Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Deep in the pain of Vietnam

Socialist Organiser no. 436, 1 March 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 1,059 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

reviews two new films about the Vietnam opens in London on 2 March, and "Casualties of War"

You can't protect yourself from Born on the Fourth of July'; the film simply tramples down any defences.

It taps unerringly into our own fears of death, disfigurement and disability and forces us not just to face them, but to feel them in all their stomach churning terror Oliver Stone's movie, which is based on the autobiographical book 'Born on the Fourth of July' by disabled Vietnam veteran Ron Kovic, takes us well beyond understanding into an intense emotional identification with Kovic. You don't just see what happened to him in Vietnam and later; you feel it in your guts.

Kovic at first isn't particularly likeable. We see him first as a warobsessed youngster, then as the ultra competitive teenager who wants to prove his manhood by going off to war. He's amazingly gung ho, eager to serve his country, desperate to stop the Commies.

So he volunteers for the Martines, goes to Vietnam, and meets the sniper's bullet that will almost destroy his lite.

Kovic took it in the chest, and came home paralysed, came home to a world he no longer fitted. Antiwar protestors were burning the flag he revered, the veterans' hospital he entered was filthy, underfunded, and unsympathetic. The mostly black staff were not uncaring, but they were revved up about their own struggle for civil rights and not wanting to be treated like menials any more.

No horror film has ever frightened me as much as this one. It's not the war scenes that are so horrific; it's the hospital ones, both in VietKovic switched from gung ho supporter of the war to prominent opponent. Was it because of the indiscriminate killing of Vietnamese, which he saw at first hand, or because of what happened to him, or because he lost his faith in a country that could lie to him? It could be any of these, but my guess is that Kovic did it to save his own life, to give it meaning and purpose after scraping bottom.

'Born' isn't a film about Vietnam; it's about what happened to one guy there, and how he saw the war. As such, it's a limited vision. left them rot... to But it it isn't wide, it's deep, and the insights we get into the life and feelings of someone who was a casualty of war ring true. They're painful.

I have rarely seen anything as harrowing as the return of the injured Kovic to his tamily home. His family gather round in welcome, trying to pretend everything is normal, yet knowing that nothing will ever be the same again.

Tom. Cruise is simply extraordinary in this part. We see him change from an open, eager, hopeful boy into a bewildered, frightened and angry man and he's never less than believable. Some of his scenes are unbearably sad; they stab you to the heart.

The view is one-sided; we're not asked to pity the Vietnamese. Yet this is an important story to tell. The American government used up men like Kovic, wrecked their bodies and their lives, then left them to rot while they tried to bury the memory of the war. Stories like this stop us from discounting the human cost of war. "Casualties of War' poses the question "What constitutes murder in war time?" and proceeds to show us. Based on a real incident in the Vietnam war, it relates the story of an army patrol who kidnapped a Vietnamese girl from a village and forced her to accompany them on a long march. The men wanted her as "portable R and R" , someone they could rape when they felt like it.

The patrol consisted of five men, led by the brutal sergeant Meserve. Only one man, Erickson, refused to participate in the rape of the girl. Tortured by guilt, he tried to show the girl kindness and help her escape, despite threats and intimidation from the rest of the men.

The film is a study of someone trying desperately to hang on to his humanity in the face of war, the greatest inhumanity of all, yet it's full of ironies.

Erickson shoots and kills the *enemy" without even thinking about it; he's been "programmed to kill" all right. But the war is one compartment. The girl belongs in another, the one where he keeps his family and his home and his religion, the compartment that looks at evil and says "It ain't right""

Erickson hasn't let himself become as brutalised as the others. To him, war and the ever present threat of death are no excuse to "act as if you can do anything" For him, lurking annihilation is a powerful reason to try to do what is right, rather than give in to evil.

This is a very moral film, one that argues the case for doing right. Even in war time, it says, rape is rape, murder is murder. Erickson's only reward is his feeling of acting rightly. Most people turn against him; he's ridiculed, threatened and attacked.

The film is scathing about the army's ability to regulate itself. How Tom Cruise as Ron Kovic can you ever control men you've trained to be killing machines? How and where do you draw the line?

Fairly generously, it seems. The top brass were desperate for a cover up. They didn't want the story to get out and to make them look bad.

If truth is the first casualty of war, it wasn't the only one in this story. The girl, the pathetic victim of army brutality, was a casualty, and Erickson too, forever guilt ridden about his failure to save herwas scarred. Meserve and his men were also casualties; brutalised by a war that warped their souls.

Both these films are anti-war, or anti the Vietnam war; "Born' because of what it did to American men's bodies, 'Casualties of War' because it wrecked American men's souls. Neither film looks at the why of American involvement; they simply deplore the how. We'll have a long wait before we get a wider view, or a view from the other side.

----- pull-quotes -----

war, 'Born on the Fourth of July', which

"The American government used men like Kovic, wrecked their bodies and their lives, then

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 436

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →