Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Below the belt LEST HEARNES

Socialist Organiser no. 436, 1 March 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 960 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Prague, November '89 "But still I'm glad. Oh, I'm glad, I'm glad!" And sad, like one who knows she'll soon be In fifty years but two such Springs she's had And all her adult life was spent in bondage, To Hitler, then to Stalin, then to Stalin's And now she's old and ending, life begins! Old worker in our "workers' state", who nevs And maybe never cared quite what the answer In Prage, November nineteen eighty nine, When Stalin's heirs had reached the end of the nam and back in the States, which play on our own fear of paralysis, of neglect, of helplessness. After the battle in which Kovic is wounded, the military hospital can't cope with the numbers pouring in. As he lies, shattered, on a bunk, a chaplain comes to him with the words "No-one's free to deal with you right now. All you can do is try, to stay alive. Just try to stay alive.

Kovic is first both terrified and bewildered; his life has unravelled overnight. Then he goes through anger and drunken self pity all the way down to the hell pit of despair. He claws his way back by joining the anti-war movement, by trying to stop the war that wrecked him.

This is the weakest part of the movie. We never really know why Brutal enfeebled heirs in brigandage;

Knew that we approved (reluctantly)

Was, about their place in history...

Sean Matgamna SICJENICE The Gardner report on leukaemia cases around Sellafield seems at first sight to answer an important question.

There are more cases of childhood leukaemia around Sellafield (and three other nuclear sites) than expected. Leukaemia can be caused by exposure to radiation and yet, according to British Nuclear Fuels at least, there was insufficient evidence of radiation leaks to explain the observed levels of these cancers.

Other explanations were proposed. One, that radiation leaks had been greater than claimed, was popular with opponents of nuclear power but less so with BNFL. Another, that some sort of virus infection was responsible, had the merit of accounting for clusters of leukaemia in places remote from nuclear installations, though no specific virus could be identified. In any event, the coincidence of nuclear power and leukaemia at Sellafield was too great for the virus theory to be taken seriously.

Now the Gardner report points the finger back at Sellafield, showing a statistical relation between exposure to radiation of men working in the plant and the incidence of leukaemia in their children. It seems that where men were exposed to 10 milliSieverts (mSv) in a six-month period, their children ran a 6-8fold greater risk of contracting leukaemia, up from 1 in 2000 to 1 in 300. It should be emphasised that this exposure is less than the "permitted level of 50mSv per year.

The report also points towards a possible mechanism for these leukaemias. It surmises that radiation may have caused mutations in sperm cells so that the resulting children became ill. But this theory raises several other questions.

Why should these mutations cause leukaemia and not other cancers or genetic disorders? And why was no similar excess of leukaemia found in the children of the far larger group of men exposed to radiation in the Hiroshima and Nagasaki explosions? Furthermore, is it feasible that a tiny dose of radiation to the genitals could have this effect? Remember, the dose of 10mSv is that received by the whole body.

These paradoxes have strengthened the arguments of those trying to dismiss the Gardner findings. BNFL has announced its own survey into clusters of childhood leukaemia around Sellafield and elsewhere, as well as appointing a prominent scientist to review the Gardner team's findings.

More important is, or rather should be, the action proposed by BNFL and you might suppose that BNFL would take seriously the possibility that the exposure of its workers to radiation might harm their children. Indeed, BNFL is to "attempt" to reduce radiation exposure not by increasing shielding or by introducing mechanical aids for the more dangerous tasks but by rotating workers in "hot" areas.

They are also going to use "volunteers" from those who have completed their families or who do not wish to have one.

This would not prevent mutated sperm. Sperm haye a fairly short life and it is likely to be radiation exposure over short periods which will damage them. Any children conceived during these periods, notwithstanding the intentions of the couples, will therefore be at risk.

BNFL are not the only authority responsible for the health of nuclear industry workers. The National Radiological Protection Board also has an important role. It was two years ago that the NRPB recommended a reduction in the maximum yearly exposure from 50mSv to 15mSv. This was in light of evidence that the Japanese A-bomb victims had suffered more from low level radiation than previously thought. However, the NRPB can claim little credit since they have done little to get their recommendation adopted.

Apart from the above steps, BNFL has offered to counsel any of its workers who may be worried and its director of health and safety proffered the profound advice that such workers should just not have children. Admittedly, BNFL quickly disavowed this callous and indeed useless piece of advice. It is stating the obvious to say that more research is necessary. For instance, it may be that the radiation damage to the sperm is due to radioactive elements absorbed by the body and concentrated in the genital region. Thus, records of whole body exposure may be underestimating the dose to the sperm-making cells.

In the meantime, it is imperative that maximum exposure levels be reduced to those recommended by NRPB, if not lower, regardless of the operational difficulties to BNFL.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 436

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →