Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why solidarity was

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan pp. 11–12 · Martin Thomas · about 2,459 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Labour's drift to intolerance back us. There is not going to be a repeat of the miners' strike. From the collections and meetings we have done we can see the support is there.

"Other workers know that if we win this one then it will be easier for them to win their own battles. The mood is changing in this country. At last people are beginning to realise that Thatcher is beatable."

Poole and Willis wasted that support, Tragically. they may well have strengthened Thatcher by allowing the Tories to win a battle in which our side was so strong. What was needed was an escalation of the dispute along the lines argued by the Liverpool crews at their 7,000-strong evidence (43 defence witnesses to two from the prosecution) they duly found all eight Broad Left supporters guilty. Their "crimes"? Using official premises and branch funds to produce Broad Left election literature. For this they are all to be thrown out of the union.

Not content with this, the NEC has also decided to investigate the activities of the CPSA Deputy General Secretary, John Macreadie, for his role in the whole affair!

CPSA members will not be surprised at the outcome of the inquiry. Like the witch-hunt currently going on in the Labour Party we do not expect justice from the union or Labour bureaucrats. However all is not lost. CPSA, like the Labour Party, has seen attacks like this defeated in the past.

The key to defeating the right-wing lies in taking our arguments to the membership as a whole. Bureaucrats are never (or very rarely) beaten by playing them at their own game; they are beaten though when they are exposed to the rank and file. In the case of the Newcastle eight, this should be done by waging a massive awareness campaign throughout the union's 850 plus branches, this campaign to culminate in winning their appeal at the union's conference.

We should all be confident that this can be achieved, by comparing the right's inactivity over issues like pay, Agencies, technology, etc., to their fanaticism in rooting out any left opposition. Members will draw the correct conclusions.

Already this has been successful in other areas, notably in the Wales & South West region, where the NEC backed off from taking action against regional officials who opposed the poll tax and supported the ambulance workers. This happened because of rank and file support for the region's officials.

The rank and file hold the key. We should avoid any talk of using the courts, mobilise the members and take our case to the conference; that will see the eight unconditionally reinstated.

The key reason why solidarity action was needed to help the ambulance workers win is spelt out this month in Labour Research.

*The dispute by 19,000 ambulance workers has been costing the public £2. million a week, easily outstripping the amount needed for a settlement."

January's edition of Nursing Times explained why:

*The cost of settling the dispute this year with a couple of extra per cent would be minimal. And because any award would be for last year's pay round, it could have no impact on this year's "going rate' , which is already well over the much-quoted 6.5%. The government's real object now is to resist any long-term pay formula and, even more important, not to appear to capitulate in the face of industrial action."

With the Tories digging in their heels, the ambulance workers were unlikely to shift them with their own efforts.

Many ambulance workers shied away from facing up to the logic of the government's tough stance. They felt that it would be too difficult to organise solidarity action which would be against the Tory laws on solidarity action. Poole, playing on their professional pride, encouraged them to believe that they could win on their own.

But the tragedy was that the dispute provided the best opportunity in ages of successfully defeating the anti-union From back page chooses to force a by-election and fight as an independent, the NEC can now "within the rules" dismiss the properly selected candidate, Paul Davies, in favour of its own nominee.

But it's not enough to deal with Birkenhead. The NEC looks. backward when it comes to policies, but displays foresight when it comes to a witch-hunt.

The reselection process in nearby Wallasey has not yet even started. But it is possible that Lol Duffy, who 1987 reduced a Tory Minister's majority from 6,708 to just 279 votes, would once again be chosen as the Labour candidate.

This accounts for the NEC's decision to investigage not just the alleged irregularities in Birkenhead, but also the activities of Wirral District Labour Party and those of laws. The ambulance workers had precedented levels of popular supp A resolute call for solidarit ac would have stood a good cl ance defeating the Tories and their aws. Months ago we were offered 9 over 18 months (1.4.89-30.9.9 that offer is back on the table ! then with an extra 7.9% for 6 months (1.10.90-31.3.91) but because the 7.9% is only for 6 months it is only worth 4% a year. Thus the actual rise over two years is only 13%; this is hardly staggering! There is an extra 2% available for local productivity, but do we want 2% extra by cutting jobs or services? And there is no pay formula. Afte a six month dispute we have an offer which does not even match the inflation rate and no guarantee for future years.

We need a formula to ensure that we never need to take industrial action ever again.

Merseyside Ambulance Works Socialist Organiser.

Lol Duffy is a left-winger and may have some links with Socialist Organiser. Walworth Road can't have this. Therefore, once Wirral DLP is under 'investigation" the parliamentary selection in Wallasey may have to wait perhaps long enough for a suitable candidate to be imposed.

But investigations may not go on indefinitely, and therefore "double insurance" is required. This is why the NEC is looking into Socialist Organiser.

Now Socialist Organiser is a small body, loosely organised around a newspaper. Its socialist credentials are beyond reproach. Its sympathisers - like many other socialists in the party - may hold minority views. But they are loyal members of the Labour Party, an asset to it, and they will, I understand, be happy to make any adjustments to their activity which the along with that line of argument.

I can understand the Tories screaming about it, but I can't understand the Labour leadership. If their argument is right, that Miliant is only a tiny rump, then how come this tiny rump is able to organise on such a massive scale?

In fact it is mainly ordinary people out on the streets who have seen the example of what has happened in Eastern Europe and have decided to go out and have a go here. If Kin-. nock were to identify himself with those people who are raising strong objections to the poll tax, rather than throwing his weight behind Maggie Thatcher condemning a few militants, then he'd do a better service to the working class.

In inquiry is going to take place into the accusations against Arthur Scargill and Peter Heathfield. I suppose we've got to be seen to be putting our own house in order.

I have every confidence that Scargill will have an answer for the charges. I had hoped for something more positive from the union executive to support the president at a time when he is under attack, not for what he has done, but because of what he stands for. But now we have to await the outcome of the inquiry.

Paul Whetton is a ton NUM, South NEC may require.

This, however, would rather interfere with the NEC's likely plans of disqualifying Lol Duffy. Hence the NEC may deem it necessary to build up Socialist Organiser into a Merseyside bug-bear, and on this basis proceed against it.

Action of this kind must been seen in the context of the current NEC policy of increasing its own authoritarian stranglehold over the party. Labour's establishment has banned CLPs from selecting the candidate of their choice, has sought to disqualify sitting left-wing MPs, and has pushed through changes which make MPs and the leadership less accountable.

These methods are allen to Labour's democratic tradition and should be condemned. Members must be alerted to the drift away from party democracy and towards intolerance and must mobilise against it.

Scan page 12

ORGANISER Marchers demand abolition of Article 6 which guarantees the Mikhail Gorbachev has trated and autocratic force is now the only way to get the renewal he wants in the As we go to press on Tuesday 13 March, the USSR's semi-quasielected parliament, the Supreme Soviet, is expected to vote through drastic presidential powers for Gorbachev, including powers to declare a state of emergency, rule by decree, and veto parliamentary legislation.

It will be the third phase of Gorbachev's policy since he came to office in 1985. First he tried a drive for more efficiency, more accoun tability, less corruption and more discipline, broadly within the framework of the Stalinist command economy:

This produced a small spurt in production in 1986, but no real success against the corrupt, cumbersome and byzantine web of bureaucratic inertia, developed over decades.

So Gorbachev moved to a second phase: a simultaneous drive for economic reform and for a limited opening-up of the political system. The opening-up would undermine and expose the most corrupt and sluggish bureaucrats, and thus enable market-oriented reforms to become reality rather than just good intentions on paper.

That second phase has shaken up the bureaucracy, and enabled Gorbachev to weed out large numbers of his opponents from the top ranks. But it has no brought economic success. It ha brought chaos and progressive disintegration.

The USSR's external empire in Eastern Europe has vanished. Russia's internal empire within the USSR is crumbling.

On Sunday 11 March, Lithuania declared itself independent. The other Baltic states, Latvia and Estonia, are likely to move the same way. On Friday 9th, the local parliament in Georgia declared 1legal the treaties joining it to the USSR and demanded immediate negotiations on independence. More radical Georgian nationalists said this demand was inadequate, and promised to set up an independent government immediately.| The independence movement is also gathering strength in Ukraine; there are strong demands Moldavia for union with Romania; and in recent months the central government has at times lost control of large parts of Azerbaijan.

This forest-fire of nationalism threatens to break up the USSR, and curtail Moscow's rule to nothing more than its heartlands of Russia and Siberia. The potential breakaway areas include some of the USS's most important industrial centres, sources of raw materials, and agricultural areas. It is hard to imagine that Gorbachev or any other Soviet leader will let them go peacefully.

On the other hand, neither Gorbachev nor any other Soviet leader has any effective means to stop them at present.

The economic reforms so far have brought chaos, destroying the coherence of the old command system without putting anything effective in its place. Industrial production went down about 1.7 per cent (on Western estimates) in 1989. Even when goods are produced, they don't reach the counters.

According to David Lascelles in the Financial Times, *The economy is rapidly becoming two-tier: the rouble-based state system overlaid by a grey economy where goods are exchanged for barter or hard currency...Every factory now holds back part of its production to exchange for other goods. In shops, the best items are kept under the counter for the same reasons.' Television production, for example, was cranked up by 20 per cent last year; but the televsion shop in a political monopoly of the CPSU political machine. In these days when CP members campaign for election with such promises as a return to the glorious traditions of pre-revolutionary entrepreneurship", the Stalinists no longer have such a machine.

The only way forward from the chaos then - so Gorbachev and his allies argue — is to establish a strong regime on a new basis, with dictatorial personal power for Gorbachev which will enable him to act independently of the crumbling Stalinist party machine, push on which it started. It is now at an end. The masses had overthrown the old feudal order and built the outline of a new order; it remained for Napoleon to organise it under a stable, strong state structure.

The masses have not made their revolution in the USSR. Gorbachev's predecessor is less Napoleon than Emperor Joseph II of Austria, who in the same period tried to abolish feudalism and push aside the feudal lords from above.

Whatever Gorbachev's new Tony Benn MP comment on the Labour Party National Executive's decision to "investigate" Socialist Organiser 've read Socialist Organiser for many years, and I believe that such papers are an important part of building a broad movement for socialism.

I think the purpose of the new moves is to separate the electoral machine from any interest in I used to think the target was the lett, then the unions, then the party, but now I just don't think they want any discussion of any kind at all.

They think that people on the left have nowhere else to go so they're goint any of them and yee they're raiding deep into the Owen/ Heseltine territory - that's what they think.

It isn't tremendously impressive. As a strategy it's disreputable. But I think that's the explanation for what the Labour leaders are doing. now.

Every time they clobber the left they seem to go up in the polls. That's the beginning and end of it. They'll do fund-raising outside the party, get the support of Robert Maxwell, and hope this will carry them in. I don't think they're interested in politics, let alone socialism. Politics, for them, are a subsidiary of advertising.

Intolerance By Vladimir CLPD f you are a left winger, you can't become a Labour MP.

This is the intended outcome of the new powers which the present Labour Party National Executive Committee has awarded itself.

As of last week, the NEC can remove the endorsed parliamentary candidate whenever there is a by-election - to be replaced with someone who they favour. This decision seems to be directly related to the current situation in Birkenhead.

If the NEC's "investigation team" by any chance finds insufficient grounds for a pretext for a rerun, or if Paul Davies is chosen once again, and if Frank Field Turn to page 11

----- pull-quotes -----

What the deal add up to

More on the USSR: page 8

An attem to kil politic party

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →