Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Chickens' lib

Socialist Organiser no. 439, 22 March 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,075 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

COLUMN M about battery farming uch of the concern is based on a humancentred idea of what it would feel like to be stuck inside a little cage, unable to stretch your wings, just eating, excreting and laying eggs.

It seems obvious that this would be a most unpleasant existence but is it? Drs Christine Nicol and Marian Stamp Dawkins are among those who have been finding out exactly what is important to hens.

Wild jungle fowl, the ancestors Br the 024106. They are high a i- live in tive during the day: walking, running, flying, preening, pecking, and scratching for food. At night, they roost together in the trees.

Domestic chickens have been selected for their egg-laying ability but studies of chickens released into the wild show that their behaviour is very similar to that of their wild relatives. Thus it seems that this behaviour is very firmly laid down in the genetic make-up of the chicken.

A truly "free range" existence for chickens would be very similar to the above, with small groups of birds living semi-wild amid a rich variety of vegetation, though with protection from extremes of climate and from predators. However, many "free range" farms fall a long way short of this.

In many cases, thousands of birds share a central house with perhaps less room each than a battery hen. They are free to go out but many rarely do. This may be for several reasons: they may not know where the exit is; dominant birds may prevent them from doing so; or the outside may not have much to offer or may seem threatening.

The latter point may be the most important. Many farms offer open grassland where the birds will not find a mixture of food sources and where they may feel exposed to the attentions of predators.

Perchery systems also pack birds in closely but without the access to the outside. Eggs can be described as "perchery" or "barn" even if the birds have as little as 64 square inches of floor space or six inches of perch. This is less than the room in a battery cage. Perches are more comfortable for the birds than the wire mesh floors of battery cages but the more timid birds often may not get access to them or to the nests or dust-bathing areas.

Thus, free range or perchery chickens may spend a lot of time in densely crowded conditions, pecking at the ground which is covered with faeces, often contaminated with parasites or disease-causing bacteria. Battery hens may actually be cleaner and less prone to such problems. However, battery birds do show other signs of distress, such as pecking each other's feathers. This can lead to severe loss of feathers, damage to skin, infections and death. The problem of cannibalism, found where chickens are overcrowded, may be a result of feather pecking.

Assuming that, for economic reasons, chickens are likely to be kept in large numbers, Nicol and Dawkins look at the evidence for what chickens really need, ie. what is really important to them. Studies have already shown that chickens prefer large cages to small ones; the company of birds they know to that of strangers; floors covered with litter to wire floors; loose material such as straw for nesting, rather than mixed artificial grass.

The next step is to find out how strong these preferences are so as to have a measure of how much the birds suffer by their denial. This is done by imposing a "cost" on the use of a facility and seeing if this affects the bird's determination to use it.

It has been found, for example, that chickens will run the gauntlet" of water-filled foot baths, unpleasant blasts of air or weighted swing doors to reach a nest box. They will enter a nest box the same number of times whether they have to squeeze through a narrow gap first or not, though this affected their willingness to reach other goals.

Nicol and Dawkins conclude that use of a nest box really "matters" to chickens and its denial to battery hens represents a real hardship. Pecking and scratching are activities that seem to be "programmed" into the behaviour patterns of chickens. Jungle fowl at Whipsnade Zoo spend more than half their time pecking the ground. This activity is obviously connected with the need to find food but chickens don't do it in order to find food: they do it because they have an instinctive urge to do so. This is provided by comparing the behaviour of chickens who have to search through litter to find their food with those who can obtain their food quickly from a food hopper. Both spent the same time "foraging" even though the hopper-fed birds had already eaten their fill and were no longer hungry.

Chickens also react badly to enforced contact with strangers. In experiments, this has been found to cause increased heart rate, enlarged adrenal glands, raised levels of the stress hormone corticosterone and increased aggression and fearfulness. This is no doubt a significant factor in the mortality of battery hens. Research is going on to see if other aspects of chickens' behaviour, such as dust-bathing, are similarly important.

Work is also going on to redesign cages to accommodate relatively small numbers (20-60), allowing nest box access, dust baths and split-level perches so the birds can get away from each other. Other designs allow the birds to scratch around once they have fed and laid their eggs. Material for pecking is also being provided to discourage feather pecking. This results in better plumage.

Still other ideas involve the sort of environment enrichment now being introduced in some zoos. Making the chickens "work" for their food, by having to press a lever for example, provides a more "natural" situation. Indeed, the chickens will do this even when food is freely available.

Does any of this matter? Most people are concerned that animals they exploit for food should not suffer unduly and there may be something in the idea that a society that cares for its members will also care for the animals that it uses for food. And would the poultry workers preter to work in a battery farm or in a more humane alternative? The eggs will cost more no doubt, but they may well taste better (or at any rate seem to!).

(Info from New Scientist).

Scan page 11

strange case of ballotiti

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 439

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →