of problems with the venue.
It may be just a coincidence, but the leaflet against the witch-hunt in n my article on the left's debates about German unity (SO 439) I wrote that the French socialist group Lutte Ouvriere had come out against reunification, Since then LO have changed their position. In their paper dated 23 March they advocated "taking account of the workers feeling in favour of reunification and showing solidarity with it. Wirral produced by the CLPs Conference, which contained an advertisement for the Wakefield conference, was part of the evidence submitted to the last National Executive Committee - and shortly afterwards the problem with the Town Hall arose.
This is the second time that Indeed, they criticised the East German left (the United Left, Die Nelken, etc.) for "trailing behind the debris of the old political apparatus, by repeated declarations against reunification"
Especially in view of the harshness of their criticism of the East German left, it is unfortunate that LO make no self-criticism of their own previous position.
"T Colin Foster, Islington. meeting of the CLPs Conference has been undermined, the first time being when the AEU National Executive cancelled our booking in Liverpool ABU Hall because they did not agree with the aims of the CLPs Conference.
We have been unable to arrange another venue in Wakefield and have therefore had to cancel the Conference.
A CLPs Conference Organising Committee, which any interested member of the Labour Party can attend, will be held in Wakefield on 7 April. Those wishing to attend should meet outside Wakefield Town Hall, Wood Street (opposite the police station) at 1lam.
I'm sorry about the cancellation, but this should make us even more determined in our campaign to bring democracy back to our Party.
Lol Duffy, Conference Network, Wallasey.
Scan page 5
rhe frame-up Birmingham Six of the Shane McGowan of the Pogues had a better grasp of the truth of the Birmingham Six case than three British trial judges, three Lord Chief Justices, and two Home Office inquiries.
The six men are literally "doing time for being Irish in the wrong place and at the wrong time"!
It is too easy to get bored with the apparently endless detail of the case, but it is important to remind ourselves that six people have spent 15 years in jail on the basis of astoundingly scanty evidence. At times it is hard to believe that even one inquiry survived without an embarrassing apology and the release of the men.
The evidence against the six is that they were leaving Birmingham for Belfast on the night that pubs were bombed in 1974. They were arrested at Heysham Ferry terminal and questioned at Merseyside police station.
Scientific tests carried out by a Home Office specialist, Dr Frank Skuse, showed that the men had a substance consistent with explosives on their hands. During interrogation the men confessed to the bombings. Some signed written confessions with details of the planning and locations of the bomb.
That is the sum total of evidence. The Lord Chief Justice, summing up the 1988 Appeal, stressed that the confessions were central. The scientific evidence was also important, but secondary.
The case for the Six is over= whelming. First, the judges' stress on the importance of the confessions in 1988 is revealing. It was just the latest example of the legal establishment shifting on to new ground as the old ground crumbled beneath them.
The scientific evidence was discredited by a simple test. A repeat of the Greiss test, which had provided the crucial evidence seastance ind son their hands could be picked up from playing cards. Previous evidence showed that the men were playing cards on the train to Heysham.
Dr Frank Skuse retired from his job three days after a World in Action TV programme proved his test worthless.
As the scientific evidence collapsed, the judiciary switched to the confessions. It is worth remembering throughout all this that in British justice a suspect is supposed to be innocent until proven guilty. The burden of proof is firmly with the prosecution, and juries should acquit if there is even a "reasonable doubt" as to the guilt of the accused. the major planks In 1985 one of of the original conviction was destroyed. That was accepted by the court in 1988. But there was no change in the verdict, • nO "reasonable doubt"
STie & no doubt hat the o the really important eviThere is no doubt that the men were severely beaten in custody.
When that became obvious, the police claimed that the beatings had been given by the prison warders at Winson Green, Birmingham. Prison warders charged were acquitted, but the police (and by implication a series of court judgments) insisted that meant that other prison warders were guilty.
A forensic scientist claimed that the men had been beaten in police custody, but his evidence • was dismissed by the judge.
The question of the treatment of the six by the police is crucial, because their confessions are the only thing to justify their imprisonment. They denied the confessions from the beginning, and claimed that they had been beaten from them.
The courts simply would not believe that the police were capable of such behaviour. The police responsible for the investigation were the West Midlands Serious Crimes Squad, now subject to an inquiry for their tendency to get results by framing suspects.] At the most recent appeal, in 1988, six key witnesses gave "new evidence" on how the confessions were gained. All six suggested that they, as police officers or prison staff, had seen evidence of beatings.
A cleaner at Morecambe police station had cleaned blood off cell walls. An ex-constable saw beatings and arrangements to fiddle interwitnesses sre dismissed by judese these as liars, perjurers, and revengeseekers.
Of course, that didn't mean that the original evidence of those "perjurers" was to be discounted, only the most recent. It was one more disgraceful example of the judges selecting the evidence to fit their story.
The work of the Birmingham Six's legal advisers and supporters has exposed various absurdities in the confessions. According to the information in the written confessions, the so-called "bombers" can't agree on where exactly the bombs were placed and how many there were. And generally none of this testimony tallied with the known facts about the bombings.
Add to this a less tangible element in the case, the sheer implausibility of the state's story. Six men, who have just carefully planned and ruthlessly carried out the most brutal civilian bombing in an English city for many years then go off together, as a group, to an IRA funeral in Belfast.
They make no attempt to go underground, to scatter, to prepare alibis.
There is a huge contradiction in the state's story of a calculating, professional IRA bomb gang on the one hand and their selection of the Birmingham Six for the role on the other. T ment in the case is he most recent developGranada TV's decision to name four of the five people originally suspected by the Special Branch.
They obtained a Special Branch document which confirmed years of research by Labour MP Chris Mullin and suggested that the bombings were the work of another group entirely and that the police knew this.
David Waddington, the Home Secretary, announced a new inquiry into the case just days before the programme. On his mind, most likely, were the Granada revelations to come, and also the endorsement of the men's case by a US House of Representatives Human Rights Committee.
The innocence of the Birmingham Six is so plain that their continuing imprisonment is difficult to believe. After all, the court system has found ways to release the Guildford Four, albeit after many years.
The problem is that the Birm ingham case, unlike Guildford and most other cases of injustice, cannot be put down to a few bad police officers. The higher judiciary is fully implicated, in fact it is more guilty, as at least some police officers and prison staff have tried to put the record straight.
Ex-Attorney-General Sam Silkin seems to have complied in defending the police story at all costs. The most notorious offender was the arch-reactionary Lord Denning, who dismissed an earlier appeal on the grounds that the implications of the men's innocence for the entire legal system were too great to be acceptable.
These six men are now in prison not because of police brutality or scienfific incompetence, but because of the naked prejudice and self-interest of the senior judiciary.
The very people who most liberals and many socialists tell us are bed todle saipmous and impar- legally tial, have been repeatedly responsible for the simplest form of bias known - they have refused to allow the facts to get in the way of an agreed good story.
David Waddington may want to release the men, but he insists on new evidence to distract from the power of the very damaging evidence that has existed for years. No new evidence is required, nor for that matter should it be necessary to name new suspects to a legal system so incapable of the most rudimentary principles of fairness in Irish cases.
The old evidence is screaming at all those who will listen. The Birmingham Six are innocent! They must be released now!