Instead of poll tax
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 17 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 17
The old rates system is not ideal, but it's better than In fact, no system can be ideal. No system of local taxes, however well-designed, can undo the inequality and injustice of capitalism. Only collective ownership and democratic control of the wealth of society can do that.
But some sorts of taxes are better, or less bad, than others.
Rates have one great advantage. They are simple and easy to administer. That's an advantage not just for administrators, but also for socialists. Rich people will always find ways to evade any complicated tax. They can't evade rates.
Moreover, businesses have to pay rates out of their profits as well as workers having to pay out of our wages.
Rates mean the rich paying more than the poor. But - and this is the big disadvantage - they tend to mean the rich paying a smaller proportion of their income than the poor.
Say a worker on £5,000 a year lives in a flat costing £100,000 (there aren't many cheaper than that in London). A capitalist on £500,000 a year might have two houses worth £l million each.
The capitalist's houses are worth 20 times as much as the worker's flat, so the capitalist pays 20 times as much in rates as the worker. But the capitalist's income is 100 times the worker's.
So the slice that rates take from the capitalist's income is only one-fifth the slice they take from the worker's income.
And if the worker becomes unemployed, or retires, it's even worse. They still have to live somewhere. But now the rates may take half their pension or benefit.
Rates are they than better take from the rich
Scan page 18
Myers have a work without the DUD services pro the council: shouldn't th employers This is impossible, so we have rate rebates. Like every means-tested rebate system, they are complicated and involve lots of bureaucratic hassle. Many people don't claim the rebates due to them.
Small businesses also suffer from the rates system, because they have to pay more in rates, as a proportion of their turnover, than bigger businesses.
Some of these problems could be reduced by making rates more flexible. Why shouldn't councils be able to charge more rates per pound of property value on bigger, more costly buildings than on small, cheap buildings? Why shouldn't councils be able to set rates on businesses much higher than rates on homes, rather than the relation between them being set by Whitehall?
Local income taxes exist in many other countries. Advantage: your tax rate is decided by your ability to pay. Disadvantage: it would be no fairer than the present national income tax system, with all its loopholes for the rich.
Labour Party policy is for some combination of rates and local income taxes.
Again, a more flexible system could be better. Why shouldn't councils be able to claim a sort of "poll tax" from the employers of workers who live in their area (and from the central government for unemployed people) in the same way that the National Insurance fund collects employers' contributions? After all, employers wouldn't have a workforce without the education, housing, and social services provided by the council: why shouldn't those employers help pay?
Central government grant to councils is good in that it siphons money from rich areas to poor areas where the council has a lot to do and few rich people to get any sort of tax from. What's bad about it is that it can give central government excessive power to control and victimise local councils - power which the Tories have used ruthlessly.
Central government grant should be decided by predictable formulas which the government can't easily alter.
Generally, socialists should support local government having more autonomy to raise its own income and make its own decisions. Local councils in Britain are much more restricted in what they can do than councils in other countries.
Several times since 1979 courts have found the Tory government to be breaking the law. Each time the Tories have just changed the law to square it with what they want to do.
Local councillors, in contrast, can be hauled up in court when they have broken no definite law but only done what the District Auditor Labour's leaders have proposed La combined local income tax and property tax as their alternative to the poll tax.
It would certainly be better than the poll tax. Your tax would depend on your ability to pay. But three problems remain.
This alternative sounds complicated. It has allowed the Tories to make demagogic, but still possibly effective, claims about Labour "wanting to replace one tax by two".
Nothing the Labour leaders have yet said indicated how their more complicated formula is any better than a straightforward local income tax, which was favoured by the Labour Party as an alternative to rates in its evidence to the Layfield Inquiry on local government finance.
The Labour adreckons to be "imprudent". Labour councillors in Liverpool have been disqualified from office and fined huge sums for their delay in setting a rate in 1985.
Hammersmith and Fulham council have been warned about possible court action for juggling with their money in the City's markets. When private capitalists do the same thing, the Tories praise it as the acme of "enterprise culture".
Central government needs to be much more subject to the law, and local government needs to be much less subject to central government.
Such reforms would mean more local democracy and more scope for genuinely socialist local councils. dressed the question of giving local government more financial autonomy. As long as local councils depend en central government for much of their money, and are closely restricted as to how they can raise the rest, local democracy will be very limited.
Any central government with a budget problem will be likely to shove cuts on to local authorities by cutting grants — and to do that in a politically selective way.
Since 1979 the Tories have cut billions from central government grant to local authorities. The third, and biggest, issue which the Labour leaders' alternative does not address is restoring those cuts.
Until they are restored - or a substantial chunk of central government tax-raising power is transferred to local authorities in compensation - all debates on local government finance will be debates on squeezing local people and local council workers more and more to pay for worse and worse services. 17
Scan page 19
nalgo OFFICIAL PICKET OFFICIAL PICKET :CA.
The next day the union's National Executive turned down calls from two branches (Islington and Knowsley) to hold official ballots for non-cooperation by their members in finance departments.
It was part of a joint retreat, alongside Labour councils in England and Wales. When the preparations were being made for the poll tax in Scotland, Labour councils dithered about how to appear to oppose the tax, yet plan to collect the money.
Councils in England are all just pressing ahead with the tax.
Can council workers stop this retreat? There are important things we can do now, and in future.
The chance of total non-cooperation which would stop poll tax departments being established has already gone, but there are ways of preventing, or at least sabotaging, the operation of the tax.
The many council workers who will be asked to give information have very good reasons not to: housing workers, housing benefit workers, swimming baths
----- pull-quotes -----
HOW T0 POLITAX
alternative to poll tax