Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Paul gnazio Silone, who died in 1978, was…]

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 1,764 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Paul gnazio Silone, who died in 1978, was one of the greatest socialist novelists of our time. Until 1929 he was also one of the central personalities of the Communist Party of Italy and a key figure in its foreign underground work.

Silone - his real name was Secundo Tranquilli — was born on May Day 1900, the son of peasants in Pescina dei Marsi. He left this area at the age of 15 after the great earthquake of Avezzano which had claimed the lives of his mother and two brothers. The impressions of this early part of his life are contained in a number of his stories and novels.

At 17 he joined the socialist youth and soon became the editor of its weekly paper Avanguardia. He became the leading figure in the anti-war youth movement. With the split in the Italian Socialist Party in 1921, Silone was one of those who left to found the Communist Party, whose Young Communist League he was to lead.

Silone was never leadins hinker in the party. Above all he was an organiser and journalist from 1922 he was editor of the Party's paper Il Lavoratore, though that work was soon interrupted by Mussolini's rise to power in October of that year, A critical moment in his political development came, in his own opinion, when in May 1927 he and Togliatti participated as representatives of the PCI in an extraordinary session of the Englarged Executive of the Comintern. The incident is recorded in the collection "Emergency Exit* the first meeting we attended we had the impression that we had come too late. It was held in a small office of the Comintern, and the German Ernst Thälmann was presiding. He immediately began reading a draft resolution against Trotsky to be presented in plenary session.

The resolution violently condemned a certain document sent by Trotsky to the political office of the Russian Communist Party. At that meeting of the senior convent the Russian delegation consisted of Stalin, Rykov, Bukharin and Manuilsky, which was extremely unusual.

At the end of the reading Thälmann asked us if we agreed with the draft resolution. The Finn, Ottomar Kuusinen, the future Quisling of 1941, did not find it strong enough.

Since no-one else asked for the floor, after consulting with Togliatti, I apologised to those present for having come late and for not having had a chance to read the document in question.

Actually," Thälmann candidly remarked, "we haven't seen it either."

Confronted with this all-toofrank reply, I preferred to doubt my ears and repeated my objection in other terms.

*It may well be," I said, **that the Trotsky document should be condemned, but obviously we can't condemn it until we read it"

"But we haven't read it either," replied Thälmann. "And neither have most of the delegates here, except for the Russians.

Thälmann was speaking German and his words were being translated into Russian for Stalin and into French for two or three of us. The answer translated to me seemed so incredible that I had words with the translator.

*It's impossible that Thälmann should have said that, " I said. "Please give me his answer again, word for word!* At this point, Stalin intervened. He was standing at one side of the room and seemed to be the only calm and unruffled person in the group.

"The political office of the party has thought it best not to translate Trotsky's document and distribute it to the delegates of the International Executive," Stalin said, "because there are various allusions in it to the policy of the Soviet Government in China."

(Stalin was lying. The mysterious document was published abroad later by Trotsky himself in a pamphlet entitled Problems of the Chinese Revolution and, as everyone can now see, it contains no state secrets, but is a violent attack on the China policy of Stalin and the Communist International.

In a speech on April 5 1927, before the Moscow Soviet, Stalin had exalted Chiang Kai-shek and confirmed his faith in the Guomindang, and that was barely a week before the famous anti-Communist about-face of the Chinese Nationalist head and his party...the Communists had been suddenly expelled from the Guomindang, and some tens of thousands of their followers were killed in Shanghai and Wuhan. It is therefore understandable that Stalin did not want a debate about his mistake and tried to protect himself behind "state secrets").

Ernst Thälmann asked me if Stalin's explanation satisfied me., "I don't dispute the right of the political office to keep any document secret," I said. "But I don't understand how others can be required to condemn an unknown document." Ignazio Silone This is unheard of," Kuusinen was shouting, red in the face, "that in the citadel of the world revolution we still have such petit bourgeois!"

The only person who remained calm and imperturbable was Stalin. He said: "If even one delegate is against the draft resolution, it must not be presented." Then he added, *Perhaps the Italian comrades are not well informed about our internal situation. I suggest we postpone the meeting till tomorrow and that someone here spend the evening with our Italian comrades and explain the situation to them.

The Bulgarian Kolarov was given this unpleasant task.

"Let's be frank," he said with a smile. "Maybe you think I've read the document. No, I haven't read the document. Shall I tell you the whole truth? The document doesn't interest me. Shall I tell you more? Even if Trotsky were to send me a copy in secret, I would refuse to read it. My dear Italian friends, this is not a question of documents. I know that Italy is a country of academics, but this is not academy. Here we are, in the thick of a struggle for power between two rival groups in the Russian central directorate. Which of these groups do we want to line up with? That's the question. Documents have nothing to do with it. It's not a question of finding the historical truth about the failure of the revolution in China. It's a power struggle between two opposed and irreconcilable groups. We have to choose. And I've already made up my mind. I'm for the majority group. Whatever the minority does or says, I repeat that I'm for the majority. Documents don't interest me. We're not in an academy here.

He refilled our glasses with tea and looked at us like a schoolteacher at two obstreperous boys. "Have I made myself clear?" he asked, looking straight at me.

"Yes," I answered, "very clear." "Have I persuaded you?" he asked me. "No," I answered. "Why not?" he wanted to know.

*I'd have to explain why I'm against Fascism," I said.

Kolarov pretended to get indignant, while Toghatti expressed his opinion in more moderate but no less decisive terms. "You can't come out for the majority or minority per se," he said. "You can't ignore the background of the political question."

Kolarov listened to him with a benevolent smile of compassion. "You're still too young," he told us as he accompanied us to-the door. "You don't understand yet what politics is all about."

The following day Silone and Togliatti repeated their position and it was now supported by the Frenchman Albert Treint and the Swiss Jules. Humbert-Droz. Again Stalin intervened: 'The draft resolution is withdrawn, " he declared.

At first Silone believed that Stalin had been generous in withdrawing the resolution because it failed to be agreed unanimously. But he soon learned better. On his return journey he passed through Berlin: / (There) I read in the papers that the Comintern Executive had censured Trotsky severely for his report on the events in I went to the headquarters of the German Communist Party and asked Thälmann for an explanation *This is untrue, " I said bitterly. *You know they didn't vote the censure." But he explained that in critical caes the statutes of the International authorised the President to adopt any measure in the name of the Executive. They had waited for us to leave Moscow to vote in our name on a text we had not approved. This also explained Stalin's impassivity before the senior convent.

During my few days of enforced idleness in Berlin, while I was waiting for my false documents to be put in order so that I might return to Italy, I read in the papers that the American, Hungarian and Czech Communist Parties had vigorously blasted ronsky so th asked Thälmann, mysterious document has finally been made public?"

"No," he answered. "But you should learn what Communist discipline means from the l American, Hungarian and Czech Communists.

In Spring 1929 Silone asked for an unlimited leave of absence from the PCI on medical grounds and moved to Davos on doctor's orders. He did not resume political activity, and in 1931 he officially broke his links with the Communist Party, though he continued to give aid to the resistance.

For a period Silone retreated to a position which said the problem was the influence of the Russians; better concern oneself with the problems of one's own 'national' class struggle. While a few of his collaborators in the underground, like Pietro Tresso, understood the real significance of the degeneration of the Russian Revolution and the Comintern and became Trotskyists, Silone was to draw closer to the Catholic Church.

It was in Davos that he wrote his first book, the brilliant anti-Fascist novel 'Fontamara'. It is the story of the development of an anti-Fascist and socialist consciousness among South Italian peasants.

This book brought Silone worldwide fame.

He remained in Switzerland through the rest of the period of fascism in Italy, not returning until 1944. In this period he wrote number of novels and short stories: "Seed Beneath the Snow', 'School for Dictators', Handful of Blackberries' and "Bread and Wine'.

This last book, which became almost as popular as 'Fontamara', expressed in novel form Silone's growing acceptance of Christian values.

The hero, an underground organiser disguised as a priest and forced therefore to carry out some priestly duties, emb: tes the two currents' Cor .unism and Christianity - that Silone saw as expressions of humanity. Significantly the peasants in the novel warm more to the Christian than the Communist side.

Silone's political development continued rightwards. He joined the Democratic Socialists after the war; then when the party split into the Nenni (left) and Saragat (right) factions under the pressure of the Cold War, Silone left the party. But his sympathies seem to have been with the right.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →