Where we come from - a where he comes from
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Tories the run in Mid-Staffordshire. Photo: n Harris ITH CHEMICAL -BOMBS ARE DESTROVINA publicly justified Saddam's Demonstration against the Farzad Bazoft (Photo: Paul Iraqi regime after the hanging of Herrmann, Protile). Healy's WRP executions of Iraqi CP members. Alan Johnson spoke to the Socialist Organiser AGM The Labour Party Policy Review commits the Labour Party to managing the profit system. To making capitalism fair, to make capitalism efficient, to make capitalism work for the workers.
We think that it is a dream. It's a dream which, every time a Labour government has tried to make it a reality, has turned into a nightmare for working people.
Supporters of the paper Socialist Organiser do not stand alone in this view. We did not stand alone in the seventies when the last Labour government was acting out the last In those awful years of Wilson and Callaghan, of IMF diktats and cuts in social services of a lahour government and Tory policies, in VUTO ME DUVICE OVI those years voices more influential than ours protested.
I can remember how a Labour MP reported back to his Constituency Party — in Bedwellty, I think it was, in Wales — he said:
"It is not the task of Labour to salvage and re-establish capitalism." The cuts in public expenditure, including in the health service introduced by Healey, were denounced by this fiery Welsh MP as one of the most reactionary ever by a Labour government"
This MP — predicted to go a long way in the party, if a little longwinded - was especially mocking of the Labour government's policy towards the City. He spoke in words I think John Smith and Gordon Brown would do well to listen to today:
*They treat the City of London as if it were some kind of winnable Tory marginal constituency. They think, generation in, generation out, that there is some deal that can be reached with people who are our sworn ideological enemies. The sooner my right honourable friends understand that, the sooner we shall have policies we need if we are to have a Labour government we can be proud of."
But his words were not heeded. And this Labour government staggered on from one crisis to another - cutting social services, holding down pay, doubling unemployment - all the bitter fruits of trying to manage the profit system.
Well, our Labour MP, a member ot the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, could hardly contain himself: he regularly broke the Neil Kinnock campaigning with Sylvia John Harris Labour whip, and said: "We have a government totally operating Tory policies."
Our man, who used to amuse the left with his witty speeches at the Tribune collection was especially furious when Captain Callaghan advised workers to cross picket lines: "the only reason we've come so far, the reason that children stay in school after 9 and we are educated is that we had picket lines. The party must remind the leadership of where we come from or we die as a movement."
Well, the party did remind the leadership as our Labour MP advised - the movement for democracy, the campaign for Tony Benn, these were not the inventions of papers like Socialist Organiser, they were the organised explosion of a gaping wound in the Labour Party, a wound inflicted by a Labour government unaccountable and out of control, and making the working class pay for the crisis of the profit system.
When the SDP split from Labour it wasn't just Socialist Organiser who said 'good riddance to bad rubbish'. Our MP, who by now had risen high indeed, was poised to be party leader, said the same: he ridiculed the Gang of Four. He said: *They want a kindly capitalism, a gentle market economy, an air-conditioned jungle." Listen to that phrase — an "air-conditioned jungle" • It's a very good phrase, but here's the rub doesn't it just sum up the Labour Party's Policy Review; the jungle of the free market, of the monopolies and the junk bonds will be air-conditioned by a few grants here..a few penalties there...a bit of R&D money.
It's the same old dream...the same old nightmare.
But our MP - by now Party leader - has undergone a remarkable Road to Downing Street conversion; now he wants us to embrace the profit system and make it work. He wants to do that which he once said was an idle dream — to salvage and re-establish capitalism.
Now Neil has every right to change his mind, every right to disavow his past, but he does not have the right to harry and chase and ridicule those who have not renounced their ideas.
Many in the Labour Party continue to believe in a fundamental transformation of British society, a revolution in the distribution of power and wealth in the interest of working people and their families. It must remain possible for those party members to retain these beliefs whilst working for a Labour The party leader would like those voices to be stilled, he allows Frank Field to push him into silencing those voices. For our part, we will quietly remind Neil of his own words to Callaghan: "The party must remind the leadership of where we come from or we die as a movement."