Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[GRAFFITT rubbed my eyes. Could it be true?…]

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 866 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

GRAFFITT rubbed my eyes. Could it be true? Standing before me, bathed in the light of a visual display unit, was surely Martin Jaques, editor of Marxism Today.

I could tell it was him from the look of self-satisfaction in his eyes and the price tag on the bottle of claret he had with him. He sat down, proudly opening his copy of the Financial Times, anxious for me to see the scoop he had scored: an interview with Karl Marx.

1 had so much to ask him. So without ado, I began, Tell me Mr Jaques, do you feel disappointed to see regimes that you once supported collapsing, all across the world, because the people they ruled simply can't bear to live under them any more. Doesn't it make you feel bad?

No, he responded immediately The people of Eastern Europe believe in democracy. And so da But you are a long-standing member of the Communist Party. That party's whole political existence, surely, was based on the idea that the system in the USSR and similar countries was socialist. How can you so easily accept their demise?

But I'm a Eurocommunist. Or I was one; maybe I'm not any sort of communist any more. But we Eurocommunists long ago rejected the Soviet model. This happened after we read Gramsci.

But the Eurocommunists were a wing of the mainstream pro-Russian movement, weren't they? That's your tradition.

Oh, but I'm a radical, and wedon't believe in tradition. You're such a typical Trotskyist, always going on about the past.

So you deny every having sup ported the USSR?

I think that question is now firmly on the agenda.

What?

There are, of course, a multiplicity of discourses on this question. What the Left has always failed to understand is the variety of individual experience.

You mean, just because you nought you supported the USSR didn't mean you necessarily did?

I think we have to get away from this way of seeing things. You see everything in such simplistic terms. Let's talk about the fact that the working class is disappearing.

Making Marxism out of date?

Well, it certainly is out of date. Except for the Russian alphabet, of course, which looks awfully nice on a black leather shoulder bag.

But apart from that?

Exactly. Marxism was all right in its day. Marx was very influential. Lots of people were influenced by Marx. Take Gramsci He read Marx, or so I believe.

And well...others too.

But let's face it, the working class really isn't just a load of thick men in clogs any more, is it? Well, there are a few left like that, I'll grant you, but for the most part they go on holiday. these days, so they're not at all like they were when Marx was around, and as for everyone else, fortunately these days peo ple are quite cultured and eat foreign foods, and all that sort o thing. Completely different, you see.

I'm not sure / do.

Well that's because you're so stuck in all those stuffy old formulas.

Such as?

Ah well there you have me but anyway i want to talk ab something else.

Do you think the working class was ever just a load of thick men in clogs?

Of course.

When?

Before post-Fordism, naturally. He sipped his wine. You see, he said, leaning back in his chair, knowledgeably, we are living in a whole new period now, which for the sake of simplicity I will call post-Fordism. We could call it post-modernism, too, of course, or, bearing in mind the great march of democracy, postMarxism.

He played absent-mindedly for a moment on his personal telephone. Look around you. What do you see? The traditional working class is dead, and traditional socialism dead with it. All the factories have been shut. Fordism was about big factories, making cars, with male workers, in strong unions, believing in socialism, eating fish and chips and living on council estates. All gone.

Isn't it that the working class is changing? There are still big workplaces, including factories. There are still unions, still strikes. Aren't you confusing a depressed time for the labour movement with the end of it?

No. Everything has ended. Everything.

And isn't your conclusion just that old-fashioned social democracy has found a new lease of life?

There's nothing old-fashioned about social democracy I'll have you know. They all read Marxism Today!

But you're confusing the failure of the Stalinist tradition with a failure of Marxism.

At this point Mr Jaques got angry. Look, you unbearable Trot. We used to treat you people like you deserved, no messing around. There was only one Marxist tradition, do you understand? Only one.

I was determined not to be intimidated. You say that socialism came to be identified with a bureaucratic state, but isn't that your fault, or the fault of the pro-Russian communist movement?

Of course not. Socialism was identified with a bureaucratic state because that's what it is. Which is why we have to forget about it. I mean, wouldn't you rather have a Next store to shor at than queue up for boiled bacon.

Most definitely. But this isn't relevant, is it?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →