[Edward Ellis reviews 'Jesus of Montreal' modern-day геenactment…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Edward Ellis reviews 'Jesus of Montreal' modern-day геenactment of the Jesus story is not a very original idea; nor is focussing on the last days of Jesus's life.
Indeed it strikes me as SO hackneyed that anything based on it would have to be very, very good in order not to be really quite excruciating.
'Jesus of Montreal' is not excruciating. Its Jesus is an actor, playing Jesus in a slightly surreal remake of an old mystery play, performed on a hillside in Canada, in French. He gathers four disciples — a Jesus rather down on his luck, it would seem — who are deeply affected by his Strong Silent, and of course, terminally doomed, personality.
There is a pharisee businessman, promising to make a media star out of him, offering ghost writers for his autobiography (which will be mine-tenths invented).
There's a bit where Jesus turns over the tables, and in this case camera stands, because the auditioners for a TV advert are being very nasty indeed to his Mary Magdalene figure. That's the temple of Jerusalem, in case you don't know; (kicking over the tables, that is; presumably not the part where Mary takes off her jeans).
There is, in the end, a crucifiction, predictably enough, with "Jesus' splayed out on an operating table, being relieved of vital organs which will - you guessed - be resurrected, in very twentieth century fashion, in someone else's body.
There is not, thank God— whoops — a Virgin Birth, but probably only because the film deals with the wrong end of Jesus's life. Given half a chance, I'm sure they would have gone for it, thus ineluctably reminding me of Jean Luc Godard's appalling 'Hail Mary' in which a modern-day woman conveniently has a virgin pregnancy, and the audience falls instantly asleep.
"Jesus of Montreal' is not as bad as that, and does indeed have a few laughs in it. Quite a few actually, and probably more if you're able to catch all the religious references, which thankfully I was not.
In line with contemporary practice, of which I by no means disapprove, the films makes no attempt to square its story with plausibility. The performance given by the five actors would indeed by pretty astonishing open-air entertainment, were it remotely possible to change from one elaborate costume to another, and move from a tree top to the centre of a lake, in less than two seconds.
Equally, it is hard to swallow that the priest responsible for commissioning their production would never have seen it, and registered its sacrilegious content, in rehearsal. Still, since the prototype story is somewhat fantastic too, that's legitimate.
Their performance is, in tact, based around a narrative giving possible explanations for Jesus's miracles, including the resurrection. To emphasise the imperturbability of faith, a woman in the audience, convinced that the actor is the real Jesus keeps interrupting the action to warn him of his enemies' plans.
Later, in contrast with the Biblical Jesus's eventual relationship with the mob, the audience rushes to the actor's defence, when the police appear to enforce church orders that the show be stopped. Ironically, this spirited defence leads to the death of 'Jesus': he is badly concussed while strapped - need you guess? - to the cross.
As I say, not excruciating. As I say, I laughed. But Matthew, Mark, Luke and John must be owed a fortune in royalties by now and it will be bad news for lots of film directors, novelists etc if there ever is a day of Judgement. They are sure to sue for breach of copyright.
I'm sure when they first worked the plot out it was bloody good. But even the best plots lose something when they're done to death for two thousand years. one way to