Ambulance stewards back leadership
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
arom now on there's no hiding place!" So spoke NUPE'S Roger Poole, unveiling the latest union tactics in the ambulance dispute to a packed stewards meeting in London last Wednesday.
With 250 stewards present, representing every ambulance service in the country, it was an ideal opportunity to take stock of the dispute, and map out a path to victory. What, in fact, emerged at the meeting was somewhat different.
The new tactic of "total non-cooperation with management" was immediately announced by Poole, and discussion from the floor was from then on wards dominated by assessing its implications. From the platform, Poole and the other four union full-timers present made it clear that other issues, such as a national strike ballot or solidarity action, were not up for debate.
"Non-cooperation" is essentially a drive to increase the number of crews suspended, from the current 50% level, by refusing to take instructions from senior ambulance officers. It appears that the union leadership has called a major escalation of the dispute - and this may well be the case.
The new course, however, has crucial limitations and its implementation could bring major problems.
The most important limitation is the rejection of calls for solidarity action irom other trade unionists. With polls still indicating over 80% support from the general public for the ambulance workers, a call for a TUC one-day general strike would have tremendous resonance in the labour movement. By insisting that the dispute can be won through purely internal escalation, the leadership may well face demoralisation amongst the rank and file if a breakthrough is not achieved in the near future.
This danger is compounded by the method chosen to escalate the action. A drive to increase susensions leaves final control of the escalation firmly in the hands of the Chief Ambulance Officers. They have taken a strictly tactical line approach to suspensions up to now, so that crews taking similar action in different parts of the country have faced differing management reaction. This unevenness in the dispute can cause tension amongst ambulance workers and will come to the fore if crews find it harder to get themselves suspended they thought.
Even if the suspension drive succeeded, there is a danger that the tactic will lead simply to lock-outs, with inadequate emergency cover. As one steward from Lincolnshire put it on Wednesday: *The aim should be to get locked in, not locked out." Unless the unions can secure emergency cover, if necessary by occupying the stations, then serious splits would open up in ambulance workers' ranks.
The alternative - a strike with emergency cover — would unify the action, and stands a better chance of stif fening it in the shire counties, where it has been weakest than calling on hesitant crews to get themselves suspended and locked out.
Why was this strategy put forward by the leadership?
After 24 weeks of the dispute, militant stewards in areas such as London and Liverpool have questioned the leadership's approach and have called for a national strike ballot. It seems that the full-timers used the considerable respect that Roger Poole has with stewards to diffuse this, by getting him to announce straight away the *non-cooperation" tactic. This helped them resist calls for a strike ballot and solidarity action.
The leadership must have known chat once the strategy was announced, the major debate would then be between suspended and non-suspended areas. If that was so, then it was a stupid and dangerous act. Poole was playing with fire.
The unevenness of the dispute is not fundamentally the result of unsuspended crews not pulling their weight, but rather of management tactics.
To tacitly encourage dissension between crews as a way of ensuring the authority of the leadership is very dangerous.
There was one particularly crude atrempt made at the meeting to isolate the London stewards (who have been advocates of solidarity action and an all-out strike). TGWU full-timer Danny Brien, from the chair, accused London of "slagging off the rest of the country" . They, in turn, demanded an immediate retraction of this slur, insisting that they were "slagging him off, not the rest of the country"! An angry walkout of London stewards then took place, which ended only when this charge was withdrawn.
Greater co-ordination is now required between those areas of the country who are in favour of a strike ballot, so that the call cannot be brushed off in the future as easily as it was last Wednesday.
Only a few voices pointed to an alternative way of escalating the dispute: through appeals for solidarity strike action. Poole directly attacked this view by arguing that it was a "cop out" •We are in control of this dispute, it we lose then it will be our fault," said Poole, adding: "We can't go round blaming Normal Willis if we lose this one."
Poole has obviously not been reading January's Nursing Times which makes it quite clear that the government are not in any mood to capitulate.
*The cost of settling the dispute this year with a couple of extra per cent would be minimal. And because any award would be for last year's pay round, it could have no impact on this year's 'going rate', which is already well over the much-quoted 6.5%. The government's real object now is to resist any long-term pay formula and, even more important, not to appear to capitulate in the face of industrial action."
In the face of such determination no amount of bravado is going to convince me that ambulance workers can win on their own. Solidarity action from workers who do have economic and political muscle is going to be needed to force the government to back down.