[for progress towards socialism. Two major aspects of…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
for progress towards socialism. Two major aspects of the situation inhibit that development.
The first of those is the manner in which the system has collapsed. The likelihood of the reabsorption of Eastern Europe into the capitalist nexus and the willing participation of the majority of the peoples of Eastern Europe in that process does not in the immediate period ahead augur well for those who argue for a perspective which is neither capitalist nor Stalinist.
The second factor is the lack of credibility of the left, who have largely failed to sufficiently distance themselves from the horrors of the Stalinist system. Even those who see ort the demands of the themselves as being in the traditions of revolutionary socialism have in the main continued throughout most of the post Second World War period to sow illusions in the supposedly progressive nature of the Soviet bloc.
Over the longer historical period these obstacles will hopefully reduce as workers in Eastern Europe experience the exploitative nature of capitalism and as adherence to such curious concepts as the "workers' states" idea becomes confined to a few flat earthists. That does not make our task in the short term any easier The recent issue of Workers" allows her to imagine that wiping out the Monarchy (SO 434) would be a solution to its ideological and cultural power. It would, of course, do exactly the reverse.)
(3) Finally, Liz's proposal to clamp together, by law, otherwise unwilling separated parents and children for set periods of weekly 'child care' seems to me bizarre. I think most child psychologists would wince at the idea which tramples over just about everything that is known about healthy child development. Bruno Bettelheim has written: "Whatever we do with and for our children ought to flow from our understanding of and our feelings for the particular situation and the relation we wish to exist between us and our child.
Children distinguish authentic from non-authentic behaviour no matter how well an adult pretends. They may not be able to articulate it to themselves, but the feeling will be internalised, maybe repressed, as anxiety, insecurity or fear. Far from helping a child, I think Liz's proposal would be positively harmful.
We should reject the vulgar Marxist attitude of 'there is nothing we can do until socialism' and the idealism of those who think we can prefigure the forms of childcare and development of the socialist future in the capitalist present. Between those two traps we can develop a policy for children and fight for it. But, that policy couldn't hinge on individual parental "success' Or 'failure' but must be about the socialisation of childcare and development.
Alan John Liverj Liberty magazine is .. pains to try to rescue Lenin's ideas from the disintegration of Stalinism. The rejection by the peoples of Eastern Europe of the monolithic one-party state in favour of a democratically determined multi-party system will most likely involve a rejection of the whole Leninist heritage, so accustomed have they become to identifying the bureaucratic states with the mantle of Leninism.
In the face of such developments and the marginalisation of Leninism in the West, simply to assert the continuing validity of that tradition is insufficient. Repetition of such well-loved Trotskyist adages as a river of blood separates Leninism from Stalinism" is not to begin to address the problem. A thorough re-evaluation of Leninism is needed in order to discover what in that tradition has continued validity in the context of representative democracy and a multi-party system.
That could well begin by asking the question as to whether there is any evidence from his writings that Lenin genuinely believed in a multiparty system.
At the practical level, in the light of recent developments in Eastern Europe, it is worth while asking the question as to what constitutes solidarity activity in Britain today. Solidarity movements are normally rooted in a perceived need to support those who are struggling against oppressive regimes. Does that have any meaning in the context of Eastern Europe today, where the likelihood is the emergence of regimes which are no more and no less repressive than those which exist in Western Europe?
Where solidarity becomes more meaningful perhaps is in relation to the Soviet Union where the monolithic one-party state still exists (although recent events in Lithuania and Estonia may spell the beginning of the end of that.
It will become even more meaningful and urgent if the hardline Stalinists in the Soviet Union oust Gorbachev and reassert control with possible consequent reverberations in Eastern Europe. That wholly undesirable possibility would necessitate renewed solidarity activity, but of a kind which is distinguished from the proGorbachev camp. Whether that happens or not, clearly a thorough discussion of the meaning and relevance of solidarity work in respect of the Soviet bloc is essential.
McCalmar Glasgow