Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why the right won the East German polls

Socialist Organiser no. 439, 22 March 1990 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,474 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

ooke reports Berlin In the eve of last Sunday's election in the German Democratic Republic (GDR), the left-liberal Tageszeitung described them as *the first and last free elections in the GDR." The election results have merely confirmed such a description.

By the usual GDR standards the elections were not just free but super-free. There was no limitation on the right of parties to organise and put up candidates. (In the past, only the ruling Socialist Unity Party and its satellite parties existed - all other parties were banned.) And all voting was in secret. (In the past, voting papers were usually marked in the open, in the presence of an election official.)

Election expenses of the parties participating in the election were paid for by the state. But the parties backed by the West German political parties — the CDU, the CSU, the SPD and the FDP (the West German Tory, Labour and Liberal parties) — enjoyed additional massive resources pumped in by their Western partners.

The elections were therefore *free" in both senses of the word. Any party was free to stand, but the wealthy West German parties also enjoyed the freedom to pump large amounts of money and other material resources into the election campaign. - 30 That the right-wing parties (grouped together in the 'Alliance for Germany') came out on top is hardly surprising.

They had a simple message to get across: "Socialism" had failed, the answer was the social market economy" which had transformed West Germany into a flourishing country. And they had plenty of money to get across such a message.

There were hiccups in the campaign of the Alliance for Germany. One of its leading figures resigned in the week before the elections when it was revealed that he had been an informer for the secret police. A similar shadow was cast across the record of other leading figures in the Alliance on the eve of the elections. And a secret bank account in Luxemburg for one of the parties in the Alliance was also uncovered.

Apart from the wild rhetoric of the Alliance about the alleged virtues of capitalism, a particularly nasty element was added to the Allianee campaign by verbal and physical attacks on left-wingers.

When the West German Chancellor Helmut Kohl spoke in Leipzig on the Wednesday before the election, a mob attacked leftwing students who had been forced to take shelter in the student union of the local university.

Only marginally to the left of the Alliance was the SPD, the German equivalent, albeit a more right-wing one, of the Labour Party. It too promised German unification and praised the avowedmerits of capitalism.

However, it argued for a more drawn-out process of unification and pointed to some of the problems which the extension of capitalist norms to the GDR would involve. As a result, it lost its earlier leading position in the opinion polls: if German unification was the answer, then those who promised it speediest (ie. the Alliance) had the most to offer.

The Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS - the descendant of the old Socialist Unity Party which had ruled the GDR for 40 years) polled some 15%. It accepted defeat in advance. ("A strong opposition for the weak" was one of its main slogans) and picked up support on the basis of the need for a strong parliamentary voice to defend the rights of the socially disadvantaged.

It ran a particularly clever campaign, stressing that it ws a new party in an attempt to throw off the burden of its past. It successfully focused on the fears that many (albeit a minority) of Germans felt about the likely consequences of German unification.

The 'Alliance 90' ', many of whose leading figures had figured prominently in the upheavals of last year, polled badly, scoring less than 3% in the elections.

The mass demonstrations of last year were no longer in evidence. It lacked the backing of wealthy supporters in the West. And it refused equated by the majority of the electorate with "socialism."

to have any truck with the rightwing inspired jingoistic fervour for German unification.

Further to the left were the Greens and the Independent Women's Association (working together on a single platform) and the United Left. Both lacked human resources, and were squeezed out by the PDS in an attempt to win votes from the left of the electorate.

in the realm of the surreal were the Spartacists. The elections were a question of "the existence or non-existence of our (sic) workers' state (sic)", declared the Spartacists. Like the rest of the world's population, the electorate in the GDR regarded them as completely mad.

Why did the right wing parties not merely win the elections, but achieve a landslide victory?

First and foremost because they pointed to the abyss in living standards between West and East Germany and were able to present capitalism as the solution. Hundreds of thousands had already voted with their feet. Now millions more voted with their ballot papers.

Secondly, because of the massive resources at their disposal as a result of the intervention of West German political parties and politicians.

Thirdly, because the East Verman left (in the broadest sense of the word) lacked a clear alternative to the easy slogans of the right wing, suffered from poor organisation, and impaled itself on the question of German unification.

The dominant mood of the electorate was summed up in statements such as "We don't want any more experiments" and "Why invent the wheel a second time?" - in other words, the capitalism of West Germany seemed to work okay, so why try and invent an alternative?

It is a commonplace to say that oppositions do not win elections, governments lose them. Despite the peculiarities of East Germany in the run-up to the polls (the recent emergence of an opposition, the effective absence of a functioning government), this applies to last Sunday's elections as well.

Forty years of repressive rule by damage were equated by the masocialism. He they had, after all, of the electorate with always been told that they lived in the land of "real existing socialism".

It was hardly surprising, therefore, that once the population had a chance to vote for an alternative, the elections should have produced the results which last Sunday's elections did. headaches, dizziness and aching limbs. Backward mental and motor development amongst children is common.

Industry in the GDR, with a few exceptions, is a generation out of date, at least. Antiquated machinery, bad quality raw materials and a workforce lacking in any incentive, produce poor quality commodities at great expense. People are employed to ensure - on paper - 105% fulfilment of the plan target, irrespective of the real level of output.

Queues are everywhere. They are not as long as in the Soviet Union. But you still have to queue for everything. The ongoing flight of East German workers to West Germany has resulted in longer queues - there might be less people now to stand in a queue, but there are even less people to serve them.

Little or nothing works properly. If something does work, it's only a question of time before it breaks down. Trying to get something fixed without resorting to the black market is a futile endeavour.

Less than 10% of homes in the GDR have a telephone. Trying to make a phone call can be a test of human endurance. To phone broad you have to go through the operator, but the line is alwav engaged. To phone from West. Berlin to East Berlin can take up to five hours.

Local public transport is often still in the form of ageing trams which clank slowly through the streets with a maze of tram wires criss-crossing overhead.

Hundreds of thousands of GDR citizens have already abandoned the so-called workers' state. And who can blame them?

For many of those that remain, the future is uncertain. Factories face closure. Landowners expropriated in the late 1940s are returning to claim back their land and property. West German business people tour the country looking for anything worth buying up.

But the response te has not been to rebuild trade union organisation and a socialist political movement. For many the response has been to keep their heads down.

Organising a trade union in the workplace might scare off new investment - so better just to lie low and hope that things turn out OK in the end.

After last Sunday's elections the end has clearly arrived for the GDR. It might not have been a happylend, but it was an inevitable one:

Scan page 10

LO REVIEWS

----- pull-quotes -----

"Forty years of repressive rule by the Socialist Unity Party, a stagnant economy, and massive ecologica damage, were

the Socialist Unity Party, a stagnant economy, and massive ecological

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 439

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →