Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Be war we could have won Exactly five…]

Socialist Organiser no. 436, 1 March 1990 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,630 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Be war we could have won Exactly five years ago the miners' strike ground to an exhausted end after twelve bitter and glorious months.

They were glorious months, because during them the miners and their families showed again the mind and spirit that first made the labour movement.

All the courage, determination, far-sightedness and individual self-sacrifice which animated the pioneers who made a great selfbettering labour movement out of suffering and downtrodden masses of workers was shown to be still alive in the mining communities -and in great abundance. The year-long strike was like an encapsulated history of the labour movement of the previous 150 years.

The miners challenged the whole dog eat dog philosophy of the Tories, and put up against it a broadly socialist philosophy which rejected the rule of the profit motive in the pits, and proclaimed that people must come before profits. In response, they were hit with everything the ruling class needed to hit them with in order to beat them When miners' leader Arthur Scargill said that the coal bosses planned to close half the pits in Britain — as they have since done - he was called a liar and a scaremongerThe emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA ask: 01 639 7965 r reports: first post ing agitator. The Tory government then organised a nationally controlled and coordinated army of militarised police thugs and unleashed them on the miners.

Often the police ignored the rule of law in their efforts to stop miner pickets and their supporters moving about the country. They illegally stopped people exercising their right as citizens to travel. Margaret Thatcher commented that if the law was not sufficient to cover what the police were doing, well then the government would make new laws — as many new laws as were necessary to win the class struggle.

Police thugs acted like armies of onghamshire mining villaghe NotThe miners fought back, the women and young people with the men, in a series of pitched battles — battles like that at Orgreave, where miners were beaten down by a powerful force of highly-trained state thugs armed with the most up-to-date equipment.

The glorious miners and their families held out against the harassming ad iole screate state adehatemongering venom of the opinionformers in the media, whose chief stock in trade was to denounce the "violence" of the miner victims of the massive state violence, which had been planned and prepared years before.

That outcry against miners' violence alienated a lot of potential sympathy and support miners. It was one of th e biggest frame-ups in British histor Monday 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not ecessarily refirct the views of Socialist Organiser min late but They were 12 bitter months, too, and not only because of the suffering and hardship of the miners and their families. They bore all that without whingeing, in the hope of winning things they considered important.

The real bitterness of those months lies in this - that the miners could have won, and didn't. The working class could have won, and didn't. We could have beaten the Tories, but instead they beat us, and the Tories still rule Britain.

To do what could have been done, the miners needed the active support of other workers. We needed a labour movement led by people came possessed of the normal human feeling of pride in themselves and in the movement they led, the feeling of responsibility towards it combined with the elementary courage to defend the movement and themselves.

But our movement was led by people who acted as if they had none of those things. The trade union leaders left the miners in the lurch. Some of them plainly wanted Arthur Scargill to get a beating far more than they wanted Thatcher to be beaten.

Where solidarity was needed, they gave sage advice to the union about "moderation" and non-violence". When the striking miners fought for the right to picket out scabs and defended themselves ARIE against Thatcher's semi-militarised police sent to stop them, other union leaders joined in the media's condemnation of "violence" that is, the miners' violence...

The leaders of the Labour Party did that too. The miners defending themselves were condemned; the police violence was accepted as "normal" and proper by those who had just led Labour to defeat in the 1983 general election.

When the miners' strike started, Thatcher had had almost five years in office, using the state power as a weapon in the class war to grind down the labour movement. The labour movement had had five years of slow cumulative retreat, which added up to a defeat.

Yet the leaders of the labour movement - trade union leaders, Labour Party leaders, and the Labour leaders of local councils — could have taken on and beaten the Tories in 1980 and '81, before the great mass unemployment sapped the confidence, strength, will, and fighting spirit of the labour movement.

They didn't, and the Tory juggernaut rolled over the labour movement, shackling the trade unions, beginning to dismantle the welfare state, undoing the achievements of the 1945-51 Labour government.

The miners' strike came late in the day, when the feeling of defeat had already eaten into the labour movement. But not too late.

If the trade union and Labour leaders had wanted to fight the Tories - if they had faced the Tories with a fraction of that classwar spirit with which the Tories faced us - then the miners' strike could have been the occasion for a great rallying of the forces of organised labour.

They didn't want to fight. The miners were left isolated, abandoned to a slow war of attrition which dragged on through the winter of 1984-85 until, finally, the miners went back to work.

In some places they marched back led by bands behind banners, proud and inwardly undefeated. But it was a defeat nonetheless, an amful and terbie bealuse it need not have happened like that.

Thatcher and Coal Board boss [an MacGregor won. And they behaved like victors in a counterrevolution always do: like pigs. Many hundreds of miners were victimised. Long-established trade union rights were ripped up. A vast programme of pit closures was commenced: in the last five years, more than half the pits in Britain have been closed.

It would be easy after such a defeat, followed by such catastrophic consequences, to find reasons to say the whole thing was a mistake, that Arthur Scargill and the other leaders should have avoided open all-out war with Thatcher and MacGregor. But the miners were not wrong to fight.

Their defeat was not inevitable. They were right in their guiding instinct that the Tories had either to be confronted head on and beaten, or else allowed to get on with their programme of making Britain a better place for the rich and a hell for the poor and vulnerable.

The miners did not just fight for the miners: their challenge to Thatcher was not just about the running of the mines, but also about the running of the country. We all lost a great deal that day five years ago when the miners were forced back to work.

No, the miners eren't wrong to fight - the rest of the movement was wrong not to make sure they won.

Karl Marx — writing about a far bigger event, the sezure or powe) by the working class in Parıs ın 1871 (the Paris Commune) - also answered our own wiseacres who let the miners be defeated without doing anything to help them and then crowed that the defeat proved that they could not have won and should not have fought.

*World history would indeed be very easy to make if the struggle were taken up only on condition that the prospects were unmistakably favourable". (Letter to Kugelman, April 1871)The Tory response to the ambulance workers. Ambulance driver David Mollant leaflets Conservative Party Conference.

Scan page 4

GRAFFITI The image of doctors miming the extraction of vital organs to immigrants who speak not a word of English is not an appealing one.

Yet this, it seems, is what an anaesthetist did in order to obtain the permission of a Turkish immigrant to remove one of his kidneys. Considerately, they were going to pay him for it, though whether at any time they mimed handing over cash has not been revealed.

Anyone who has every played charades might know that miming is not easy. You stand up to explain that it's a film and a book, with four words, and even after they know that the second word is 'exit' some idiot still hasn't got the hang of syllables. Ten minutes later, you're tearing offensive is recipe intolerance.

But you will note the Labour leaders keeping their heads down on this, as on everything to do with the 'Rushdie affair'.

Mark Fisher, shadow spokesperson on the arts, was invited to take part on Newsnight to comment on Rushdie's most recent writing -his article in the Independent on Sunday, and his Herbert Read memorial lecture.

After a shadow cabinet meeting, Fisher declined the offer.

Labour is afraid, of course, of losing Muslim votes. But they can't believe they will keep the respect of the Muslim community if they just keep their mouths shut. Fence-sitting neve won anyone an election. M responsible for the arx was no more gulag than Nietzsche (Photo: Paul Herrman, Profile). *The Saints' and the "Z-Cars" theme. The audience applauded en-

----- pull-quotes -----

Th WhORIAL

day... late"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 436

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →