Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tough guys an strong women

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 713 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

reviews 'The War of the Roses' and 'Sea Love"

Strong women have men by the leading strings in two new movies in town, 'Sea of Love' and The War of the Roses'. Former screen tough guys Al Pacino and Michael Douglas don't seem to know what hit them.

In 'Sea of Love' , Frank Keller (Pacino), a cop with twenty years' service, gets involved with Helen, a suspect in the string of lonelyhearts murders he is investigating. Helen (Ellen Barkin) is a sexual magnet to Pacino; he can't resist her, despite the risk to his life.

The film is competent enough as a thriller, but there is something off putting and queasy in the character of Frank.

Thrillers are usually about crimes or conspiracies, with the main characters either cops or agents of some kind. In romantic thrillers, the heroine was rewarded for her terrors by the love of her knight. His armour might have been tarnished, but he was true blue underneath.

That formula is well past its sellby date now. No-one believes that the cops or the CIA are 'nice, however necessary they may believe them to be. In movies now, we don't want the cop to get the girl. He's no catch.

This is particularly true in Sea of Love' '. Pacino's Frank is a mess, a drunken, belligerent, self pitying manipulator who's waiting around to be rescued. Everything about Frank signals desperation, but he's gone slack; he won't lift a finger to save himself. Self pity has sapped his strength.

Pacino is around fifty. Frank's face looks lived in, and by a bad tenant at that, someone who leaves the beds unmade and the taps dripping. Frank's self pity oozes out of him like sweat. He complains when people keep pressing him to retire; euthanasia seems more fitting.

And he's supposed to attract Barkin, a sexual powerhouse of a woman who's got it all together! The only way this can play is for her to fall for him out of pity, by sensing his desperation, his need. But it isn't shown that way. Helen's attraction to Pacino is just a given, not explained, not backed up.

For all her independence and style at the start, Helen is reduced to the role of mother figure, nurturer and rescuer of feeble Frank. It's a shame. We don't want to see a strong woman kowtowing to this pathetic basket case; Frank doesn't deserve her.

The film gives aid and comfort to the flabby, never-grown-up, middle aged male who, despite paunch. smoker's cough and incipient alcoholism, can kid himself he's really a tough guy underneath, and thus deserving of a woman of Barkin's stature.

Women turn the tables towards revenge as wife Barbara Rose (Kathleen Turner) dishes it out to movie husband Oliver (Michael Douglas) in "The War of the Roses' Oliver Rose isn't self pitying like Frank Keller, but he's just as pathetic, a man who only walks tall because a woman is propping him up.

Oliver is fatuously complacent. He thinks he has it all, a lovely wife, two children at college, a beautiful home, worldly success. Alas, things in the Rose household are about to go very sour. Barbara's needs, kept down for so long, are about to surface and she turns out to be as determined and as malevolent as the shark in 'Jaws' The disintegration of a marriage about to begin.

The film should be Barkin and Pacino come out with a bad case of the so whats?'. Sure, marriage can be hell, and people do crazy things to get revenge, but the savagery in this film is too cartoonish to be taken seriously. It's meant to be black comedy, so the laughs aren't unexpected, but the cautionary tale falls flat.

The Roses' pampered lifestyle may be partly to blame; the sufferings of the rich never seem all that bad, do they? But Turner and Douglas also seem to be playing it tongue in cheek. They're having a ball brawling and fighting, but they don't convince. Barbara and Oliver are like Ken and Barbie dolls, pretty to look at, but empty, empty. Tragedy could not touch them.

All the same, it's good to see a full frontal attack on male complacency, even if the tone is slightly

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →