Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

It's right to break this law L says we should fight the poll

Socialist Organiser nos. 440–441: How to Beat the Poll Tax (1990), 29 March 1990 · scan pp. 21–23 · about 680 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 21 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 21

Labour leader Neil Kinnock Itax without breaking the law. He's used the same argument before — on trade union laws, for example. We have to respect the law, his argument goes, or democracy collapses. First elect a government, then change the law.

If working class people had ever taken this argument seriously, we wouldn't have democracy now.

Our democratic rights were all won through struggle. And very often that struggle has meant disobeying the laws of the day, because those laws have been worked out to protect the interests of the rich and powerful. Only by breaking the law could working class people win rights for themselves in a society dominated by the rich.

The idea that laws are democratic because a democratically-elected government passed them is ridiculous. In 1975, a democratically-elected Prime Minister in India, Indira Gandhi, decided to suspend Parliament! Was thai democratic? Adolf Hitler came to power through parliamentary channels. Did What 'the law' meant for striking miners that make Nazism democratic?

Of course not. Democratically-elected governments can make thoroughly undemocratic laws. And when they do, they should be opposed by every means possible.

The poll tax is an attack on working class people's rights. If we don't break the law, what do we do? We comply with the poll tax all down the line. We pay it. Trade unionists collaborate in implementing it.

In other words, we don't really oppose it at all. Our opposition is just words. We wait until Neil Kinnock is Prime Minister.

Photo: John Harris (Report)

But if the Tories get away with the poll tax, who's to say they won't just go from strength to strength? If we're to get a Labour government, we need to beat the Tories now.

Inevitably that means breaking the law. It means breaking unjust laws — not breaking all laws! It means taking seriously the fight against the Tories.

Either we fight or we don't. In this, like every working class struggle in the past, if we fight we refuse to play by the ruling class's rules. If they make laws designed to keep us in chains, we have no choice but to break them.

Scan page 22

spokesman, David Blunkett, has apologised for the weakness of the official opposition to the poll tax.

Blunkett is thought to have tried unsuccessfully to persuade the National Executive Committee of the value of a demonstration.

He said in a letter to local Labour Parties: "Considerable delay occurred in getting agreement for these plans through the machinery of the NEC and the Labour Party headquarters," adding: "I can only ask that you do attempt to link in with the local protest activities even in these unsatisfactory circumstances."

Working class people have not been cowed by 10 years of Tory artacks. They have been demoralised and confused by the lack of any decisive opposition or alternatise. The poll tax gives us the opportunity to rally and organise the working class opposition to Thatcher.

Almost every working class person stands to lose from the poll tax. Our job must be to organise that massive reservoir of potential support, to bring together the community activists and the rank and file of the unions and the Labour Party.

If we can carry our existing leaders with us, excelleni. If not, they must be replaced by those who will give a lead to the fight.

To those comrades who've been demoralised by 10 years of defeats and say, "Nothing can be done now, we must wait until 1991 and the next election," we say: it is always better to fight back. Even if you are right, and outright defiance won't stop the Tories now, what it will do is build up the resistance.

To lie back and simply accept the poll tax is a recipe for further demoralisation and defeat, even if you think that we have to wait until The poll tax continues 10 years of Thatcherism the next election to get rid of the Tories.

Scan page 23

GENERAL MUNICIPAL BOILERMAKERS AR, ALLIED TRADES ANS POLL TAX cottish "PROSECUTE STO Photo: John Harris (Report)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 440–441: How to Beat the Poll Tax (1990)

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →