Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Broad Left supporters expelled from CPSA 3y Sam…]

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 11 · Mark Serwotka · about 1,282 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Broad Left supporters expelled from CPSA 3y Sam Eaton he ambulance workers have voted to accept the pay deal cooked up by Roger Poole and NHS management.

As the Merseyside ambulance workers emplain on this page, the final settlement looks very similar to the original offer rejected by ambulance workers in September last year. Poole has managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

The ambulance workers have had one of the best opportunities presented to any group of workers over the last few years to decisively defeat the Tories, they have had massive, overwhelming popular support. But that support has been wasted. Why?

A big part of the blame for the outcome of the dispute lies with the strategy pursued by the leadership. They did not adopt an approach that could unite ambulance workers and mobilise the huge reservoir of popular support through solidarity strike action.

The ambulance workers' own ranks were divided from day one. For most of the dispute there were huge gaps between different regions. In London, for instance, the vast majority of ambulance workers were locked out or suspended, and a significant minority took strike action, whereas in other areas crews were taking very limited action and more or less working normally. The TUC's 14 point guidelines were never evenly and universally applied.

Ambulance management were allowed to take the lead and dictate the scale of the action by controlling the number of enspensions.

Even when, under rank and file pressure, Poole unveiled a new polcy of "total non co-operation' in the last weeks of the dispute, the initiative was left in the hands of the management.

As a delegate to the national ambulance stewards conference on February 14th explained:

*Even if the suspension drive succeeded, there is a danger that the tactic will lead simply to lock-outs, with inMerthyr Tydfil DSS 23 votes to one, the National Executive Committee of the CPSA has decided to expel eight Broad Left supporters from the union.

The eight, all from the union's largest branch at Newcastle Central Office (DHSS), are the victims of a vicious political witch-hunt which has become an everyday fact of life in the union.

Newcastle Central Office branch, representing 5,000 members, has always been vital in the running of the CPSA.

Its votes in elections and at the union's conference have at times been the deciding factor in many important periods for the union. For the last two decades it has been regarded as a stronghold for the left in the union, and the Militant in particular.

Two years ago, the so-called Charter Group (right-wing/Stalinist alliance)

took control of CPSA, and emboldened by their seizure of power, the demoralisation of defeats for the union, and in line with witch-hunts taking place throughout the labour movement, they decided to act.

Using allegations from a few right-wingers in the branch, the NEC suspended the entire Newcastle Branch Committee and replaced them with a number of full-time union officials to run the branch. The following two years then saw these full-timers attempt to build a case that would stick. At an enormous cost to the union (the full-timers were claiming up to f40 per night expenses), and at the expense of providing any sort of service to the Newcastle members, they duly set about discrediting dedicated, long-serving union activists. An 'independent' tribunal was established, this though lost a number of its hand-picked members who found the whole issue too much to stomach.

However, after hearing all the adequate emergency cover. AS one steward from Lincolnshire put it, The aim should be to get locked in, not locked out'. Unless the unions can secure emergency cover, if necessary by occupying the stations, then serious splits would open up in ambulance workers' ranks. "The alternative - a strike with tion, and stands a better chance of stiffening it in the shire counties, where it has been weakest than calling on hesitant crews to get themselves suspended and locked out."

But Poole held out, refusing to even consider the option of calling a national ballot for an indefinite strike with emergency cover Poole was not averse to throwing the odd red herring around. He used the mistaken calls for a strike without emergency cover by a small number of crews to confuse the issues, making it more difficult to get over the rational case for a strike with cover.

But, because of their lack of industrial muscle, the ambulance workers could not have hoped to win on their own. As Eric Roberts of North West London NUPE explained in January:

'We won't win on our own. We've never believed that we could.

"We're going to need solidarity action from other groups of workers. 30 January is just the start.

"We know other trade unionists will demonstration on January 30th.

*Today's demonstration is only a starting point for building up the campaign. We haven't got the muscle to win this dispute by ourselves. So the next stage is to urge the leadership of the TUC to call a one-day general strike and that's what we're going to be campaigning for."

Poole and Willis rejected calls for serious solidarity strike action. Poole played on illusions that the ambulance workers could win on their own. His approach was summed up by a delegate to the stewards' conference:

"Only a few voices pointed to an alternative way of escalating the dispute: through appeals for solidarity strike action. Poole directly attacked this view by arguing that it was a cop out'. 'We are in control of this dispute if we lose then it will be our fault' , said Poole, adding: "We can't go blaming Willis if we lose this one'."

It's not surprising that in this situacon the solidarity action that did take place was the result of rank and file pressure, sadly from a minority of ambulance workers. As Eric Roberts explains: "It was our initiative to call for solidarity strikes on 6 December. The march and rally we called has forced the TUC into taking action.

*Without that pressure " have here in my hand...

ranks they would never have called this 15-minute action.

The problem was that there was no organised force amongst ambulance workers, or in the broader trade union movement, that could have taken on the task of building effective wide-scale solidarity action in the face of opposition from Poole and Willis.

In the ambulance dispute we saw a glimpse of the potential strength of organised labour in the widespread response to the 30th January protest. What was missing was an organisation of the rank and file across industry that could have effectively harnessed that potential.

The task of every activist in the unions is to build such a movement. WEEK A miner's dien cople are really beginning to understand the poll tax and see what it is all about. And I'm not sure it's not tied in with what's happening in Eastern Europe.

People have seen on their screens. what can be achieved when they are united and committed. Maggie Thatcher has been throwing her arms up in delight at what's happened in Eastern Europe, but she may well find herself not SO delighted when she faces the same action at home.

We've seen that the people, if they're united and committed enough, can topple Causescu. They can topple the Berlin Wall. The poll tax is a small and insignificant pimple compared to those tasks.

We've seen the state machinery swing into action against the poll tax protests and we've seen the usual attempts to blame it all on Militant and the "Trots". Much to his discredit, Kinnock has gone

----- pull-quotes -----

East Europe WALT ONES-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →