[This was not camouflage for the enemy but…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
This was not camouflage for the enemy but education for the workers' vanguard. He explained it theoretically as we, following him, tried to explain it in popular language at the trial.
Again, in April 1917, refuting the accusations of Plekhanov and others who accused the Bolsheviks of "anarchism, Blanquism and so forth" , Lenin once again explained the question, for the benefit, as he said, of "those who really want to think and learn" . Into a few paragraphs he compresses a profound thesis which every member of the workers' vanguard ought to learn by heart. He wrote:
Socialism democratic movement and programme...can *9 absolutely insured myself in my theses against skipping over the still existing peasant movement, or the petty-bourgeois movement in general, against any playing at "seizure of power' by a workers" government, against any kind of Blanquist adventurism; for I directly referred to the experience of the Paris Commune. And this experience, as we know, and as was shown in detail by Marx in 1871 and by Engels in 1891, absolutely excluded Blanquism, absolutely ensured the direct, immediate and unconditional rule of the majority and the activity of the masses, but only to the extent of the conscious and intelligent action of the majority itself.*In definitely ed the question to one of a struggle for influence within the Soviets of Workers' , Agricultural Labourers', Soldiers' and Peasants' Deputies. In order to leave no trace of doubt in this respect, I twice emphasised in the theses the necessity for patient and persistent "explanatory' work 'adapted to the practical needs of the masses*.
Ignorant persons or renegades from Marxism, such as Mr Plekhanov, may cry anarchism, Blanquism, and so forth. But those who really want to think and learn cannot fail to understand that Blanquism means the seizure of power by a minority, whereas the Soviet of Workers' ', Agrigultural Labourers! Soldiers' and Peasants* Deputies are admittedly the direct and immediate organisation of the majority of the people.
Work confined to a struggle for influence within these Soviets cannot, absolutely cannot, blunder into the swamp of Blanquism. Nor can it blunder into the swamp of anarchism, for anarchism denies the necessity for a state and for state power in the period of transition from the rule of the bourgeoisie to the rule of the proletariat, whereas I, with a precision that excludes all possibility of misunderstanding, insist on the necessity for a state in this period, although, in accordance with Marx and the experience of the Paris Commune, not the usual parliamentary bourgeois state, but a state without a standing army, without a police opposed to the people, without an officialdom placed above the people."
Again explaining where - in *Marxism differs from Blanquism' - he obviously considered it absolutely necessary for the advanced workers, to understand this so as to be sure of their ground at every step — he wrote in a letter to the Central Committee of the party on September 26-27, 1917;
*To be successful, the must be based not on a conspiracy, not on a party, but on the advanced class. This is the first point.
"The uprising must be based on the revolutionary upsurge of the people. This is the second point.
*The uprising must be based on the crucial point in the history of the maturing revolution, when the activity of the vanguard of the people is at its height, when the vacillations in the ranks of the enemies, and in the ranks of the weak, half-hearted, undecided friends of the revolution are at their highest point. This is the third point.
*It is in pointing out these three conditions as the way of approaching the question of an uprising, that Marxism differs from Blanquism, Naturally, when Lenin, or any other Marxist, spoke of the necessity of the revolutionary party having the support of the majority, he meant the real majority, whose sentiments are ascertainable in various ways besides the ballot box of the bourgeois state. On the eve of the insurrection he wrote his devastating attack on Zinoviev and Kamenev who opposed the insurrection on the ground, among other things, that "we do not enjoy a majority among the people, and in the absence of that condition insurrection is hopeless."
Lenin, in 'A Letter to the Comrades' this statement as either distorters of the truth or pedants who desire at all costs, without the slightest regard for the true circumstances of the revolution, to have a guarantee in advance that the Bolshevik Party throughout the country has received exactly one half the number of votes plus one". Nevertheless, he took pains to prove the Bolsheviks had the majority by "facts":
*The elections of August 20 in Petrograd" "The elections to ihe Borough Dumas in Moscow September". The new elections to the Soviets"... "The majority of the Peasants' Soviets" who had *expressed their opposition to the coalition" 'The mass of the soldiers".. ."Finally,...the revolt of the peasantry". He concluded his argument on this point by saying: "No, to doubt now that the majority of the people are following and will follow the Bolsheviks is shameful vacillation."
Once again disavowing Blanquism, he wrote in his polemic against Zinoviev and Kameneve:
"A military conspiracy is Blanquism IF it is not organised by the party of a definite class; IF its "A democratic movement. movement majority in interests majority. organisers have not reckoned with the political situation in general and the international situation in particular; IF the party in question does not enjoy the sympathy of the majority of people, as proved by definite facts...
On September 25-27 Lenin called upon the Bolshevik party to take power. In this famous letter, addressed "to the Central Committee, the Petrograd and Moscow Committees of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party", Lenin, with the logic and directness which characterised him, states his premise and his conclusion in the first sentence:
*Having obtained a majority in the Sovies of Workers' and Soldiers' Deputies of both capitals, the Bolsheviks can and must take of ti the of the power into their hands."
He was not worried about a 'formal' majority: "no revolution ever waits for this" . But he was sure of the real majority. He insisted upon the revolution "right now", as he expressed it, not sooner and not later, because:
"The majority of the people is with us. This has been proven by the long and difficult road from May 19 to August 12 and September 25: the majority in the Soviets of the capitals is the result of the people's progress to our side. The vacillation of the Socialist Revolutionaries and Mensheviks, and the strengthening of internationalists among them, is proof of the same thing.
The prosecution at the Minneapolis trial attempted to convict us, as charged in the indictment, of an actual "conspiracy to overthrow the government by force and violence" . We successfully refuted this accusation, and the indictment covering this point was rejected by the jury. —The most effective element of our refutation of this absurd charge against our small party was our exposition of the democratic basis of the proletarian programme, of the party's reliance on the majority to realise its programme, and its corresponding obligation, while it remains in the minority, to "submit to the majority"
In making this exposition we had a legal purpose, but not only a legal purpose, in mind. As with all the testimony, it was designed primarily to explain and simplify our views and aims to the workers who would be future readers of the published court record.
We also thought a re-statement of the Marxist position in this respect would not be wasted on the members of our own movement, and might even be needed. The discussion which has arisen on this question only proves that we were more correct in this latter assumption than we realised at the time.
Socialism is a democratic movement and its programme, the programme of the vanguard party, can be realised only with the support of the majority. The party's basic task, while it remains in the minority, is "propaganda to win over the majority". To state this was not capitulation to the prejudices of the jury; it is the teaching of Marx and Lenin, as has been shown in the foregoing references.
• Grandizo Munis was a Spanish Trotskyist who later became a spokesperson for the ultra-left group that calls itself the International Communist Current. They consider the existing labour movement as bourgeois, rejecting trade unionism, etc. They publish "World Revolution' in English.
• Ochlerites were an ex-Trotskyist faction in the US led by Hugh Oehler. They made a principle of proclaiming "the revolutionary party" no matter how small its numbers and support, and of counterposing it as a supposedly finished institution to everything else. Essentially they were "Trotskyists' who were extremely formalistic and rigid in their thinking on general political questions as well as on the party and thus parted company with Trotsky.
They are the unacknowledged political ancestors of organisations like the WRP and the SWP.
• Blanquism was an early form of revolutionary communism in France. The term as used here means the politics of armed insurrection by a conspiratorial" minority who would seize power for the workers.
----- pull-quotes -----
only be realised w the support of the majority."