[ligures were never the Somnulant One's strong suit…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
ligures were never the Somnulant One's strong suit. But even I can work out for myself that 13 divided by 2 comes to It seems that quite a few ambulance workers have an equally firm grasp of rudimentary mathematics. Mr Andy Lawrence, spokesperson for crews at Crawley and East Grinstead has been widely reported saying, "basically all they are offering is 9% which we turned down in October." That 9% offer was for 18 months which meant that it was, in turn, the same as the original offer of 6.5% over 12 months — a point that has not escaped Mr Ray. Clayton of Merseyside NUPE who demonstrated his arithmetical skills to great effect on BBC Newsnight last week.
So how can superstar Roger Poole describe the deal as "simply staggering" and talk of a "coach and horses" being driven through government pay policy? The answer seems to lie in some pretty fancy mathematical juggling which can make the deal look like 17.6%; it can even be made to look like 19.6% if you include an extra 2% for "local productivity" - which in practice (as Mr Clayton points out) means selling jobs and maybe even going along with privatisation of non-emergency services.
None of this changes the simple fact that the deal will cost the government 13% over 2 years; Kenneth Clarke and Duncan Nichol have no hesitation in pointing this out and explaining that all they have really done is a "repackaging job on the original offer. It would be tempting to go along with the Independent's assessment: "The two year pay package...is by no means as "staggering' as the unions are claiming and not quite as moderate as the government would have us believe." But in fact, the government's description is plainly nearer the mark than Mr Poole's. And all that is before we even come on to the small matter of the pay formula that was supposed to be central to the union's demands...
Of course, Clarke is taking a risk in talking-down the size of the deal: he obviously reckons that the danger of provoking a rejection of the deal is less pressing than the need to drive home the point that the government has held the line.
So why is Roger Poole presently on automatic pilot, talking in sound-bites about coaches and horses? Why is he (let's not mince words) telling lies? Part of the explanation is to do with the internal politics of NUPE - the General Secretary election is coming up and Poole's prospects of replacing Bickerstaffe largely depend upon the general perception of the outcome of the ambulance dispute. But he is also motivated by the natural (and not always dishonourable) bureaucrat's instinct to put as good a gloss as possible upon any negotiated settlement.
So what do we say about it? I for one have no hesitation in simply branding Poole's deal a sell-out.
I do not use this term lightly, and, indeed, have often criticised people who bandy it around willy-nilly. Very few disputes end in outright, unambiguous victory for the union side. All disputes are finally settled at the negotiating table. Negotiations by definition involve some degree of give and take.
Some examples of unsatisfactory settlements that were not sell-outs immediately spring to mind: the 1987/8 Ford strike ended with a deal that fell far short of what many militants felt was possible and lefties of the 'Socialist Worker'/"Briefing' variety immediately started squawking about a "sell-out"
Some of us took the view that while more could, indeed, have been won, the final outcome was essentially a victory; management had been forced to make real concessions and the government's unofficial 7% pay norm had been breached. In addition, workers throughout industry saw the Ford settlement as a breakthrough and it very soon sparked a significant resurgence of militancy.
In March 1988, workers at Land Rover Solihull (partly inspired Ford's) came out over their pay claim. A bitter 5-week strike resulted in a return to work with a deal worth very little in practical terms and no "new money", The Land Rover settlement is roughly comparable to the ambulance deal as far as I can see...except that (1) the Land Rover officials and stewards didn't pretend that the settlement was any sort of famous victory, and presented it honestly as a disappointment but the best that - in their estimation - could be achieved under the circumstances.
(2) After 5 weeks the Land Rover strike was on the verge of collapse and no realistic strategy could have saved it by that stage. An orderly retreat was the only option open to responsible officers and stewards Nevertheless, the ritual cry of "sellout" went out from the usual quarters.
So why is the ambulance dispute any different? Most obviously, because Poole is not presenting the deal honestly or objectively. But also, because Poole does have a realistic option for progressing the dispute — building solidarity action. Why Poole has deliberately avoided going down that road is a subject for another article, but suffice for now to note that he was willing to make concessions to militants calling for "internal escalation" but avoided calls for solidarity strikes, like the very plague...
I am aware of an excessive use of the past tense in this discussion of the ambulance dispute: hopefully, the crews will throw out Poole's deal and return to the fray with renewed vigour and a decisively different strategy to that pursued so far. But the point of this article is to demonstrate that while some poor settlements can be justified under certain circumstances, the proposed ambulance deal is only "staggering" in the literal sense of the word (ie. weak-kneed), Roger Poole has done me, personally, one big favour: his actions over the last few days encouraged me to re-read Farrell Dobbs' splendid "Teamster Rebellion'. In this book, Dobbs describes a disappointing deal that he and other militant Teamster leaders were forced, reluctantly, to recommend to the membership:
"Unlike the snake-oil seller's pitch with which the AFL (American Federatoin of Labour, cf British TUC) official had presented the coal settlement the previous February, this proposal. was frankly described as a compromise with the bosses. What it did and did not accomplish with respect to the original union demands was forthrightly and fully discussed...Recognising that they had won a limited victory...the strikers voted to accept."
Someone should tell Roger Poole about snake-oil.
----- pull-quotes -----
THE UMIONIS By Sleeper