Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

More than write history

Socialist Organiser no. 439, 22 March 1990 · scan p. 10 · Vicki Morris · about 610 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

due examination of the crimes of Stalin, illustrated by historic footage and interviews which have only become available now because of the opening up of discussion of the past in the USSR itself.

What is the argument? Who was responsible BOT the crimes of Stalin's era? Stalin himself? Those who went along with him? Or those who went before (for which read "Lenin")?

Stalin is portrayed as ruthless and megalomaniacal, while "those who went before" are understood as acting in defence of the 1917 revolution which at least promised to put an end to the horrors of the time.

However, the history is still portrayed in terms of "the biography of great men". Even a dictator needs a constituency, at least before he establishes his control. Yet there is no analysis here of the people who supported Stalin's rise to power, nor of those people who while "being nothing much in themselves carried out his orders. The director leaves one element out of his equation altogether.

It was explained how Lenin established the mechanisms through which Stalin came to rule - the one-party state, the Cheka, at first necessary for the dictatorship of the proletariat, later capable of repressing the whole country in the interests of layers of the "Communist" bureaucracy.

There was an attempt at evenhandedness. Lenin's disillusionment with Stalin was documented, and his attempt to have him removed as General Secretary.

But the political battles for control of the Party were dealt with superficially. There was no explanation of the alternative economic strategies put forward in the '20s, and no discussion of the international context events in the USSR, beyond the difficulties created for the Bolsheviks in the early days by the foreign intervention in the civil war.

No credit was given to the Bolsheviks' expectation that the Russian Revolution could only be consolidated by revolutions in advanced Western countries, and how their disappointment compounded the economic problems they faced. There was nothing about Stalin's disastrous role in the Communist International.

The greatest omission in the gramme was not explaining the ideology of the Bolsheviks. historian really must explain people's motivations; but all we had was a few people's word that the early Bolsheviks stood for something completely different to Stalin and the people who joined the Party when conditions got a bit easier and there were perks of membership.

Lenin's dissolution of the Constituent Assembly in 1918 was seen as his attempt to keep Bolshevik keeput off the chance of real democracy in Russia.

The narrator put on an ironic tone when he described the "bourgeois"" parliament which Lenin did away with. Only a well-read person would know that it was Lenin's description of a form of democracy which was inferior to the form of democracy which had emerged in 1917, the Soviet. There was description of those "Councils of Workers' Soldiers! and Peasants' Deputies" which constituted the power base and democracy of the Revolution.

A writer who depicts Lenin sympathetically, even assigning him "heroic" intentions, yet ignores the idea of soviet democracy, is being disingenuous. He rejects the theories without even discussing them so the viewer gets the impression that Stalin was just a more rigorous Lenin.

The programme is on the side of the people, and we should welcome it on that level. Odd moments were astonishing, like Stalin's daughter saying she is proud that her father was initially opposed to the Bolsheviks' plan to take power in November 1917, and passing no judgment on his appalling crimes.

But I can't help being irritated by omissions which have the effect equating Leninism with Stalinism.

----- pull-quotes -----

TV TV's "Stalin" is a long over-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 439

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →