8 CAPITAL PUNISH Discipline and punish
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
in China today where A apart from massacres like that in Tiananmen Square - perhaps 30,000 people a year are killed by the state, for crimes ranging from murder to theft, so it was in Britain in the past.
Capital punishment once lay at the centre of the British ruling class's strategies for control of the masses. Never was this more the case than in the eighteenth century, when the landed gentry — who had generally made their money through corruption in government office or through monopolies in trade - protected their property by means of an extensive array of capital statutes.
Notorious among the acts that were passed on their behalf were the was reserved for a removed from public domain. so-called Black Acts. They made it a hangable offence to hunt the precious deer of the landlords, to poach, to sell game, to black one's face with the intention of poaching (thus the name of the Acts), to break down the head of a fishpond, to kill cattle, to cut down trees belonging to another, to commit arson, to send anonymous, threatening letters, to try to rescue someone from custody, and so on and so forth.
The hanging itself was a public ceremony, with all the trappings of a military parade. The condemned person would be taken in an open cart from his or her place of confinement to the gallows (eg. at Tyburn, where Marble Arch In London stands today. In full view of the public at large they would be strangled to a painful death by the rope.
The whole gruesome business was a show of power by the ruling class. It was meant to instil terror into the hearts of the masses and at the same time to make them aware that power over life and death lay at the discretion of their rulers.
As often as not, the victims could be pardoned and transported overseas on a convict ship instead; but this act of mercy, which could be left until the last moment, depended absolutely on the good grace of the monarch and his fellow rulers.
This combination of terror and mercy formed the essence of punishment at a time when the ruling class was defending its own form of domination with all its might.
In the course of the eighteenth century, however, we also find the great bourgeois reformers (Beccaria, Manzoni, Howard, Romilly, etc.) make their case against capital punishment as both barbaric and futile.
They declared that capital punishment violated the fundamental rights of human beings, that it was an inhuman punishment. They declared also that such punishments were useless in the modern world.
Far from deterring people from violence, they set an example of the most horrific and cold-blooded violence being given legal sanction. By definition, they cut out the very possibility of reform.
Juries were becoming unwilling to convict and judges unwilling to sentence, when the punishment was so out of proportion to the offence committed. The manufacturers argued that they needed certainty of punishment and not the remote threat of a dreadful punishment if their property was to be adequately protected.
On the basis of these and other arguments, the reforming bourgeoisie won. Capital punishment was reserved for a few major offences (mainly murder). Hanging was removed from the public domain, The horder sociated non hanging was as far as possible done away with - improvements in the technology of the knot and the drop were intended to make death as Capital punishment in China quick and painless as possible.
In place of the rope, there arose the familiar institutions of the modern age, the police and the prisons.
The spirit of punishment in the new age of bourgeois rule was caught by Kant and Hegel. Hegel wrote: "punishment is the right of the criminal. It is an act of his own will...His crime is the negative [overturning, denial, subversion] of right. Punishment is the negation of the negation and consequently an affirmation of right solicited and forced upon the criminal by himself."
The new penitentiaries of the early nineteenth century were intended to replace physical torture by mental torture, to link vengeance on the criminal with penance in the criminal, the corporal punishment of isolation with the spiritual punishment of guilt.
This penal theory "No rational argument support: the death penalty. By definition it cannot reform at great length by the philosopher of utalitarianism, Jeremy Bentham: punishment must make the criminal the judge of his own crime; it must appear that in their punishment criminals pass sentence on themselves. A whol machinery of power and i ontrol w as set up to ensure that tl is fetish of power was sustained.
The convicts were shut behind prison walls, cut off from intercourse with the outside world, subjected to a regime of constant surveillance, subjected to an interregime of rewards and punishments to ensure that in word and gesture - if not in their hearts they consented to the punishments inflicted upon them.
In today's prison codes, the watchword of the prison is penitence, or the reformation of criminals into human beings. The reality of the prison is less fine: we find in fact a reinforcement of all the inhuman conditions — the deprivation, isolation, mutual competition, racism, etc. — that lead men and women to commit crimes in the first place.
The crisis of modern punishment is that the reality increasingly deviates from the ideal. The right wing answer to this crisis is not to alter the reality but to do away with the ideal. Nowhere is this more evident than in the perennial howls for the reintroduction of the death penalty. The Tory hounds have
----- pull-quotes -----
"The reforming bourgeoisie won. Capital punishment
few major offences (mainly murder). Hanging was