Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Hands off the NUM!

Socialist Organiser no. 437, 8 March 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 650 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The police organised one assault on the miners in 1984-5, while the media organised another. (Thoresby pit, 15 March From page 1 union official in that respect. In his willingness and eagerness to organise labour movement resistance to Thatcher and Thatcherism, he has been very far from typical.

"Hate Arthur Scargill became the battle cry of every reactionary in the country during the great miners* strike. And not only the battle cry of Tory reactionaries: Labour's right wing and soft left too joined in the outcry. Neil Kinnock and his team established their credentials as reliable "moderates" by condemning the violence of the miners.

Miners were being beaten down by semi-militarised squads of police thugs, directed from a central headquarters in London. Pit villages were being occupied as by a foreign army of police. Miners' families were being ground down by the poverty of the 12 month strike.

The whole campaign against the miners, from centralised seminilitary police to pit closures anc the organisation of scab coal supplies, had been planned by civil servants and Tories for years in advance and that was widely known.

What did the press see in the "violence" strike? miners' violence. miners' They saw They convinced the "public" of it.

It was a great success for the lie machine of the ruling class. It was one of the greatest frame-ups in British history, a great success for the politics of the history-shaping lie.

It belongs in the same category as Stalin's Moscow Trials. If Stalin's was the dictatorship of the lie, Thatcher's was the lie democratic, relying not on police-state censorship but on the venality of the privately-owned media and the solidarity of the "opinion formers" in Britain for whom the violence of the police was legitimate and democratic, and that of the miners evil and subversive.

Now we have the "revelation" that the miners got money from Moscow and Tripoli. We don't know whether they did or not. The accused miners' leaders say they didn't.

But there is one short answer to this allegation: so what? If money, without political strings, flowed to the coffers of the beleaguered miners' union from Moscow or Tripoli, or for that matter from Hell, then in principle the miners' leaders would have been wrong not to have taken it and used it.

The only arguments against taking it which a serious activist committed to the miners' fight could have raised would be considerations of expediency — calculations as to whether the advantages that the money would bring were greater than the disadvantages for the miners' cause of the outcry that the media made during the strike about an alleged visit by Roger Windsor to Libya.

During the strike miners' families suffered tremendous hardship. Thatcher's government had primed the courts to seize and freeze the union's assets. It was open class war with neither decency nor any "Queensbury Rules"!

Morally and in every other way the NUM leaders would have been The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA esk: 01 639 7965 i reports: first post 1984. John Harris, IFL entitled to take help from wherever it came and irrespective of the motives guiding the donors, provided that there were no strings.

And, even if there was money, there is no evidence of any strings. Arthur Scargill has had a favourable attitude to the Stalinist the propaganda and selfjustifications of the tyrants of On Friday 9th the NUM Executive will meet to decide what to do about the accusations. They will decide whether to hold an inquiry, and what sort of inquiry, and whether or not to sue the Mirror for libel.

Right now, every honest person on the labour movement should say: Hands off Arthur Scargill! Hands off Peter Heathfield! Hands off the NUM!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 437

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →