A tale agreed upon
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
CINEMIA Belinda Weaver reviews 'Cinema Paradiso* Cinema Paradiso' starts with a death, but it's full of life and feeling. Set in Sicily, it's the story of Salvatore, a movie-crazy boy who grows up to be a film maker.
He has escaped into a world wider than the small town life of his SICIENICE radiating food with large doses of gamma rays kills all known bacteria and fungi. It could thus eliminate much of the food poisoning bacteria that have been causing such problems recently.
Yet most people fear irradiation of food. Out of 7000 polled recently in Britain, 51% thought irradiated food would be bad for them, 6% more than in a survey 6 months before. Only 8% thought it would be good for them.
Irradiation is supported by the World Health Organisation, the UN's Food and Agricultural Organisation and the International Atomic Energy Agency, as well as the British government's Advisory Committee on Irradiated and Novel Foods (ACINF). Against it are ranged a variety of consumer organisations, including the Consumers' Association and the London Food Committee.
There are really two questions to answer in deciding our attitude to food irradiation: Is it safe and is it necessary?
The process itself is remarkably simple, consisting in the bombardment of the food with up to 10000 grays of gamma rays, X-rays or fast electrons. Just for comparison, this s about 1000 times the dose to kill a numan.
The radiation works breaking childhood, but the death of calls him back to his village.
His journey back there opens up the past, a past he had long left behind him.
The film is obviously autobiographical, but it seems universal. The young Salvatore's pain on first leaving home rings true. Narrow as the life is there, the village is his home, with all the memories and associations that growing up provides. Yet it is also the place he must leave if he is to strike out on his own path through life.
Alfredo never left. Caught up in the spell of the movies he showed, up molecules into reactive fragments, called free radicals. These then career around inside the bacteria, disrupting key molecules, like enzymes and DNA.
These free radicals are of course also produced in the cells of the food. If the food is "alive" , like fresh fruit and vegetables, the normal processes of ripening, sprouting and decay will be delayed or stopped, increasing its "shelf life" and hence its value. Happily, free radicals are "mopped up" in a few seconds and so cannot harm the consumers. However, they can change the composition of the food, altering its taste and perhaps its nutritional value. This is a drawback with any method of tood preparation or preservation. For instance, cooking destroys a large proportion of the Vitamin C in food. Some people will therefore only eat uncooked food, despite the risk of food poisoning attached. I myself tend to eschew the raw potato.
ACINF says that foods that can be irradiated safely without spoiling their taste or smell include poultry, seafood, fruit, vegetables. and spices.
The above drawbacks are rather minor and in any case not exclusive to food irradiation. But does the technique cause the production of harmful chemicals in the irradiated tood!
It is here that the greatest controversy arises.
The expert committees set up by WHO, FAO and IAEA have okayed irradiation at levels up to 10000 grays, stating it to be a safe method of food preservation which "presents no toxicological hazard and no special nutritional or Alfredo lived in a dream world, with the fatherless Salvatore as his companion and accomplice. Alfredo urges Salvatore to leave, not to waste his life on flickering images and dreams.
But was it the right choice for Salvatore? If success is getting what something else, it's wanting what you get. Perhaps Alfredo had had the best of it after all.
Home again for Alfredo's funeral, Salvatore begins to question everything in his life. Haunted by the memories and desires of his younger self whose presence he feels all around him, he is as doubtful and uncertain as any adolescent on microbiological problems. ACINF referred to 40 years research in their conclusion that radiated food was safe to eat.
The London Food Commission, a. radical campaigning group on issues of food quality and safety, criticised these conclusions, saying much of the research quoted has not been published and has therefore not been subject to review by other scientists. The LFC quotes the results of an experiment 15 years ago in India where five severely malnourished children were fed on chapatis made from irradiated wheat.
The children all developed a condition called polyploidy, where some of their cells contained too many chromosomes. Apart from being a rather unethical thing to do to sick children, it is difficult to say what this experiment shows. The polyploidy cleared up after the children were switched to normal food and it is unclear whether there are any health risks attached to it.
Similar experiments on laboratory animals showed polyploidy, as well as damage to sperm, increased incidence of miscarriage and a reduced immune response.
In reply to the LFC's criticism, the WHO suggests that these side effects may be due to loss of vitamins in the irradiated tood, citing as evidence its failure to find ill effects where animals were given vitamin supplements with their irradiated food.
One of the WHO's advisers, German food expert JF Diehl, describes the LFC's criticisms as "a lot of half truth and exaggeration" . He estimates that no more than 5°p of Food will be irradia ed bal Ba the brink of adulthood.
Yet Alfredo was right. Salvatore was right to leave, and there can be no going back for him. His childhood world has vanished, the past is closed. It is too late to regret what might have been. Alfredo's final legacy to Salvatore is the lifeaffirming message he needs to shake off his melancholy.
The film is gentle, touching and nostalgic, funny in parts, sad in others. There wasn't a dry eye in the house by the end, but it's not manipulative or calculating. By the end, you simply feel you know Alfredo and Salvatore, you feel they've been part of your life, the way the movies were part of their hence the whole thing has blown up out of proportion"
Diehl also dismisses the claim that irradiation can be used to make stale or spoilt food palatable. "If it smells, irradiation will make it smell worse.
Professor Campbell-Platt of Reading University says vitamin losses are worse during ordinary cooking and that chemicals produced in food by irradition are produced by ordinary processes, too.
Alan Holmes of the Food Research Association says: "The biggest proof that irradiation is safe is that you can't detect it."
This is not strictly true, though at present the methods being developed are experimental and rather expensive.
The other question still remains, though — is it necessary? The Consumers' Association sees irradiation as a technical fix for a problem of hygiene in the food industry. It is feared that unwholesome food will be disguised.
Obviously, it is better that poor hygiene be remedied, but food contaminated with dead bacteria is not necessarily unwholesome. It depends on whether the bacteria produced any poisons while they were alive.
The other reason for irradiation, to inhibit ripening and increase the shelf life of food, is not necessarily a bad thing either. Many people like exotic fruit, vegetables and spices and these have perforce to be transported large distances before reaching the consumers. If irradiation makes these foods cheaper by reducing wastage, it is difficult to see why it shouldn't be used, as long as the consumers kunw and have ice bf 300 TV Hous That is history but a tale W agreed upon? asked Napoleon Bonaparte.
There is a series of encrusted myths and tales and 'traditional' interpretations, and then there is historical research.
King Alfred burned the cakes, and a thousand years later an academic burns the midnight oil and proves conclusively that it couldn't have happened.
Much of the history current in the labour movement is a matter of tales agreed upon, images projected, and myths. Last Thursday (15th) you could see the old process of myth-furbishing at work in the modern medium of TV.
The Comic Strip's "GLC" told the story of Big Ken Livingstone and his fight against the Dragon Lady Thatcher as it might be bowdlerised into a hack American TV movie. It was extremely funny and very well done, obviously thought up as a successor to the same team's "Strike"
"Strike" was the brilliantly funny story of the miners' strike as it would be recast to meet the "script values" of a typical Hollywood movie. It climaxed with Arthur Scargill making a desperate 160-mile ride from Yorkshire to London, where a benign and smiling Speaker of the House of Commons, dressed like Uncle Sam with a goatee beard, allowed him to take part in the debate and Save the Nation.
The real subject was not the miners" strike, but Hollywood movies.
Second time round, the subject was less Hollywood than the GLC. Ken Livingstone, played by Robbie Coltrane, is a happy beachcomber on the backs of the Thames who stands for the GLC and wins the leadership first time out. He does wonderful things and everyone loves him, except the supernaturally villainous Thatcher.
Whereas the real Livingstone fawned to the Queen in public, this one forms an alliance with a dopey but decent Prince Charles, whom Thatcher sends to the Tower and almost to the scaffold.
It ends with a heroic Livingstone shooting it out with the Army, willing to die in the last ditch for his principles and for the people of London. Then Charles speaks to the soldiers and they all live happily ever after, except Thatcher.
F enioved it enormously. The mythspinning lay not in the invention but in the story's starting point - the assumption that Livingstone stood his ground and fought. He didn't. He spent years promising to fight, and then when i came to it he bottled out on the publicly stated - grounds that anything else would be bad for his career!
Yet there are a lot of people in the labour movement who still think of Livingstone as "the council leader who dared to fight". This very funny film will have reinforced the myth.
One oddity was the appearance of Tony Benn as a retired gunslinger who had lost his bottle but hovered in the background advising Ken. The comedians missed a trike here in not having a robotic gnome playing one of Ken Livingstone's real background advisers Gerry Healy of the WRP, who helped keep Livingstone's paper Labour Herald afloat, providing an editor and other things.
Maybe the Comic Strip plan to do the Gerry Healy Story next, as it might be scripted by Vanessa Redgrave. No doubt Ken Livingstone will have a bit part as a Well Known Name who sits at the great man's feet while the great man makes money from Arab governments by denouncing dissident Arabs and spying on prominent Jews.
LEFT UNITY
Solidarity with the East European REVOLUTION!
unity broadsheet: 30p Unity, c/o 56 Kevan ndham Road, London
----- pull-quotes -----
Alfredo, the town projectionist who first fostered his love of the movies,
you want, then he was more than successful. But happiness is