Tunnelling for profit
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Given that failure would C a ruin all involved, it's no surprise that the impasse over the building of the Channel Tunnel was resolved, for a while anyway.
But it was bad. The company running the Tunnel project, Eurotunnel, is technically bankrupt. A court had ordered it to pay £62 million to the building contractors' consortium TML, and it only had £30 million.
The banks would not bail out Eurotunnel until an agreement to cut future costs was signed by Eurotunnel and TML, and TML refused to sign until Eurotunnel boss Alistair Morton was sacked.
Meanwhile British Rail has given up and declares that it cannot build a highspeed rail link from the Tunnel to London unless the government helps it out with El billion. Without that rail link, the Tunnel won't be much use. So much for the Tory Government's prize demonstration on how the free market can tackle major infrastructure projects!
It was never really a free market project, of course. There was never any question of a number of different companies building different Channel Tunnels as competing companies built parallel railway lines in the 19th century - and competing so that the market would decide who had done the best job. The whole affair was licensed, regulated, and decided on by the Governments of Britain and France.
The "free market" bit is that Eurotunnel is a private company, raising money from private investors, and reckoning on covering its costs and making a profit by charging a "market" rate for the use of the Tunnel once it is built.
This means that charges for the Tunnel - and, correspondingly, rail fares between London and Paris will be much higher than they need have been.
The banks which have invested in Eurotunnel will demand big, fat dividends once the Tunnel opens, to compensate them for the time their money has been tied up and the risk they have run. The risks may not be all that big in reality, since the banks would surely have enough political clout to force even the most dogmatically free market Government into a bail-out if the Tunnel project really did collapse — but certainly the banks are demanding compensation for the risk.
They should be able to get it, because the rail route should be quicker than air and much quicker than ferry, enabling Eurotunnel to push up the charges without limit short of making the rail fare much dearer than air. Passengers and consumers of everything transported through the Tunnel - will paThe Tunnel will make rail fares more expensive. It will, however, make ferry fares cheaper, as the ferry firms cut costs and squeeze their workers to stay competitive. Hence the 'Herald of Free Enterprise' disaster at Zeebrugge and the Dover P&O seafarers' dispute - all part of the magic of market economics One other social effect of the free market approach will be found in London. Against the wishes of almost everyone living in the areas concerned BR has insisted on siting the Tunnel rail link terminus at Kings Cross rather than Stratford.
Why? Because BR is also selling off vast areas near Kings Cross for property development. It will get a better price if Kings Cross is the cross-Channel terminus. If Stratford is the terminus, the gain in property prices will instead be spread among the landlords and business people of Stratford.
And the redeeming feature of the "free market" approach? It should be that it imposes market discipline and keeps costs down, preventing the huge overruns common on public projects. fact it has done nothing of the sort. The cost of building the Tunnel is now reckoned at £7.2 billion - way above the f6 billion "worst case" forecast, let alone the £4.7 billion initially quoted by TML.
----- pull-quotes -----
THE HIDDEN HAND