Revolt in the hell-hole
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
December 1989 conference. But the policy has not been implemented by the Labour-led National Executive. Walworth Road finds our policy of "Don't pay, don't collect" far too embarrassing, Poll tax is a pressing issue for students. It is not only the direct effect of the poll tax on student pockets that is worrying activists. Through its effect on council budgets, poll tax will lead to closures and cuts at Further Education colleges.
On Monday 2nd, activists heard lan Greaves, one of the nonMilitant members of the National Committee of the All-Britain AntiPoll-Tax Federation; address a 150-strong Left Unity fringe meeting.
Ian's message was: implementi NUS policy and beat the Poll Tax!
Also at the meeting was Left Unity supporter Mark Studdart from Leeds University, who had 25 stitches in his head after being attacked by the police on the demonstration last Saturday, 31 March.
Ian Greaves won the conference poll for guest speakers, and will be addressing the full conference on the poll tax. are invited. The conference is at Sheffield Poly, Pond Street, from 1lam to 5pm Saturday (registration begins at 10am) and from 10am to 2.30pm Sunday.
Credentials are £10 (organisations), £6 (waged individuals) and 63 (unwaged) from PO Box 118, Chesterfield, Derbyshire S44 SUD. The next planning meeting for the conference is on Sunday 8 April, 11am at Durham Road Community _Centre, off Seven Sisters Road, London N4.
RAMI MILLETE ded Many, have died in the rioting at Strangeways prison in Manchester.
According to a banner displayed at a prison window, none. According to the emergency services, dead are to be expected.
What is clear is that the riot was a product of appalling and inhuman conditions in the overcrowded prison. It is not the first riot in Britain caused by such conditions in recent years, nor will it be the last. The scale of its violence only reflects the urgency of the situation.
The prison officers have been saying for a long time that British prisons are overcrowded and understaffed. Indeed, last year they staged a strike against the conditions they have to work under, and police were drafted in to do their job - badly.
One of the biggest scandals of all is the equal overcrowding to be found in remand centres, such as Paul Herrmann, the one in the north east knownas 'grisly Risley'. Here men who have not even been convicted of a crime - they are waiting to be tried - are kept cooped up like chickens in a battery farm. Last year there was a riot and rooftop occupation at Risley.
Britain is notoriously worse than most West European countries. It is not so much that our prisons are smaller or less well-equipped. Quite simply, more people are in them -three times as many in proportion to population as in Holland, for example.
People get put in prison in Britain for crimes which, in other contries, they would not.
In other words, prison is used in Britain as a form of punishment, and a supposed "deterrent', far more than in other countries. That the numbers in prison are so high must show, surely, that as a method of crime prevention it is a failure.The Strangeways riot shows graphically the real results of this policy. Prisoners are treated like animals.
are not animals. are people. Even those who committed dreadiul crimes al committed dreadful ple. ple.!
Some of the worst offende bably need care and attentior than punishment, although an untashionable 'pinko' o these days. Certainly, ce prisoners up in hell-holes w make them better able to tak places in society.
The reason most prisone from working-class backgrot not hard to find out. Pover insecurity breed crime. Rich get off more: they can pay fo awyers, they play golf wi judges, they are more likely t "good characters" and so be prison even when found guil Prisons are tied in with the system of rich and poor, po and powerless!
Any democratic socialist : would have to have some v dealing with people who bre aws, who killed or raped or But a socialist society wou proach the matter differentl reat any prisoners differentl -Speaking about the Action mittee established in Ales Township, South Africa, rears back, independent inion leader Moses Mayekisc nented: "In Alexandra, the ion of sentencing is proble secause how do you sentence ion?
*We do not believe in co sunishment, but we have ucky because people listi whatever decision is made. I ›le listen we don't need to nent any punishment...
"We believe that the cour people's courts"] have an / ional function. They are th politicise the offender. Most n the area is caused by the caf und apartheid systems, so v he offender that he mustn't limself to be used by them"
Such an approach doesn' sut exactly what prisons strangeways should be rej vith. But a society that ad hat approach would surely be ikely to avoid the *Strangeways yndrome". re peors proa more that is pinion hoping ill not le their is are nds is ty and people r good th the o have let off ty., whole werful society vay of oke its stole. ld apy, and Comkandra a few trade • comquesmatic, a perrporal been en to f peoimpleeducaere to crime pitalist ve tell allow spell like placed lopted
Scan page 3
Not to distinguish between foolish anarchists and people driven to spontaneous revolt is not to be able to understand what happened and why.
The main responsibility for what happened on Saturday lies with the leaders of the labour movement. No wonder people feel desperate and hopeless enough to lash out blindly when the leaders of the Labour Party and the TUC confine themselves to verbal fireworks and fencing displays with Mrs Thatcher and her ministers in the House of Commons.
As Tony Benn has said, had the Labour Party and the TUC backed Saturday's demonstration, then it could have been a million or more strong. Proper stewarding could have controlled the unruly.
Even the police would perhaps have had to behave themselves better at a demonstration with Neil Kinnock and Norman Willis marching at its head.
Instead the leaders of the Labour Party and the TUC have eagerly joined in the Toryconducted chorus against "violence". It is a long time since anything quite SO odiously hypocritical has been seen in Britain.
People sitting in their homes saw on their TV screens a troop of perhaps 20 mounted police ride down a lone woman in the centre of a road, ride over her without falterling, and go on their way, leaving er on the ground where the horses hooves had trampled her.
They saw a mounted policeman with a long baton leaning down to club a man who had fallen on the ground, beating him repeatedly on his head. They saw policemen -sometimes mounted - charge wildly into crowds of bystanders, swinging batons indiscriminately.l They saw peaceful bystanders with their heads streaming blood as a result of such tactics by the police.
And the politicians - Labour and Tory alike — go on and on about violence, meaning violence by the poll tax demonstrators! Labour leaders Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley vie with the Tories to demand exemplary punishment of those arrested, and call for police investigations into the "conspirators" behind it all. Roy Hattersley blames the Socialist Workers Party - though even the police have stated that known SWPers were seen trying to calm things down! So does George Galloway, the well-off "left" MP (quoted in the Guardian, 2 April).
It is hard to imagine anything majority of Tory voters - is the very opposite of democracy. If Thatcher's attempt to brand Labour with responsibility for last Saturday's semi-uprising has failed, that is not because Labour's leaders have played little sir echo to Mrs Thatcher but because people in Britain know where the violence comes Vast numbers of desperate people Britain probably sympathise, half-sympathise, or can anyway understand those who ran amok last Saturday.
If Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley are interested in democracy, then they should cut the cackle and the cant about the democratic nature of Mrs Thatcher's tyranny and fight for the democratic rights of the British people now by campaigning for an immediate general election.
It is still not too late for the leaders of the labour movement to take their proper place at the head of a powerful labour-movementbased movement against the poll tax and Mrs Thatcher. If they believe their own talk about democracy, that is what they will do. Probably they won't.
The months ahead may well see other explosions of anger like last Saturday's, essentially spontaneous. If the leaders of the labour movement won't lead an organised fight back, then the rank and file must.
Not only Labour MPs like N Hattersley and Galloway have gone in for "fingering" sections of the left and acting, or promising to act, as "felon-setters" for the police by trying to identify left-wingers as being responsible.
The officers of the All-Britain Anti-Poll-Tax Federation - Steve Nally and Tommy Sheridan - have promised to hold their own investigation" and then "go public naming names" (Nally). To whom?
To the police? To go public is to go to the police.
The left has a right to defend itself against anarchist disorganisers and against outbreaks of wild hooliganism, including the right to throw disrupters off marches. Nally and Sheridan had a right to dissociate themselves from the violence last Saturday.
But nobody on the left has the right to felon-set people on our side who act against Thatcher and her poll tax according to their best lights.
Nally and Sheridan are Militant people, and the All-Britain AntiPoll-Tax Federation is completely (and very bureaucratically) controlled by Militant. Those who run Photo: John Harris They talk for the record about not collecting, and call for a general election now to "bring down the Government" but in practice they pay no attention at all to the fight to line up Labour councils to refuse to implement the poll tax, or trade unions to refuse to cooperate, This is surprising, but true. Militant burned its fingers too much in Liverpool.
And Militant is in considerable disarray politically. People in Scotland like Tommy Sheridan looked set early this year to stand as candidates against Labour in the local government elections. They seem to have been dissuaded.
It is right to advocate non-payment, and Socialist Organiser does advocate it. But Militant HIGGSAN HEL makes it into a one-side panacea, and foolishly ignores its limitations and difficulties, while at the same time channelling the anti-poll-tax movement away from concern with the trade unions or with local government, which is the interface between the Tories, the labour movement, and the working class.
These politics - or lack of politics - help push young people new to politics and not part of the labour movement into anarchist attitudes.
More than that. Militant was in charge last Saturday. The AntiPoll-Tax Federation is tightly controlled by them and patrolled in their usual ultra-sectarian spirit. Most of the stewards on Saturday were Militant (many of them full- timers), or controlled and selected by Militant, and Militant had an airtight grip on the overall organisation.
There can be no certainty that better stewarding would have made a decisive difference, but it is a matter of fact that the stewarding failed completely at the end. Since Militant has a jealously-guarded nearmonopoly on the Anti-Poll-Tax Federation, the responsibility is Militant's when things go wrong. To cap this inept performance with a public promise to investigate and publish a list of names of allegedly violent people there on Saturday — that is, in effect to hand them over to the police — is to reduce things to la nasty and unpleasant farce.
----- pull-quotes -----
Britan's death squad 7 exposed
s we go to press, it is still A not known how many, it
sOWS From front page
Fuck ThE POLL TAX