Astounding 'tolerance
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Of course. We all have to signify our own individuality, stupid. He turned away from me to flick through an untitled Penguin Original. No one wants to wear crimplene, do they? Think of all the wonderful things Thatcher has given us. Think of what Sainsbury's used to be like.
I wondered what he was going on about and noticed how empty the wine bottle had become. He hadn't offered me any, I realised.
So what is the role of the Communist Party in this situation? I asked.
That's an agenda we have yet to engage with meaningfully he said, meaningfully. We must play, essentially, an ideological role. Engage with other people's discourses, that sort of thing.
Suddenly he had gone, leaving only the faint odour of expensive aftershave. Was this a dream, or does this dreadful man really exist?
For all 1 know, John Cunningham (SO 430) is right that Michael Powell was a "high Tory". If he was, then the political "tolerance' and liberalism' of his film I See a Dark Stranger' is even more remarkable than l've always thought.
Made in 1946 or '47, this film is abour German spies in wartime England and Ireland. A central character is an honourable old-fashioned non-Nazi patriotic German spy, which is nothing surprising in Powell and Pressburger:
Very surprising for the time is the main character, a young Irish woman, brought up on stories of Ireland's fight against England for its freedom, who goes to England and works there to help Germany destroy England. The IRA - both its "left' and right wings — was then allied to Germany.
She is presented sympathetically, as are her reasons for seeing things the way she does. She is shown as blinkered and politically ignorant and she changes sides when it comes home to her that her spying must mean the deaths of many English -and Irish - soldiers.
But if you remember that Winston Churchill was so bitter about Southern Ireland's war-time neutrality that he attacked the Irish state even in his 1945 victory speech on the radio, then the political attitudes of this mainstream British film are astounding. tical of Liz's uncritical endorsement of Relate and conciliation services: I await to be convinced of their relevance to the problems of working class people whose relationships break up. In practice, Liz's solution seems to come down to women yet again having to mend their ways. Thanks very much, but mothers have enough guilt-tripping from the straight press without socialist newspapers adding to the chorus.
Marx and Engels (whoops, sorry, not trendy) argued that whatever the personal horrors of the industrial revolution drawing women into the factories, it was a progressive trend which socialists had to support. On the terrain of the labour movement, SO has resisted New Times designer capitulation. What makes it OK to ditch the ideas of Women's Liberation? Is is that you were less attached to them in the first place?
In sisterhood, Gerry Byrne South London