Childcare and the family
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Z Millward (Women's Eye, SO 431) is absolutely correct to use her column to argue for the rights of children.
In our society children suffer silencing, humiliation and abuse. Liz is also right to insist that children can suffer trauma as a result of the sudden disappearance of one of their parents.
But I think the solutions Liz proposes to deal with this are mistaken and ironically would harm the very people Liz seeks to aid - children.
Liz argues that children should be "protected' from divorce not just by trained counsellors saving' relationships in trouble but by parents staying together for the sake of the children'; by laws making divorce a "hard option' and, if this fails then the Left should be insisting by legal means if necessary that the divorcing parents both spend time with their kids"
(1) Liz tries to find solutions within a framework that is not only far too narrow but is in one sense part of the problem — the privatised family. Liz puts great store in counselling to keep the family' together. Now more counsellors can only be a good thing but, like social workers, they only treat the symptoms of a far deeper malaise created by the social relations of capitalism. It is a structural not a pathological problem.
Parenting takes place in a very particular context. For a start poor housing, unemployment and poverty conspire to make child care extraordinarily difficult for millions. A recent study carried out in North Battersea into the kinds and numbers of children coming into care made findings according to the author, "linking poverty and reception into care. The overall picture Is one of families on desperately low income in the worst cramped housing with few supporters or other resources...More resources are needed for housing, income maintenance, employment and day care provision to reduce family stress and insecurity. Supportive work with families could include family centres, proper payments to neighbours for short-term fostering." (Peter Beresford, 'In Care in North Battersea'.)
It's not that the "trained counsellors" Liz looks to are irrelevant. But it is rather like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.
(2) Liz seems to accept one of the core assumptions of conservative social policy: that the family should be the only unit charged with the everyday responsibility for children. Liz is concerned to make that unit work. And if it fails to work to make its members legally obliged to pretend it hasn't!
As Peter Moss, co-ordinator of a Common Market initiative on childcare provision has observed, *In Britain we have a whole industry discussing ways of teaching malfunctioning parents to perform better, but we don't discuss ways in which we, as a society, could provide better conditions for parenting."
There are virtually no public, collective childcare facilities. Parenthood is seen as a private indulgence which takes place as far as possible between consenting adults in private. The current use of childrenas-cultural-accessory in advertising is part and parcel of this: "them that's got shall have" celebrates the Volkswagen ad. And the caring services are often just a police force, intervening when it all breaks down, as it must.
When Liz wrote a similar article some time ago (SO 420), Belinda Weaver replied, putting the case for an opening up of childcare from its privatised ghetto, to socialise it. Now this is not to say that parental bonding - deep, stable and emotionally rich attachments — are not absolutely essential for child development. They are. (The letter from Mark Stevens seemed to ignore this.) But all too often it is just this bonding which is fractured as the privatised family world, from being a haven, turns in on itself with horrific results. The answer is not to prop up that privatised world with counsellors and laws but to surround the act of parenting (by whoever, of whatever sexuality, in whatever number) with resources and structures which empower parents and children alike.
In France a vast array of childcare facilities exist - reserved places in drop in centres with a positive encouragement to leave children, universal full-time nursery provision from 3 years old, publicly resourced home helps to relieve the strain of the ill or exhausted parent, etc, etc. In the here and now it is all this and more that we should be campaigning for. But in her cramped focus and authoritarian slant Liz risks lending support to the Tories' cult of the individual, tut-tutting at parents, and moving us in the wrong direction. (It Is the same slant, presumably, which
Scan page 11
ambulances: 'Wt we are on strike'