“The workers must become an alternative governing force” (continued)
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
6 Nov 2026: the last column of this article, on page 9, transcribed from the scan; the machine split had filed it at the head of What is the 'Nomenklatura'? The article begins on page 8. 'PSR-DR' (beside PSP-DR) and 'working clas' are as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 9
[...] ecological catastrophes” (as the programme indicates) even without monopolies. It did so in the 19th century, before modern monopolies emerged. And the programme could not prevent monopolies anyway: how, other than through extremely wasteful duplication, could Poland have more than one or a very few railway systems, electricity supply systems, telephone systems, steelworks, car assembly plants, computer manufacturing enterprises...?
Moreover, the market cannot be controlled “from below”; workers’ councils in individual enterprises cannot control the relations between enterprises. A workers’ self-managed republic would need to control the market from above, through control of the banks, credit, and the state budget.
The programme points out that worker takeovers enterprise by enterprise would leave some workforces with modern, competitive plants, and others with outdated factories doomed to bankruptcy. The inequalities, it says, “can be evened out with the help of taxation”; but how? This would mean market chaos tempered by bureaucratic corruption, as in Yugoslavia’s “market socialism”.
A socialist economy cannot be built workplace by workplace. It cannot even be built in one country alone. The programme declares that “The PSR-DR is a party of international solidarity, which sees in close cooperation with anti-totalitarian and socialist movements and workers’ parties the possibility of liberation from state oppression and economic enslavement”; but it does not follow up that declaration with any detailed international programme.
Although the programme speaks of “the complete destruction of the ruling Party bureaucracy”, it also insists that the PSP-DR will proceed “without the use of force”. How will the bureaucracy be completely destroyed without the use of force? If it is not destroyed, then (especially with the aid of Western capital), the central state will surely overcome the uncoordinated efforts of local self-management initiatives. The programme is right when it declares that the workers must “become an alternative governing force”, and wrong when it fails to follow through that thought.
A revolutionary party has to act as the memory of the working clas — the means to sum up the lessons of past struggles and bring them to bear on the future. That task is doubly important, and doubly difficult, in the Eastern Bloc, where decades of Stalinism have not only suppressed the socialist tradition, but also taken its phrases — “workers’ state”, “planned economy” — and attached contrary meanings to them.
The Polish workers’ movement has a rich history. The programme tries to link itself to that history, right back to the foundation of the first Polish Socialist Party in 1892. But from the period between 1894 and the 1930s, it cites only one strand of that history — the nationalist, reformist strand, as opposed to the internationalist revolutionary strand represented by Rosa Luxemburg, Leo Jogiches, the Polish Communist Party before Stalinism and the Polish Trotskyists.
The aspirations in the programme are much closer to the tradition of Luxemburg than to the nationalists and reformists. By linking up with that part of the Polish working-class tradition, the PSP-DR will find the way to turn its aspirations into a programme for action. Its doing so will be important not only for the Polish workers, but also for all the workers of Eastern Europe and indeed the world.