Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why MPs don't represent women - or

Socialist Organiser no. 437, 8 March 1990 · scan p. 2 · about 991 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

taste of the direction Greenslade and Maxwell are taking the Mirror. Monday's paper devoted nearly five entire pages (including the front page) to allegations that during the 1984/5 strike, the NUM leadership obtained £163,000 from "the terrorist-linked Security laws to deny strikers' families their rightful state benefits.

If, however, there is any truth in the claims that Scargill and Heathfield made use of funds for their own personal benefit, then there would be real cause for concern. But the Mirror's T programme about sexism he BBC meant to show a in the selection of MPs. They did. But they also showed a programme about the farce of British democracy.

'A Safe Sex for a Safe Seat' let the cameras in to the Tory party selection process. The film followed the progress of three women who had "applied" for the safe seat of High Peak (rural Derbyshire).

One woman, who "wanted to go up North to see what goes on" , didn't get to the first interview. The second had a closer link with the constituency - she played her first game of golf there. She had a first interview, but got no further. The third candidate, a Tory councillor trom Shettield, made it to the final three, and then lost to a (male) chinless wonder from London.

Sexism was certainly in evidence. The woman candidate had a thousand times more humour and personality than the twit of a bloke who won. She also had a northern accent, and had lived all her life within five minutes' drive of the constituency. In a non-sexist world she would have won hands down. The programme didn't have to point this out, it was all too depressingly obvious.

The selection procedure itself was not (as far as 1 could see stacked against women candidates. In fact at least half of the selectors were women; and the two most central organisers shown were both women. The sexism was in the hands of the participants rather than the structures of the election.

But those structures were a problem, and a problem for the women of the constituency. The seat has been "safe" my lifetime has it ever returned a Labour MP. It is a rural area, a commuter belt for the affluent of Manchester and Sheffield and Britain's oldest national park. It has three main industries - farming, tourism and mineral extraction with little or no unionisation in any of them. The local council for much of the area is also Tory-controlled. Compared to nearby cities, rural Derbyshire is in a paternalistic time warp. Vast tracts of the constituency are owned by one man -the Duke of Devonshire, The BBC showed the selection of the area's representative in parliament. It would take a big swing to Labour to unseat him. Yet he will be accountable only to the 60 local Tories who chose him - 60 landowners and shopkeepers out of 50,000 people.

Those 60 representatives of the ruling class think the High Peak and the Derbyshire Dales are wonderful. They love the low rates because they don't need bus services, adult education courses or youth clubs. Their kids go to private schools so it doesn't bother them that the local schools are so bad. They can afford an architect to convert an old barn, so the planning regulations which don't allow the less well off to build an extra bedroom on the back of their cottage don't matter to them. When their kids grow up they just buy a house. Inflated prices just mean a profit on their "investment' rather than nowhere to live. No doubt the High Peak's new MP will represent their interests very well.

This Tory paradise is also peopled by those who don't find it quite so pleasant. Families in tied housing. Young couples who can't afford to buy a home, and who find that all the rented housing is for holidaymakers. Young women with kids who are stuck in their village without proper shops, leisure facilities, libraries — even the doctor you are literally stuck. If there is a bus it comes once a day. It may not take you where you want to go, but it will be the only way in or out of the village.

Schools are a lottery. Many village schools have been closed. Of the secondary schools, some are Ok, some aren't. All have rigid catchment areas — and the 'good" schools have inflated house prices to match. Apart from school there is nothing for the kids to do. Without transport they can't even get to the nearby towns. There is no Poly or University in the whole country and few FEs — 'continuing education' is basket weaving in the church hall (if it hasn't been converted into four flats, or a gift shop). There is little choice of employment because there are so few employers. Those employers can dictate their own terms. Blot your copybook with ICI and you may well be out of a job, out of your home and the nearest similar work is 20 miles away — with no public transport.

All these problems, and more, affect the working class, and particularly working class women in the High Peak. Yet those women are not represented in parliament or anywhere else. Democracy is a vote every five years which will not change their lives for the better at all because of the demographic nature of the constituency. Yet this is the democracy Thatcher and company want to bring to Eastern Europe. Democracy which is still based on money, and property. Democracy which stitches up areas like High Peak so that working class women are powerless and isolated. Democracy based on money. A Democracy where the person who represents 50,000 people is accountable to 60 of them, and chosen by that 60.

Derbyshire Tories could have chosen a woman for 'their' MP and it would have done absolutely nothing thousands of Derbyshire women.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 437

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →