Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Resist the poll tax Labour

Socialist Organiser no. 438, 15 March 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 1,617 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

front

Heath government's immigration policy was a minor uproar.

Mrs Thatcher would lose a general election now. But she doesn't have to call one for two years or more.

If we had a parliament with annual elections, such as the early labour movement (the Chartists) set out to win over a hundred and fifty years ago, then Mrs Thatcher would be driven from office.

But of course we have nothing like that. We have a system whose need of reform could not be more glaringly illustrated than it is now.

This minority government, with its arbitrary and non-representative majority in the House of Commons, is pushing through the latest piece of savage class legislation — legislation to benefit the haves and penalise the have-nots - against the manifest opposition of a big majority of the electorate. No wonder there is widespread and growing dissatisfaction with the government and the system of election under which it was chosen.

No wonder there is a vast rolling wave of civil disobedience by people refusing to pay the poll tax - up to one million in Scotland.

And what do you say to those people? You tell them to obey the law! In effect you say to Thatcher, *I disagree with everything you do, your notion of democratic propriety is a central reason why Mrs Thatcher has been able to abuse democracy in the she has and does.

but the Labour Party under my leadership will defend to the death your right to do it"!

Thatcher and the Thatcherite press create a great hue and cry about "violence" to distract from the real issue, and what do you do? You join in the condemnation. You don't even have the decency to make a distinction between the angry young people outside Hackney Town Hall and the few political boneheads who may have wanted rough-housing demonstrations outside Town Halls because they aren't interested in the broader political processes.

Your calculations here are obvious. Don't let Thatcher do what she wants to do, and "blame" Labour for the violence. But you also tell the millions of potential non-payers of the poll tax to obey the law. You turn yourself into Mrs Thatcher's political outrider and trouble-shooter over the poll tax.

Why, Mr Kinnock? You say democracy demands it. The law is the law. We must bow down before the law, even rapacious class law enshrining inequalities and breeding a vast crop of injustice.

Your idea of democracy, Mr Kinnock, is, I submit, not one that those who fought for and won the democratic system you support would recognise.

Any notion of democracy which does not recognise the right of The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA lesk: 01 639 7965 w reports: first post

resistance to bad laws and to tyrannical governments and how would you go about arguing that Mrs Thatcher's government is not now behaving tyrannically? - is a recipe for passive submission to any indignity inflicted by an ephemera majority - or, in this case, by a government which is far from being elected or supported by a majority of the electorate.

Any living democracy even one as shallow and "bourgeois" as the one we have, which combines civil liberties and the vote with a system of grinding tyranny of the

rich in industry - will include struggle and conflict. What a government can and cannot do will often have to be determined by resistance to government decrees.

The democratic system we have now, inadequate though it is, was shaped and expanded by decades and centuries of such struggles by our class and political ancestors, Mr Kinnock. So what has changed?

Is the present system so perfect a democratic mechanism that the example of all our long history of struggle becomes invalid? That is the only possible argument you and your supporters could bring in here. t is plainly absurd!

A system that allows a government with only minority backing to ram through what Thatcher has rammed through over the last ten years is patently imperfect, if not positively malign.

The truth, Mr Kinnock, is that your notion of democratic propriety is a central reason why Mrs Thatcher has been able to abuse democracy in the way she has and does. She has met with only feeble resistance and has thus pushed ahead, getting bolder and bolder. Yet she could have been stopped and prevented from doing much of the evil she has imposed on the working people of Britain if the labour movement's leaders had been less supine, less willing to accept and to champion her "democratic right" to wreak havoc against the majority on behalf of a minority of the minority who elected her.

Is this just "the usual totalitarian claptrap"'? Mr Kinnock, it is your idea of democracy which corresponds most closely with that of the totalitarians in the labour movement. It is you who preach the divine right of an elected government to do what it likes and deny the democratic right of resistance to injustice and tyranny. It is you who defend Mrs Thatcher's "elected dictatorship".

More than that, though. One reason why some people who wanted to be socialists feel for the Stalinist totalitarian claptrap and undervalued and rejected democracy was because they understood democracy as you understand it — a matter of passive submission to rigged parliaments and manipulated majorities. Like you they didn't understand democracy as a matter of struggle.

Where you worship the bourgeois version of democracy and make a god of it, they rejected it and made a devil of it. The basic attitudes about what it is have much in common, though.

I repeat: those who fought for, von and built the modern limited parliamentary democracies - what Marxists call bourgeois democracies Monday 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser Thatcher"s democratic riaht to do iniustice. — had a radically different notion of what it was all about. Democracy to them was something alive and real.

This, for example, is what the American Declaration of Independence of 1776 says about it.

*We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal: that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among them are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

*That, to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed; that, whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute a new government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organising its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and happiness.

... When a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same object, evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such government and to provide new guards for their future security"

In principle one could make a plausible case for full-scale insurrection against the poll tax and still be completely in step with the real spirit of even bourgeois democracy! In fact a vigorous political campaign centred on civil disobedience would be enough to defeat Mrs Thatcher's tyrannous poll tax.

Labour should advocate such a campaign, and you should lead it, Mr Kinnock.

Right now you hope to sail calmly towards an election victory in two years time. You want no upsets, no risks. Your strategy is one of halfpassive speculation and hope that the tides and waves of politics will see Labour home and dry in 1991 or 1992.

But what if you miscalculate? What if the tides change? Better than hoping and speculating would be a vigorous Labour campaign to harry the Tories by organising the opposition that is now seething and steaming under the Tories.

Nine years ago Michael Foot was elected leader of the Labour Party. Thatcher was very unpopular in the opinion polls. Unemployment had begun to bite into the sinews of the labour movement, but the movement still had the heart and morale for a fight.

Michael Foot promised to raise *a storm of indignation against the Tories" and to drive them from office. He never did it, never even tried to do it. The result of that failure was that Thatcher thrived and the '80s were terrible years for the labour movement and for large sections of the working class.

The mass revulsion now against Thatcher — which is even convulsing the Tory party itself -gives Labour the chance to organise a new "storm of indignation" and make sure that the Tories are kicked out. Labour should do that. It should side with and defend the youth, such as those who got out of control outside Hackney Town Hall, against the Tories who would grind them down further.

Labour should dare to seize this chance to rouse and organise the storm of indignation which Michael Foot talked about at the beginning of the Thatcher years.

Labour should not say: *We disagree with Thatcher, but we'll defend her democratic right to do injustice". It should say: "We disagree with Thatcher, and we'll support the right of the people to oppose her, lead their fight to resist her".

Meet at Kennington Park at 12 noon March to Trafalgar Square LONDON

----- pull-quotes -----

John O'Mahony NO POLLITAX the семО Sat 31st March

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 438

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →