The left the poll tax
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 24 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 24
now lots of people feel that the Tories will never be beaten.
Thatcherites are in many ways a new breed of Tory. They have set out to tear up the 'post-war' consensus' - that is, the Welfare State, trade union participation in government, low unemployment. Their job they knew, was to restore the ailing profitability of British big business.
And they've been quite successful -for now.
The fight against the poll tax can be the turning point. The Tories are not unbeatable. So far they've survived big crises, like the miners' strike; and survivors often look unbeatable.
But the poll tax, like many Tory policies, is unpopular. What we need to do is harness and mobilise the popular opposition to the Tories. Beat them on this, and we could really turn the tables.
How? This pamphlet has spelt out the strategy we need to beat the poll tax: a mass campaign of refusal to pay, linked to a trade union campaign to refuse to comply with the tax. If the labour movement -Labour Party and trade unions -adopted this policy and fought for it among 'non-political' working people, the Tories would be very scared indeed.
For that to happen, people understand and support this strategy have to get together convince others of it.
we lave lu try to co-orainate alIferent battles against the Tories. We haro ta nonnaina dha -- 1 - Have lu urgamse ine peopie wno understand how the different battles mesh together. That way we can build a coherent, intelligent movement that, like the Tories, knows what it wants, and knows how to get it.
Too often the working class movement reacts to Tory attacks. When we've beaten the poll tax, we should make sure that in the future we take the initiative. That way we can beat the Tories - and their money-grabbing system — once and for all.
To do that we need an organised body of socialists with a clear strategy and ideas, inside the labour movement. We need a cohesive Marxist left wing in the labour movement. That's what Socialist Organiser aims to build.
To believe the Tory press, you would think that the boisterous scenes outside (and inside) Town Halls throughout England and Wales in March 1990 had all been engineered and masterminded by professional agitators from the 'Militant Tendency' The Mid-Staffs by-election, where thousands of former Tory voters registered their bitter hostility to the poll tax by voting Labour, gave the lie to that ridiculous conspiracy theory.
Nevertheless, it has to be admitted that 'Militant' supporters have often been at the forefront of anti-poll tax campaigns, first in Scotland and then south of the border. Militant recognised the importance of the poll tax issue earlier than most people on the left and they have made it their central campaign since early 1988.
Unfortunately, their undoubted energy and seriousness on this issue has not always been directed towards building an effective anti-poll tax movement, so much as furthering their own factional interests. In Scotland, Militant packed out meetings of the Lothian Federation with delegates from local groups representing little or nothing on the ground, in order to take control. At the November 1989 'All-Britain Anti-Poll Tax Organising Conference' they used their control of the conference organisation and their majority on the floor to stifle any serious discussion and to turn the whole event into a selfcongratulatory rally.
Worse than Militant's bureaucratic and often undemocratic organisational methods, has been their one-sided and simplistic over-emphasis on 'mass non-payment" as the only way to beat the poll tax. Socialist Organiser supporters (and a few other serious campaigners) have insisted from the start that mass non-payment alone will not be sufficient to beat the poll tax: it has to be combined with a campaign for non-implementation by Labour councils and the trade unions.
Militant do not go so far as to oppose the demand for non-implementation: it's just that they constantly "forget" to mention it (as at the November All-Britain conference), and rarely, if ever, discuss the practicalities of building for non-implementation.
For a while, carried away with community-based zeal, Militant even opposed allowing local Labour Parties to affiliate to the All-Britain Federation - a bizarre aberration for a tendency whose entire political existence normally revolves around the internal affairs of Worse still, material produced by Militant and by the All-Britain Federation consistently suggests that non-payment is an easy, painiess matter.
"A surcharge of about £50 on those paying full poll tax and about £10 for those paying the 20% minimum" are the trivial penalties referred to by the Militant. £10 is, in fact, not such a "trivial" amount for someone who has to live on Income Support. The full implications of attachment from earnings, attachment from benefits or the arrival of bailiffs are never spelt out honestly or realistically in any Militant or Federation publication. Boosting the confidence of potential non-payers is one thing: deliberately misleading people about the possibile consequences of such a strategy — and its likelihood of success in isolation from a campaign of non-implementation — is quite another.
In contrast to the Militant, the SWP has never really got its act together on the poll tax. The SWP were slow to get involved in Scotland and changed line (for instance, on whether or not non-registration was a viable tactic) on a number of occasions.
Unlike Militant, the SWP has given considerable emphasis to the demand for non-implementation by councils and trade unions. But this (correct) orientation resulted for much of 1989 in the SWP effectively writing off any nonworkplace opposition to the poll tax.
The SWP pamphlet, (now apparently withdrawn) 'Socialists and the Struggle Against the Poll Tax' , dismisses meetings on housing estates because "they only involve minority. sometimes an extremely impressive minority, but a minority
Scan page 25
nonetheless." But isn't win the mili-