Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Surprises from

Socialist Organiser no. 437, 8 March 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 528 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The swift and relatively peaceful (except in Romania) dissolution of Stalinism in Eastern Europe has taken place with a rapidity that has left almost everyone gaspingFew authorities on the Eastern Bloc foresaw the speed of disintegration. One exception is Hillel Ticktin, who has for a number of years forecast the rapid disintegration of the system once the process began.

Just as the Trotskyists in the immediate post Second World War period were caught off guard by the swift spread of Stalinism throughout Eastern Europe, so have those who stand in that tradition been surprised by recent events. To admit surprise is no disgrace as long as it is accompanied by a resolve to analyse fully the implications of these developments.

One of the key issues for analysis is the effect on East-West relations. Just as the Warsaw Pact ceases to have any coherent rationale, so also its alter ego, NATO. Spokespersons for the latter are now reduced to gibberish as they try to defend the continuance of an outmoded arrangement and in particular their adherence to a nuclear strategy.

Deterrence has lost its meaning and with it the concept of nuclear capability. The short-sighted attitude of Kinnock and Co. in abandoning unilateralism is now exposed. There are signs that the Scottish Conference of the Labour Party will re-endorse unilateralism. Even if that tails to happen, we must press for an urgent rethink on this question by the Labour leadership.

Without recent developments in Eastern Europe socialists have correctly adhered to unilateralism. These changes, however, make that strategy more meaningful in the eyes of wider, sections of the elec torate.

The most likely prospect for the East Europe economies is a fairly rapid reabsorption into the capitalist world framework. Whatever the protestations of socialists in the East and West, the misery of life under the Communist systems will propel them towards that solution. The unification of the economies of East and West Germany and the privatisation of industry in Poland and elsewhere are part of that process.

Where does that place socialists in relation to the European Community (EC)? Commitment to the Community's institutions, such as the Strasbourg parliament, may have the effect of reinforcing the insularity of the Community and so excluding the economies of Eastern Europe and thereby relegating them to an inferior status.

The logic for socialists may well be to call for the break-up of the EC and the creation of a federal framework for Europe as a whole. This position breaks both with British nationalism and the straitjacket of the Treaty of Rome, and lays the foundations for a wider Europe, thus making more meaningful the slogan of a United Socialist Europe.

It has been an opinion long cherished among the Trotskyist left in the West that the downfall of Stalinism in the Soviet bloc would make the case for socialism in the West more convincing. The identification of socialism with the system in the Soviet bloc has been regarded as constituting a blockage in people's thinking to a true evaluation of the value of a socialist future.

That does not mean, however, that the dissolution of that system automatically releases that potential

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 437

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →