Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What is the ‘Nomenklatura’?

Socialist Organiser no. 435, 22 February 1990 · scan p. 9 · Duncan Chapel · about 1,175 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: the machine reading had opened with the end of the article beside it and had filed this article's last column as a separate item. Printed 'By Duncan Chapel'. Transcribed from the scan of page 9; the two pull-quotes are left out. 'Trostkyist rightists' and 'Voslenky' (beside 'Voslensky') are as printed.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 9

The ruling bureaucrats in the Stalinist states are often referred to as the ‘nomenklatura’. What does this phrase mean?

Literally, a nomenklatura is a list of names. In the USSR, the nomenklatura is a list of positions whose ranks are confirmed by higher authority. Where did these people come from? How did they get their power?

After the Russian Revolution of 1917, the Russian workers faced terrible odds. Many of the best democrats and socialists perished in the civil war which followed the invasion of the USSR by the armies of many capitalist states. Many of those remaining were taken from the industrial proletariat to become administrators or party officials.

The taking of power did not mean that the workers suddenly gained all the knowledge that their bosses had had before. For military and technical information in particular, Communist Party (CP) members in positions of power became dependent on individuals often hostile to the revolution and to the ideas of the new workers’ state.

As the civil war went on, activity and discussion in the workers’ councils withered away, placing power in the hands of communists in administrative positions, and in the hands of ex-Tsarist officials.

Surrounded by bureaucrats and careerists, many Bolsheviks inside the state machine were far from the workers and their party. They soaked up many of the bureaucrats’ ideas. They began to see themselves not as the workers’ agents against the capitalists or within the state machine, but as intermediaries independent from both classes. Slowly, a conservative layer within the Communist Party was assimilated into the bureaucracy.

Headed by Stalin, the bureaucrats wanted to consolidate their power. They struggled inside the CP against their opponents, and used their hold on the administrative machinery to install their supporters. Stalin invented the system that makes it possible to do this.

From the early ’20s, special departments were created to scrutinise and appoint officials. These were known as the ‘Uchraspred’. They organised dismissals as well as appointments within the nomenklatura, drawing up lists of those who would “return to the workshop or the plow”.

Where positions had to be elected, Stalin’s committees would make “recommendations”. In his 1923 book ‘The New Course’, Leon Trotsky pointed out that the level of appointments had risen to over ten times the number made at the height of the civil war — when elections were harder to organise. “The party is living at two levels. At the top decisions are made; at the bottom information about these decisions is received.”

One further development finalised the power of the nomenklatura, the ‘Lenin Enrolment’. Between Lenin’s death and the following party congress in May 1924, membership rose from around 330,000 to 740,000.

The party was flooded with opportunists who wanted not revolution, but the good positions the Stalin regime could offer. The enrolment was a conscious plan to overwhelm the authority the older party members held.

By 1924, the democratic workers’ regime established by the 1917 revolution had been lost to a new bureaucratic layer. It consolidated its power. Inside the party, the nomenklatura raised the slogan of “socialism in one country”. Linking with the right, they defeated Trotsky and the left who defended the programme of Lenin and the Bolsheviks.

The next decade saw the Stalinists extend their control. But many of the old generation held onto their positions.

In 1930, 69% of the regional secretaries of the CP, and of its Central Committee were still old Bolsheviks. Over 80% of delegates to the Communist Party Congress in 1934 had joined before 1920, before the end of the civil war.

The old guard’s position was strong because of the respect and moral weight its members held. But Stalin and the new careerists rising through the nomenklatura system had no use for them. Bureaucratised though those old Bolsheviks were, they were still not just careerists.

A great purge started with the murder of Kirov, the First Secretary of the Party in Leningrad. Kirov was murdered at Stalin’s orders; but the murder prompted the framing, arrest and trial of many old Bolsheviks. Torture and persecution led to Zinoviev, Kamenev, Rykov, Bukharin, Radek and other revolutionary leaders ‘confessing’ to parts in a Trotsky-Hitler plan to destroy the USSR!

Many were murdered, many more were sent into internal exile. The Gulags, Stalin’s concentration camps, were massive. The scale of the deportations can be shown by Soviet censuses.

Between 1926 and 1939, the total population of the Soviet Far East rose by 329%, of Eastern Siberia by 384%, of the North of the European part of the country by 558%. The frame-ups in the Trials of the ‘Trotsky-Zinoviev terrorist centre’ (1936), the ‘parallel Trotskyist centre’ (1937) and the ‘anti-soviet bloc of the Trostkyist rightists’ (1938) built up a massive slave army, up to ten million strong at some times.

Between 1934 and 1939 the Bolshevik old guard was completely removed. Conclusive figures are given in ‘Nomenklatura’ by Michael Voslenky.

In 1930, he tells us, 69% of senior party secretaries had joined before the revolution. In 1939, 80.5% had joined since Lenin’s death in 1924. 80% of delegates at the 1939 congress were still at school in 1920!

Of the 71 elected onto the Central Committee in 1934, only 10 were newly elected and most were members before 1917. In 1939 nearly two-thirds were elected for the first time, and only two were members before the revolution.

The struggle for power over the USSR was primarily carried out within a working class party, the Communist party. But was it a struggle between two sections of the working class? Is, as some argue, the nomenklatura just a labour bureaucracy? The evidence suggests not.

The obituaries of nomenklatura officials in the Soviet press suggest that the overwhelming majority of the first generation nomenklaturists were of peasant origin. One sample of 855 leading officials of the next generation showed that 709 (over 80%) were of peasant origin, while 58 were of worker origin.

The evidence shows that direct power in the Soviet Union was lost by the working class by 1924, held for 10 or 15 years by a bureaucratic layer of old Bolsheviks, and afterwards by a nomenklatura whose members are mainly of peasant or intellectual origin.

Without doubt, the nomenklatura is alive and well today. In the special shops, clinics and other privileges we see proof of its material advantages.

How big is it? Voslensky suggests that altogether the nomenklatura and its families account for 3 million people in the USSR, who command a massive share of the country’s resources.

Periodically, it purges itself. Sometimes, as in Poland, we see the ruling layer opening up to absorb some of its enemies — the leaders of Solidarnosc. But their exploiting and dictatorial regimes remain.

The nomenklatura regimes are massively corrupt and devoid of democratic planning. After 40 years the big lie — that these countries were socialist — is finally dead.

Organising together with socialists in the eastern bloc, we must sweep Stalinism away in a struggle for workers’ liberty and workers’ control East and West.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 435

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →