Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

6 GERMAN REUNIFICATION The left debates German unity

Socialist Organiser no. 439, 22 March 1990 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,937 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Colin Foster su the debate on t West European about German reunification Leftists in West Germany, with a gale of German nationalism whistling around their ears, are fiercely and desperately against reunification.

A coalition of leftist Greens and feminists, the 'United Socialist Party' (neo-Trotskyist/Mandelite), the "Communist League' (ex-Maoist), and sections of the West German Communist Party, has put out a declaration, "Never again Germany!"

"From one day to the next, the Federal Republic has plunged into a German-national delirium unparalleled since the World War.

As the Wall was opened, the politics of the Federal Republic put reunification on the agenda. In Parliament a great-German allparty coalition sang the Deutschlandlied - just like on 4 August 1914, after the beginning of the First World War, and just like on 17 May 1933, on the confirmation of Hitler's declaration of foreign policy.

And the nationalist delirium is tied in with triumph over the 'Evil Empire.

It is true: the system called Teally existing socialism' is finished. Many people, who certainly did not identify with the specific social form of the GDR, the USSR, and so on, but nevertheless had committed themselves to a socialist society and against capitalist exploitation and oppression, feel in their own work and in the public climate the offensive of the right. A massive, partly overt, partly covert campaign is under way, with the message that 'socialism' of any sort, or planned economy, must be excluded from social discussion.

In its place the praises are sung of the performance-oriented society and the market - that is, of an economy where the strong Demonstrators tear down an East German flag prevail. At the same time we see the revival of a new great-German nationalism, revanchism, antisemitism, and increased racism, together with continuing sexism.

Capitalism has been proved victorious in its conflict with the noncapitalist social order of the Eastern Bloc. The strategy of imperialism to do away with that social order has succeeded.

That victory results, however, not only from the strength of the capitalist system, but also from the inner fragility of the bureaucratic regime in the Eastern Bloc states.

"No unification Germany in the foreseeable future can be turned into a socialis unification by a bit of pressure from militant To be against any capitalist unification is to be against unificatio for now at least."

Every attempt to overcome capitalism - from the communist communities in the USA in the 19th century, through the Paris Commune of 1871, to the noncapitalist societies in the Eastern Bloc today - every attempt so tar, capitalism has been able to deteat...

This system has a sweet side only in its metropolises - and even there not for everyone. The problems of capitalism - its conjunctural and structural crises, unemployment, tendencies to impoverish some while yielding maximum riches to others - will remain, even after the social model of the GDR, the USSR and other Eastern Bloc countries is wrecked...

Doubtless similar and identical problems exist in the GDR as in the Federal Republic - and many specific ones, too. But those problems can fundamentally be solved better in the framework of a GDR society, and | without interference by the West German government and corporations...

The anti-colonialist right of self-determination cannot be claimed by the Germans, for they are noone's colony. They should renounce the formal right... in view of the damage caused by the German robber empire of 1871 to 1945. If a new German imperialist colossus should arise, none of the other peoples of Europe, and especially of Eastern Europe, will be able to protect themselves from it.

We propose a demonstration against reunification, for the recognition of the statehood of the GDR and for radical disarmament in the whole of Europe...

Winfried Wolf, writing in the paper of the United Socialist Party, is bitter about the softening of the East German left's attitude to reunification.

"Many people are bowing the knee before the national wave...

With the exception of the United Left, the Independent Women's Federation, and the Green League, all the other formations have bowed to the general opinion and the enormous agitation against anyone who holds to the two states formula or even proposes a socialist perspective. The majority of New Forum is now swimming with the stream...

It has been, and will be, often said against us that 'only saying no', 'only being against', is 'not a meaningful position'. That argument sounds nice, but that is all.

There are projects which one must simply refuse. There are situations in which a socialist and a Marxist must simply be a naysayer - against the majority of the population...

Thus it was at the start of the First World War... It is not quite so bad now, not yet...

So Wolf and his comrades come out for the slogan "Never again Germany! Against the reunification' or 'unification' of the Federal Republic and the GDR!" Why not "Against a capitalist united Germany, for a socialist united Gernany"? Wolf's comrade Manue Kellner explains in a letter to the French socialist weekly Rouge.

"The slogan of a 'united socialist Germany' has absolutely no grip on the political situation, since the only German unity which is realistic today is the creation of a new imperialist and capitalist state, to the detriment of what remains of the social gains in the GDR, and to the detriment of the interests of the working class and the dispossessed on a world scale"

What if a revolutionary working class movement develops in both parts of Germany? "That is remote", , replies Kellner. And even then: "The slogan 'united socialist Germany' will be no more progressive then, for it would be necessary to propose the perspective of the withering away of national states from the start...

Kellner was responding to a debate in Rouge in which three positions have been expressed. Daniel Bensaid and the editorial majority argue "for the unconditional recognition of the right of self-determination for the German people, its right to live in a single state if it SO decides... the withdrawal of all foreign troops... for a socialist united Germany' "It is just and legitimate that the East German workers should define their own conditions for unification: the demilitarisation of the GDR and the Federal Republic, the socialisation of the multinationals... a common system of social welfare and social rights -beginning with the right to work for all - and powers of control and decision of the workers on the orientation of a united Germany.

This approach links our response to the German national question inextricably with the programme of the anti-bureaucratic revolution. It is opposed to any capitalist unification of Germany...

As Kellner indicates, and as must be clear now even if it was not in December when those words were drafted, they reconcile contradictory impulses through wishful thinking. No unification of Germany in the foreseeable future can be turned into a socialist unification by a bit of pressure from militant To be against any capitalist unification is to be against unification, for now at least. To uphold the right of the German people to unite if they wish is to accept capitalist unification.

However, one of the other positions expressed in Rouge is even more optimistic about socialist unification. Gerard Filoche and his co-thinkers declare:

*No-one should imagine that it is necessary to compromise with the bureaucrats for fear of a restoration of capitalism. The bureaucrats are the best allies of the capitalists!

Like their brothers in Poland and Hungary, they are selling the na tionalised economy to themselves and to foreign capital. Only the workers, by their mobilisation and self-organisation, can oppose this, defend their gains, and open the way to real socialism..

The mass movement has mont wine victory Lothar de Ma Germany's Prime Minister question the division of Germa Into two STates he whole org decided at Yalta is threatened.

so much the better ve against that order.. The task revolutionaries is to be with t masses for German unity. wor ing so that it will put into questi not onlv the Stalinist order in t East but also the capitalist ord in the West. Thus can be creat a dynamic to unity Germany on a authentic socialist basis The riaht to German unity is t conditional: Kon is for it oniv that capitalism safeguarded.

Probably the whole of the left. Socialist Organiser included - ha exaggerated November Then, there was a mass mood East Germany for *bette socialism". But it produced n strong workers' self-organisation; large part of the mood, evidently was illusions in the possibility o new leaders ike Modrow reformit the system from above.

..we firmly reject notion of so-called fundamental gains which confer on the Stalinist regimes some superiority in relation to the overall capitalist system."

When those illusions were sha tered, the East German worker quickly turned the othe available and 'realistic' way for ward: union with West German Only three months later, Filoche position piece reads like the word

Scan page 7

GERMAN REUNI of the CDU becomes East of delirium.

Helene Viken and Francois Dietrich have a third view. They argue - rightly, I think - that the German left has allowed its thinking to be depressed and distorted by its justified hatred and fear of German nationalism and German capitalist triumphalism. They go on "Some people reckon that Gerwas some sort of "workers' state" seems to play a part in German leftists' feeling that they are in the midst of a terrible debauch of reaction, where the only honourable socialist course is to say no clearly and sharply. Yet some left tendencies who believe that the GDR was never any sort of "workers' state" have also been sharply against organisation of the popular masses... In this context, it is understandable that the prospect of German reunification, in one form or another, is a popular ° Militants who stand for the proletarian revolution working in the present situation in East Germany should not, however, campaign for reunification. They should sions: East German face the depredations man capital without and integration into law and conditions ma least some protection. workers will of West Gerreunification, Nest German ly well give at Britain started by not mentioning the question of reunification at all; then came out against reunification (or seemed to do so); and now has a position 'neither for nor against'. New Forum of "failing to give a lead to the 50 percent of demonstrators still opposed to reunification" and approvingly quotes an East German socialist: "We are against reunification because it will bring unemployment and homelessness. But we are not against a united socialist Germany under the workers"

More recently, however, (SW, 17 March) Socialist, Worker has argued: "The left needs a strategy along the lines of 'neither Kohl nor Modrow, but the class struggle* because whether Germany remains divided or becomes unified the ruling class will try to make workers pay for the further integration of the economy into the world market... The defence of workers' rights and conditions should be the main question, not unqualified opposition to unification"

Socialist Organiser wrote back in November: "Should Germany be reunified? Yes". But: "To win democratic rights the East German workers should look to their own struggle, not to what the West German capitalists may grant them.

Therefore, while we say reunify Germany, we say more than this: we say, reunify Germany on the basis of workers' liberty East and West!" In a more recent summingup (SO, 1 March) we called "for workers' unity, defence of workers' living standards, democratic rights throughout GerMorkers' gains across Germany".. and levelling-up of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 439

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →