Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Reforging da slavery

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 557 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The Tories are trying to use the law to ban women, especially lesbians, from creating families without fathers. Photo: Peter LETITER Until I read Liz Millward's article (SO433) I was puzzled why little bundles of SOs addressed to my erstwhile partner kept arriving through my door months after he'd moved out. All is now clear. You are determined to keep us as a nuclear family unit whether we like it or not.

Even mentioning the nuclear family makes me feel like a dinosaur. It's not very. 9 not designer socialism, is it? It harks back to the days when we talked about 'domestic slavery' and demanded free 24-hour nurseries. I suppose to many of your readers that's ancient history.

I shrugged off Liz's first article as a bit of ill-considered naivety bunged in to fill a column. But a second article, reiterating the first, implies a degree of editorial approval. Men, as they get older, do get more patriarchal.

It is important to respond to Liz because, though she and SO seem unaware of it, we're facing an ideological offensive in defence of the nuclear family. Abortion rights are again under attack. Tories are explicitly trying to use the law to ban women, especially lesbians, from creating families without fathers. There are calls to cut benefit for single mothers who won't name their children's fathers (spearheaded by Labour's own failed abortion, Frank Field).

In many ways it is reminiscent of the 'maternal deprivation' (ie. working mothers) horror stories of '50s. The same ills psychological trauma, delinquency, under-achievement — are now being blamed on single parenthood as were once caused working mothers. Paternal deprivation looks like being the buzzword of the '90s.

Research isn't ideologically neutral; it doesn't come out of a vacuum. You find what you set out to look for. I'm sorry if this sounds very '60s, but it does save time not to have relearn yesterday's lessons from scratch.

I don't know the American research Liz refers to. I don't know how their samples were selected. Were the children of divorced parents matched with randomlyselected children from 2-parent families? Or with children from families which would have split up but for religious or cultural bans on divorce? Were they compared with children who lost a parent through death of imprisonment, or who FoRGROIN Walsh (Profile) never had two parents? The inferences it is proper to draw would depend very much on what was being compared to what.

Bowlby, the father of 'maternal deprivation', was within his own terms a scrupulous and childcentred researcher. His findings revolutionised the way children in institutions were treated. His work was used in an utterly reactionary (unsuccessful) attempt to drive women back into the home and reforge the shackles of domestic slavery.

We are now witnessing another attempt to turn back the tide. The Tories are horrified that a quarter of children are now born outside marriage; that three quarters of divorces are initiated by women; that lesbians are openly articulating their right to have and keep their children. We should be dancing in the streets. This is the (partial) break-up of patriarchy.

We shouldn't be callous about the casualties of this social revolution. I'm in favour of more research into how to minimise the trauma of parental break-up. I'm more scep-

----- pull-quotes -----

BIAN THER NO PY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →