"The workers must become an alternative governing force"
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Polish workers face austerity from a Solidarnos government Martin Thomas look at 'The SelfManagement Alternative:
Programme o Polish Sociali Democratic Revolution This is the first socialist programme for 40-odd years from within the Eastern Bloc that comes from a real organised workers' political party, rather than a couple of individuals or a small clandestine group of intellectuals.
The Polish Socialist PartyDemocratic Revolution (PSP-DR) is the first workers' socialist party to emerge in the Eastern Bloc. It is the oldest (at two and a half years!) of the anti-Stalinist left groups in Eastern Europe, and emerges from the working class that has the richest experience of struggle in Eastern Europe, from 1956 through 1970, 1976, 1980-1, and 1988 to today.
All this makes its programme a very important document. The drastic conditions in Poland today make it even more important. Workers' living standards were halved, or worse, in the single month of January. Unemployment is rising. People are hungry and desperate. The authoritarian, chauvinist, anti-semitic and fascist right is growing.
If anti-Stalinist socialists do not very quickly find a programme that both relates to workers' immediate struggles and shows them a way to a new society based on workers' selfmanagement, then the prospect is not the gradual emergence of a parliamentary welfare state like Western Europe's, but a harsh authoritarian regime. The programme argues:
"The process of privatisation and sale of national property which today serves the end of maintaining the dominant position of the nomenklatura must eventually produce systematic changes which will undermine this position.
*In such a situation, either there will be Stalinist reaction, reversing the reform process, Or the nomenklatura will create, together with the Solidarity elite, a new ruling oligarchy on the basis of representing the interests of foreign capital [with] a place for Poland among the countries of the Third World...
"This process will lead to poverty, unemployment and desperation for millions of wage-earners.
The text of the programme represents a compromise between different wings of the PSP-DR, and debate is continuing inside the party. Different parts of the programme point different ways on important issues.
It calls for a *Democratic Revolution", but rejects the idea that this can be a matter of "society" as a whole, without class differentiation, against "the state" "The alliance between the nomenklatura and part of the opposition, " it points out, has been concluded in circumstances of intensifying economic and political struggles by working people. The elites of the authorities and of the opposition drew closer together in the face of economic catastrophe and the fear of an uncontrolled social explosion...(The new Solidarity ministers] agreed to act as intermediaries between Western capital and the nomenklatura.
Since neither the Stalinist system, nor its replacement by capitalism, can "meet the aspirations of working people, " "their only chance is to become an alternative governing force. " "The PSP-DR is a workers' party. "
The programme goes on to call for the transformation of "state enterprises" into "workers' enterprises" , run by workers' councils which hire and fire the manager. To bring this about, it calls for "the rebirth of strong trade union organisations in the workplaces" the reestablishment of the independence of Solidarity from the state, and mass strike movements.
Yet the programme does not include specific demands raised in a manifesto from the Wroclaw committee of the PSP-DR: the sliding scale of wages (ie. automatic wage rises to keep pace with price rises), a cut in work hours to 35 a week, social control over food distribution, and a general wage rise. It is also vague about the shape of the self-managed system it advocates.
Although it calls for the workers "to become an alternative governing force" , and to struggle against the old bureaucrats and the new capitalists, it says that victory would bring not a workers' state but "the Self-Managing Republic - a state which does not express the interests of any social group, but is rather a framework providing law and services to all."
It is no wonder that socialists in Eastern Europe shy away from terms like "workers' state", so misused by the Stalinists. However, the existing state in Poland serves the interests of the bureaucrats and the capitalists. If the workers oust them, the new state will serve the workers' interests and go against the interests of the bureaucrats and capitalists. Neither will the state float in mid-air, neutral between the opposing classes.
The search for a "neutral" state can greatly disorient workers in Eastern Europe. In Czechoslovakia, for example, there is great demand for a "government of experts" . All but three per cent of the people also reject a move to tull free-market capitalism. However, all the economic experts now in top positions belong to the pro-capitalist three per cent!
The PSP-DR programme says: *Independent social experts should be introduced to groups taking economic decisions, together with people with a humanistic background, enjoying social authority. " But no experts are neutral or independent.
The same search for some mythical neutral or independent force to stand above society also blurs the programme's ideas about reorganising production. "In all economic systems up until now, " it says, "capital in various forms has taken primacy over labour. " So we need to "equalise the opportunities of employees in relation to employers.
Yet later on the programme calls for the transformation of "state enterprises" into "workers' enterprises" — not enerprises with an "equal" balance between the workers and the state or private capital.
Shying away from the ideas of a democratically-decided workers' overall economic plan, or a "The Polish workers' movement / movement has a rich history. The programme link itself to history.
workers' government, the programme relies heavily on decentralisation as a way to economic and political democracy.
Decentralised local initiative is certainly necessary, and not only as a corrective to Stalinist ultracentralisation. Without strong workers' organisation in the workplace and neighbourhoods, and the ousting of the old bureaucrats by workers' councils in enterprises and districts, all talk of a workers' self-managed republic is so much words in the air.
And democratic planning cannot just be a matter of ousting the Stalinists from the planning offices and replacing them by democratically-elected people. Socialist planning is possible only on the basis of accurate and comprehensive information about costs and technologies. It cannot be built on the basis of the bureaucrats bungled and corrupt accounting.
Marxists have never proposed to abolish the market overnight; and in Eastern Europe, especially, even a workers' government would need to use the market for a long time to gain economic information. It would need to give market mechanisms more scope than the old Stalinist system. Its economic planning would reject what Trotsky called "the superstition of administrative plan and administrative prices"?; it would set broad outhnes, but be open to correction and local initiative.
All that said, no modern society can be just a network of small autonomous enterprises and communes. Large-scale enterprises and nationally-planned services are central.
The programme proposes two democratic controls over economic affairs at the national level: a "selfmanagement chamber" of parliament, "representing all workers"" as a counterpoint to the main assembly "representing all citizens"; and "referenda, in which the inhabitants of Poland can choose between alternative economic programmes" . But referenda have historically served authoritarian, not democratic, governments, and for good reason: they offer the people only a yes-no vote on terms set by the government. Referenda on issues as complex as alternative economic programmes would be doubly open to manipulation.
There is no alternative but the establishment of a flexible, accountable system of working-class democracy, based on mandation and the right of recall at every level, in which different political parties can compete with different social and economic programmes. What the PSP-DR programme seems to do is to concede, reluctantly, the continuation of a central state authority, to assume that it must be bureaucratic and dominated by a privileged minority, but then to try to limit it by calling for independent experts, by maximising local as against central power, and so on.
It is almost like a new version of the "self-limiting revolution" proposed by Solidarity leaders 1980-1. Then, the idea was that the Stalinists would be left in control of the state superstructure, but Solidarity would enable the people to take control of the whole of society underneath that Stalinist canopy. Now the idea seems to be a curtailed workers, state hemmed in by and local selfmanagement all around it.
Instead of replacing the existing army by a citizens' territorial army, it proposes a smaller professional army. Instead of elected judges, it proposes a "self-governing judiciary". It proposes no specific measures to break up the civilian state bureaucracy.
The programme proposed is unworkable, as a model of society, and inadequate, as a plan for combatting the power of the entrenched state machine.
Each local authority, it proposes: should rely solely on its own local taxes; indeed the national government would have no tax powers of its own, relying instead on a fixed economy cannot built workplace by workplace. It canno even be built in one country alone."
percentage paid over from local taxes. Each local authority would have the right to veto all national decisions - even investment decisions of national significance, the programme says explicitly.
Such radical decentralisation would make it impossible to run a national railway or electricity supply system, let alone a socialist economy. And it would lead to huge regional inequalities.
The programme envisages an economy where workers' self-managed enterprises would relate to each other through what it calls "a market controlled from below [which] would make possible equivalent exchange". It argues that the market is a good regulator of production and distribution, only under capitalism it is distorted by the rise of monopolies.
However, the capitalist market *leads to unemployment, waste and