Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Democracy, not revenge!

Socialist Organiser no. 437, 8 March 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 563 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

bureaucracies of the Eastern Bloc. This newspaper has criticised him for that. But that attitude was established long before the strike. If it changed during the strike, it was for the better: faced with the evidence that Poland's Stalinist government was sending coal to break the strike, while Solidarnosc miners' committees were sending messages of support, Arthur Scargill commented, "I owe an apology to Lech Walesa"

And who is Robert Maxwell to criticise anyone for getting money from the USSR and Libya? He has made a fortune out of publishing Monday 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Su bialist Organiser The mini-crisis around German recognition of the existing Polish-German border has ended with Chancellor Helmut Kohl's unconditional acceptance of the current border between the two countries, along the Oder and Neisse rivers.

History will have to be left to say whether or not that is the end of the matter. The crisis throws light on a question which confronts the left in many other parts of the world - in Palestine and Ireland, for example - and to which the left habitually gives the wrong answer.

What should happen in areas from which one people has been driven out and a different nation planted? Revenge, or a democratic settlement based on the new established facts?

Present-day Western Poland was in 1945, and for many centuries before, German territory. At the end of the war the Poles and Russians drove between eight and ten million Germans to the West, allowing them nothing but what they could carry.

They crowded the roads, and swarmed on to whatever transport they could find. Their descendants are still a powerful force in West German politics half a century later.

That expulsion was a crime done by Poles and Russians, but one agreed on by all the Allies at their Potsdam conference — by Britain, France and the US as well as the USSR. Stalin wanted it to "compensate" Poland for territory (part of the Ukraine held by Poland since the war of 1920) he had detached from the Polish state on its eastern border.

Stalin also hoped to erect a perpetual antagonism between Poland and Germany, and thus bind Poland to the protection of the Russian state.

For a while last week you could hear Stalin's ghost laughing. Not all the horrors which the Nazis committed against the Poles can justify or excuse the atrocity committed when up to 13 million Germans were driven west in 1945 (three million from Czechoslovakia as well as the ones from Poland); and nor can that atrocity justify the new atrocity which would be implied by any attempt to reverse 1945's atrocity now.

To try to reverse it now would be to uproot the people who have taken root in western Poland, and to replace them with people scattered in West Germany.

What should happen when one people has been driven out of an area, and a different nation planted? Neither in western Poland, nor in north-east Ireland, nor in Israel, is revenge the answer.

The socialist answer is to fight for full equality for all minorities, to oppose all chauvinism and revanchism, to organise working-class unity across the national and communal divide, and to fight for socialism.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 437

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →