Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Nicaragua: a victory for terrorisn

Socialist Organiser no. 436, 1 March 1990 · scan pp. 5–7 · about 4,132 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

the victory of the "UNO"

14-party coalition in the Nicaraguan election is a victory for US military and economic terrorism.

For ten years the rag, tag and bobtail army of the 'contras has conducted a campaign of indiscriminate slaughter from across Nicaragua's border. Without US funding, support and encouragement, the contras would not have existed.

The US government has harassed Nicaragua economically, discriminated against it, and, for half the decade, operated a full-scale trade embargo against it.

It provided anything up to $20 million to finance Ms Chamorro's "UNO" election campaign. No let-up was in sight. Contra killings continued. The economy was in ruins. Most Nicaraguans must have reckoned that they could not hope to continue defying the Yanqui giant alone.

So the voters were under tremendous pressure to vote themselves off the hook. And enough of them did that to give the victory to Chamorro and her allies, who included many conservative parties together with the two segments of the old Nicaraguan Stalinist party.

President Daniel Ortega has promised that the Sandinistas will allow Chamorro and her allies to form a government, and will act as a loyal opposition, defending the gains of the revolution. He has made the handover of power apparently conditional on the prior disarmament of the contra terrorist bands.

What was really going on in the Nicaraguan election was portrayed plainly by the way the TV and newspapers reported the result. They went straight to George Bush for a comment, as if he were the real opposition to the Sandinistas.

The strangeness of the world we live in was shown in another way, too: Henry Kissinger was brought in, as a great philosopher-cumelder-statesman of the American system, to offer his thoughts about the prospects for Nicaraguan democracy. This was the same Kissinger who was, with Richard Nixon, responsible for bombing Cambodia into the Stone Age and thus indirectly for the genocidal Khmer Rouge. He is a greater war criminal than most of the Nazis hanged at the end of the Second World War.

Much of the television coverage was crudely biased: one news programme claimed, quite untruly that it was the first election called by the Sandinistas since they overthrew the Somoza dictatorship in 1979.

Yet, in one sense, the outcome of the election may be the best thing for the Nicaraguan people now. Given the relentless ten year war on them - and that is what it was -by the American government, there was no way out for this small country, with its ruined economy.

The formation of a Chamorroled coalition government must force the US to stop the war and give "aid", which in fact will amount to some reparations for their war on Nicaragua.

A Chamorro government does not necessarily mean an end to the Sandinista revolution. The Sandinistas still have great strength and resources. The army and state apparatus is Sandinista, and it is improbable that it will allow itself to be purged and broken up.

The Sandinistas are by far the biggest party, with over 40 per cent of the vote. Against them is arrayed an improbable coalition, ranging from old-line Stalinists to rightwingers. It will have great difficulty staying together as a ruling coalition, even should great US financial support be forthcoming.

Effectively the Sandinistas will still have state pewer, or a large share of it. Any attempt to change that quickly and drastically would mean an immediate civil war, which the Sandinistas would clearly win.

What is opening up, therefore, is the beginning of an evolution towards something rare in Latin America: a representative democratic system. With justice the Sandinistas claim to have won that for the Nicaraguan people, through their revolution against the USsponsored Somoza dictatorship and their ten year war for the integrity and independence of the country.

The Sandinistas and their revolution have always been a shifting mixture of contradictory things. The movement began in the '60s as a Castroist guerrilla current, with essentially Stalinist politics. It then divided, and the "Tercerista" faction, led by Daniel Ortega and his brother, worked out a broader strategy to overthrow Somoza in alliance with bourgeois and other forces:

The Somoza family had ruled Nicaragua since the 1930s — father, older brother, and then the younger brother chased out in 1979 - and ran the country as a family farm, squeezing out much of the bourgeoisie. The "Terceristas" put together a broad coalition including large sections of the bourgeoisie.

The Sandinista army was the spearhead of the battle against the dictatorship, but there was a mass movement, and it was partly organised by the bourgeoisie. For example, the 1979 general strike was supported and partly organised by the bourgeoisie.

When Somoza fled, the armed power in the country was the Sandinista movement. They immediately started to create a structure in which their party-army reconstructed the state around itself - that is, they moved towards a Stalinist-type state.

The bourgeoisie who had allied with the Sandinistas Ms Chamorro for example — moved into opposition in 1980. Though at first viewed with comparative favour by the Carter administration in the US, the Sandinistas soon came under vicious attack from the Reagan administration and its "contra" proxies.

Yet the Sandinistas simply Stalinists. While Chamorro government do not necessarily the end of the Sandinista revolution. The Sandinistas still have great strength and will allow itself to be purged and broken up".

ties to Cuba and supported the Soviet Union on most foreign policy issues — for example, the invasion of Afghanistan — the Sandinistas also showed that they were trying to avoid grafting full Stalinism onto Nicaragua. They did not want to go the whole Cuban way; they were genuinely committed to a degree of pluralism.

They did contradictory things. They allowed private enterprise to survive on a large scale while banning strikes for long periods.

The US-contra offensive crippled and warped the development of the revolution. Now, paradoxically, there may be a chance for things to straighten out.

There is a rough parallel in the Irish Free State in the '20s and '30s. Sinn Fein split over the 1921 Treaty, dictated at gunpoint by Britain. The "Free Staters" • predecessors or today's Fine Gael party, accepted the Treaty. Republicans, forerunners of both today's Fianna Fail party of Charles Haughey and the Provisional IRA, opposed it.

Civil war followed for a year, very bitter and destructive. The Free State state machine was constructed by the Fine Gael party (to use its present name) to repress the others.

Yet in the mid-'20s Fianna Fail became a legal opposition (the IRA spit ott), and in 1932 won a parliamentary majority. Fine Gael let them take power peacefully.

There was then a period of great tension, and a few state officials were purged. The Fianna Fail government relied on the unofficial army, the IRA, until the mid-'30s. But things settled into a sort of democratic two-party system.

No two cases are the same, of course; and the destruction and damage has been greater in Nicaragua than in Ireland. Yet the parallel does indicate that not all is lost, by any means, for the Sandinista revolution in Nicaragua.

The Sandinistas are populist nanonalists, not working clas socialists. They have organisec trade unions, but then so have many petty bourgeois nationalist groupings. How the Sandinistas will evolve now is far from clear.

Against brutal American bullying they are entitled to the support of socialists everywhere. But socialists should not confuse the issues of national self-determination and of class politics.

In Nicaragua socialism will develop by way of the independence of the working class from both the bourgeois pro-US forces represented by Chamorro and the populist nationalists of the FSLN,

Scan page 6

6 SOCIALISM Bradley outlines Socialist liser stands for of two parts).

The think tanks of the Western world say socialism is dead. In the last few months, regimes which for nearly half a century had claimed to be socialist have been forced, by huge popular opposition, to step aside. They are leaving socialism, as they and their advocates in the West had defined. it, in ruins.

In contrast, Western capitalism, they say, is a system of democracy and liberty, economic efficiency and political treedom.

This conclusion is shared by those like Mrs Thatcher who want to let free-market capitalism rip, and those like Neil Kinnock who think it can and should be tamed. Socialism is dead, long live capitalism.

There is an alternative view, not given much publicity, that the opposite is true. It is totalitarianism that is dead, or dying - not socialism. Socialism is being reborn. The end of the totalitarian parody of socialism will give real socialists a new chance.

Socialist Organiser subscribes to this view. For our whole existence we have insisted that the regimes of Eastern Europe are not socialist. We want real workers liberty, East Homeless in London and West: real control by working class people over their lives, over their communities and workplaces, over government and the economy. We want a society without rich and poor; without bigotry, without racism, where women are recognised as equal to men, where different nations don't blow each other to bits, but live together democraticalAll this is what we mean by socialism.

Those in the East today who believe that capitalism can fulfil their dreams of prosperity and freedom will find they are wrong. Capitalism is not only the economic success stories of West Germany and Japan: it is the disaster of population is regimes to rentine almost an the plant from which cocaine is made; it is the catastrophe of Ethiopia, endlessly hit by famine; it is the death squads of El Salvador.

For every person in Western capitalism who is comfortable and well-off, there are thousands who are starving, have no homes, have seen their countries ravaged by senseless wars. For every capitalist country with a parliamentary democracy, there is one with a military dictatorship. Some that are democracies now were dictatorships less than twenty years ago, even in Europe: countries like Spain, Greece and Portugal.

And even the richest capitalist countries contain within them massive inequalities. Every US city has ghettos of appalling poverty, where kids survive by selling crack to each other. Every major European city has a huge pool of unemployed.

On the streets of London it is now commonplace to see teenagers sitting in doorways wrapped in sleeping bags. Everyone knows that in the inner cities, the majority is poor, and in many cases getting poorer.

In the West as in the East, society is divided into classes. There are those with wealth and power, and those without it.

In Britain today, we elect the government. But no one elects the top civil servants. No one elects the bankers. No one elects the army top brass. Socialism would be a society in which all these things, government and the economy, administration and defence, are under the control of working class people.

A socialist movement aims to organise the powerless in society to fight militantly for their interests against the rich and powerful. It aims to break the power of big business, the Tories and their backers, and replace it with the real, democratic rule of the majority. Fanatics and democrats Socialist Organiser aims help bulld such movement.

Socialist Organiser is a legitimate part of the Labour Party and the labour movement. It is a Marxist newspaper: though that's an unfashionable thing to be. Throughout the history of the labour movement in Britain, Marxlists have been active. One of the earliest real rank and file unions was organised by one of Karl Marx's daughters. From the birth of the Labour Party, there have been Marxist newspapers and organisations trying to influence the wider movement.

The word 'Marxist' conjures up either wild-eyed fanatics with secret arms supplies in their bedsits, or Causescu clones whose sole ambition in life is to force everyone else to eat black bread and wear drab uniforms. And unfortunately, some people who have seen themselves Marxists have rather lived up these stereotypes.

But Marx himself was not fighting for anything Ceausescu would have recogised. He was no secret plotter or supporter of nasty dictatorships. He was a revolutionary democrat who worked out a theory of how capitalist society works, and how working class struggle against it can develop.

Marxists try to understand the overall interests of the working class, to unite the working class movement, and think ahead. As Marx put they represent the movement of the future' in the movement of the present. Marxists try to bring the lessons of the whole history of the international working class struggle to the struggles of today.

For example, in Eastern Europe, real Marxists are trying to convince the mass democracy movements that capitalism is not the answer they are looking for. Marxists try to provide an overview of capitalism and totalitarianism.

Unless Marxists convince the mass movement, they will get nowhere. Marxists aim to achieve the rule over society by its majority - something which can't be imposed by small groups of people. Indeed, one of Marx's distinctive contributions to socialist theory was to challenge the dominant view of his day, that socialism would be brought about by 'conspirators'. No, said Marx: we need to win the mass working class movement.

For socialists today, after all the abominations of the Eastern European and Chinese regimes, it is important to reassert the connection between socialism and democracy.

Ours is a socialism of more democracy than exists in Britain today, not less.

What kind of democracy! Over an overse in, all aross the world, workers have formed workers' councils, which can take control of enterprises, localities, and if linked together nationally, the whole country. Representatives in these councils are accountable to the people who elected them: they can be recalled if they are not acting according to their electors' wishes, they don't get paid more than the average worker, and posts are rotated. We want a democracy based on these kinds of institutions, rather than inadequate Westminster-style parliaments, where the people we elect can ignore us for the next five years, and anyway have less real power than the permanent civil service.

Parliament is better than no democracy at all, of course. And in reality it is the ruling class that considers parliament expendable. It is now well-known that the "security forces', like MIS, have plotted to bring down elected Labour govern.

ments in the past, and would do so again: that was the revelation contained in the book Spycatcher' that Mrs Thatcher most anxiously wanted kept secret. Top army officers are on record as having planned "if necessary' to organise a military coup against the last Labour government: "if law and order and national security were under threat as they defined them.

We believe that every democratic freedom we have in Britain, which was won by struggle, is essential for the working class and the labour movement./ We believe that democracy in Britain and elsewhere needs to be defended, and we have to fight against all sorts of erosions of our civil liberties. Democracy must be extended. All we say is that parliamentary democracy is not the only kind, and that something better is possible.

Socialism means also economic democracy, abolishing the inequalities of capitalism. Capitalism causes inequality. It is a system based on exploitation: that is, some people, the majority, work to produce society's wealth, while others get most of the wealth that is produced. A tiny proportion of society own most of its wealth. 200 or so monopolies control 80% of production in Britain. 10% of the population own over 50% of the country's marketable wealth.

The purpose of production, in capitalist society, is profit. Goods are not made just because people need them: a profit has to be possible. It is because of profit that the inner cities rot; it simply doesn't pay to build decent houses (or houses at all, these days) or provide people with jobs.

It is because of profit that the health, education, transport and other services have been cut. They don't make enough money.

It is because of profit - the "market' so beloved of Thatcher -that the Third World is starving. Many Third World countries export only one basic commodity. If its price on the world market falls, the Third World economy suffers. The country has to borrow from foreign banks which insist on an 'austerity programme' - spending cuts, unemployment.

There's no money to be made in aid to the starving. So they're left to rot, by governments and private enterprise, and charities foot the Even in the richer Third World countries, like Brazil, local profiteers make millions while the majority of society still ekes out a living in saualid shanty towns. According to recent reports, in the shanties of Rio de Janeiro, unwanted and homeless children are being shot in the streets like dogs. There are - literally - millions of such children swarming in the streets of Brazil.

Socialism aims to replace the principle of private profit with democratic planning to meet society's needs.

The Thatcher decade M people now hope to god illions of working class that Thatcher will lose the next general election and that the Labour Party will win it. So do we: and supporters of Socialist Organiser will be campaigning for a Labour victory in the future as we have in the past.

How have the Thatcher years shaped Britain? Was she as invincible as she sometimes seemed to be?

How have different political forces changed over the past Thatcherite decade?

Thatcher was elected in 1979, after five years of a Labour government that had promised to squeeze the rich until their pips squeak' fact, that Labour government, after doing a deal with the International Monetary Fund, launched a proGluttony in the City gramme of cuts in health, education and welfare that the Tories only continued. Moreover, through its "social contract' , a deal this time with the trade union leaders, the Labour government presided over -years of wage restraint and decline -in workers' living standards.

Scan page 7

It was a public sector revolt against the government's wages policy, the so-called 'winter of discontent' , that forced it to call an lection, which it lost.

So the Labour government funcioned in fact as a thoroughly capitalist government, trying to run the country' without in any ray challenging the centres of economic power. Harold Wilson, Who was Prime Minister until 1976, nd had been Prime Minister from 964-70, recounts in his memoirs ow, in a conversation with the irector of the Bank of England, he ras told that the Labour governent would not be allowed to carry ut its manifesto promises, which ere considered too damaging to hig business' interests.

By neither fighting that be, nor defending the interests of the people who had elected it with high hopes, atter deteating the Tory government of Edward Heath), the Labour government succeeded only in demoralising its own supporters. The result was a big Tory victory, and the beginning of Thatcherism.

But it was by no means inevitable that Thatcher would still be in power eleven years on. It was possible to beat her — with mass campaigns and trade union muscle.

There were campaigns. Liverpool and Glasgow saw huge demonstrations against unemployment in the early 1980s. The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND) mobilised thousands against the siting of Cruise missiles in Britain, Polaris missiles elsewhere in Europe, and the development of abortion Corrie Bill, in 1979, was successful.

And there were strikes. In 1980, there was a big strike by workers in a central industry - steel. Steel workers chanted slogans for the TUC to call a general strike.

But the steel workers were defeated, and following their defeat, employment in the steel industry decimated. A pattern had been set. But the Tories still didn't get it all their own way. During the health service dispute of 1982, once again demands were raised for a general strike, and for a day — in September - there was the most widely-supported strike action of recent years.

The biggest battle of all was to come after the Tories had been reelected in 1983. In March 1984, in response to a deliberate provocation by the National Coal Board, a strike spread across the coal industry. The miners' strike was to last almost exactly a year. It was a decisive turning point in the recent history of Britain, summing up all the lessons of the struggle against Thatcher.

The miners lost, with terrible consequences for their communities. But they didn't need to lose. The Torie s and the NCB knew it wasn't an easy matter to beat the miners: they had shied away from confrontation before, and during the strike did everything they could to stop other sections of workers joining the miners on strike. Railworkers and others got much more favourable pay settlements than they would have otherwise; and Liverpool City council was bought off at the height of the summer when it looked like there could be a city-wide general strike against the government.

So why did the miners lose? Because of the abject failure of the labour movement as a whole to stand by them. Serious solidarity action could have stopped the Tories; a general strike could have defeated them. But the trade union leaders didn't lift a finger to help the NUM. Neil Kinnock sat on the fence, only timidly supporting the miners; solidarity actions remained isolated.

The miners' defeat showed up the weaknesses of the organisations of the labour movement. These organisations, the trade unions and the Labour Party, while still quite strong (Britain has a great many more trade union members, proportionately, than most countries, even after a fall in membership as a result of mass unemployment), were simply not up to the task of building solidarity and standing up to the Tories. They 'bottled out'. If we are not to see defeat after defeat, the trade unions and the Labour Party will have to be radically changed Changed how? They need to be more democratic, more responsive to their members' needs. Officials often aren't elected, and some have been there for years. The leaders who usually don't identify with their own rank and file much, and often get paid massively more, should not only be made more accountable, but got rid of: the trade unions need new leaders, who are committed to the notion of strug gle.

The NUM Leaders proved very unusual during the strike, because they really did fight with everything they had. Yet even they had serious shortcomings. Despairing of real help from the other trade union leaders, Scargill called over their heads for a general strike, but there was no organisation in the unions, independent of the inert leaders, who could even begin to deliver such solidarity. That also needs to change: we need a rank and file movement, organising the militant activists, within and across the trade unions.

In the Labour Party, too, the feebleness of the leadership's support for the miners indicated, once again, the need for big changes.

There had already been attempts at change. Many people in the Labour Party had concluded from the Wilson-Callaghan years that there was only one way to avoid repeating them: greater accountability and democracy in the Party. In carrying out their cuts and IMF plans, the Labour leaders had defied Labour Party policy. That should never be allowed to happen again.

The individual who best represented this new Labour Left, with its focus on Party democracy, was Tony Benn, who in 1981 narrowly missed being elected deputy leader. Already, by then, the Left had won significant victories: Labour Party leader and deputy leader were, after 1980, to be elected by Party conference, rather than just MPs, and there was to be automatic reselection of the MPs, so no one could be in a safe seat for life without ever being held to account by his or her local party. Socialist Organiser played a significant part in these democracy battles: we initiated a united campaign of the whole Left, the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy, which was decisive in getting the democratic reforms pushed through.

But we also warned that a lot more needed to be done. The Labour Left was strong in the local Labour parties, but not in the trade unions. And the democracy campaign needed to be linked to a more radical challenge to the policies of the Labour leaders. Accountability was important, but not enough: Labour needed to be able to fight the banks and monopolies Continued next week

----- pull-quotes -----

resources. The army and state apparatus is Sandinista, and it is improbable that it

Britain's 'independent deterrent' The campaign against the anti-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 436

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →