Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[IHE UNIONS By Sleeper There were angry scenes…]

Socialist Organiser no. 439, 22 March 1990 · scan p. 11 · Pat Markey · about 1,035 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

IHE UNIONS By Sleeper There were angry scenes at British Aerospace, Preston, earlier this month. A mass meeting was judged by senior stewards to have voted to accept the company's offer of a 37-hour week tied to a 19-page package of strings.

But it took no less than three shows of hands before the stewards announced the vote as being narrowly in favour.

Militants were furious: not only was the deal well short of their demand for a 35-hour week with no strings, but it was widely felt that the stewards and officials had "done a Nelson" from the platform — that is, had turned a blind eye to what was actually a majority for rejection and staying out.

Now, there is nothing terribly remarkable about any of this - I have been at dozens of mass meetings where the rank and file's assessment of how the vote went and the platform's decision did not coincide. Sometimes the rank and file are simply wrong: on the whole, the platform has a better view of things whereas standing in the middle of a field or car park amid a few thousand other workers is not the ideal vantage point from which to assess the outcome of a close show of hands.

After a series of contentious hand votes at British Leyland in the 1970s, the BBC and ITN even took to hiring helicopters from which to film the proceedings — thus giving BL workers the opportunity to second-guess the platform in much the same way as boxing fans study slow-motion playbacks and argue about the ref's decision.

What was more remarkable about the Preston row was that rank and file militants were demanding a ballot whilst the senior stewards and officials like Bill Jordan were insisting that the show of hands decision must be there's a funny thing.

Wasn't it Bill Jordan who told last year's Labour Party conference, "workers have got used to ballots and they're not going to give them up""? And haven't most of the hard left been arguing for years that something called "ballotitis" (an unhealthy addiction to putting crosses on pieces of paper instead of exercising the right arm in time-honoured fashion) was evidence of the dreadful decline of rank and file militancy, conclusive proof of the "Downturn", etc, etc?

Don't get me wrong: I've always believed mass meetings are a Good Thing. But what is good about the traditional mass meeting is the opportunity it gives workers to hear all sides of the argument and have a proper debate, free from press and TV interference. There is nothing especially wonderful about the show of hands itself as a means of counting the vote - indeed, on contentious matters it can often be a very bad way of voting, causing all sorts of unnecessary problems and giving the losing side the opportunity to "foul" and even defy the decision.

It has to be said, as well, that all too often the good old fashioned mass meeting wasn't actually conducted all that democratically: for instance, the platform seldom allowed dissident speakers to get to the mike.

At British Aerospace Chester (where a mass meeting was held the same day as Preston) a majority of stewards favoured rejection, but were prevented by the officials from recommending it from the platform!

Of course we need to get back to mass meetings as the natural, elemental form of workplace democracy. And of course, secret postal ballots are not an appropriate (or democratic) way of calling a strike (or even calling off a strike), but then the Tories have never suggested that, have they?

What's wrong with having a ballot at the mass meeting, after all sides of the argument have been aired? That way, you'd at least avoid the sort of shambles they had at Preston. Or am I suffering from that dread ailment, ballotitis?

Right months into the Confedaeration of Shipbuilding and • Engineering Unions (Confed)

*Drive for 35 campaign and the number of workers winning a reduction in the working week ranges from 19,000 according to the Engineering Employers Federation (EEF) to the Confed's figures of 66,000 (which even the Financial Times thinks closer to the truth), plus another 20,000 workers in the Scrap Metal Federation, who have just won a 37-hour week with no strings.

A shorter working week is now firmly on the agenda. But any successes have to be set against the scandalous role of the Confed leadership.

Back at the start of the campaign in the glossy leaflets put out by the AEU we were given figures about the massive rise in productivity in engineering over the last 10 years. Thus the reduction in hours was couched in terms such as "we've earned it!" The implication was that the campaign to reduce the working week (to 35 hours brother Bill!) would be without any strings.

The reality is that the deal recomBritish Aerospace where sterihis of British Aerospace (where sections workers have been on strike for five months, and which the Confed leadership sees as 'pivotal' - if BAe cave in "then the rest of the engineering employers will be easy. It will be like robbing old ladies, or taking sweets from children") is almost identical to the kind of flexibility proposals put forward by the EEF in 1987 which Jordan wanted to accept, only to be met by a rank and file revolt.

Back in January, an issue of the Confed's Strategy Committee (!) weekly "Update' bulletin commented: 'We hail the absolutely magnificent dedication and determination of the 7,200 men and women, manual and staff, who are on strike in British Aerospace plants in Chester, Preston and Kingston. We pay tribute... etc, etc. Oh spare us, spare us.

That's not the situation at BAe now: There is a deal with bad strings at Chester (accepted after pressure from Jordan and Airlie); continued strike action at Kingston, where the stewards are recommending rejection of the company's "final documents". At Preston the Strand Road site has accepted a deal with strings, and at Wharton and Salmesbury sites the deal has been rejected and they are working to the old 39-hour week agreement.

----- pull-quotes -----

steward, British Timken, Northampton

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 439

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →