Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Another victory against the odds WHETTONS

Socialist Organiser no. 435, 22 February 1990 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,749 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

moon self. us vici WEEK Anners dary the hir is a tremendous victory.

I would hope it would give them all a Doost to know that Mandela is freed. The effect that the small amount of sanctions seem to have had shows what we could have achieved if we had imposed full sanctions.

enere is a long, long way to go, and I think that things are going to get very much more dodgy before it gets better in South Africa.- 1 can see a lot more bloodshed before freedom is achieved. Now is not the time to start relaxing inevitable.

But if you had predicted a few years ago that Nelson Mandela would walk free and the ANC would be legalised, people would have dismissed it Along with the breaching of the Berlin Wall it shows no matter what the odds, people with commitment and dedication can struggle against the odds and win.

Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM, South Yorkshire. democratic, involve Party and non-Party members, and carry the message of opposition to this appalling tax. Look at the following quotation. Remember that it is part of a 'dossier' asking for disciplinary measures to be taken. Then ask yourself where on earth is our party going.

'A large number of Wallasey CLP members are involved in the Anti Poll Tax Unions in Wallasey and Wirral. These include Edwina Doyle, Janet Furber and Dianne Harris. The latter two members also organised the print and sale of I-shirts for the Anti Poll Tax Union cause'" failed to base themselves on student activity turning instead around 'nonpolitical' issues. A number of Green sabbaticals have become very rightwing.

Apparently Socialist Outlook's little band is backing the Greens.

To take such a position is to forget the central role of the labour movement and to ignore the fight to transform Labour Students into fighting organisation. Socialist Outlook are disoriented.

In the run up to the elections socialists will have to be very clear about the ssue, and keep their sense of perspecrive. NOLS represent something much better than Cosmo and the Greens.

Keep NUS Labour and fight for campaigning NUS!

Scan page 6

Sergei Sedov with his brother Lyova's son. Both perished at Vorkuta is today a name associated with the recent great strike of miners. In 1938, Vorkuta was the place where the last great massacre of the surviving Trotskyists occurred. There the last of the Bolsheviks who, standing by the programme of the October Revolution, had fought the Stalinist counter-revolution inch by inch, were first concentrated and then systematically slaughtered.

Joseph Berger was a prisoner in the Soviet Union for over 20 years. He tells here about a meeting in prison with Trotsky's younger son, Sergei; about the mass hunger strike of the Trotskyist prisoners - women, men and their children - at Vorkuta, after which they were annihilated by the GPU.

met Trotsky's son Sergei in 1937. We were both waiting to be interrogated in the Lubyanka.

The waiting-rooms were small bare cells known as "kennels" Normally each prisoner had a kennel to himself but the Lubyanka was overworked, busy officials rang each other up in search of a place for their charges, and sometimes two were made to share. Thus we spent several hours together one night in February.

For me it was a memorable meeting. Sergei had recently been brought back from Vorkuta. His case had been re-opened and he took a gloomy view of his prospects. My own seemed little better, and before long I was in fact sentenced to death. But for some reason Sergei said he had an intuition I would survive, and he gave me a message for his parents, should I ever see them.

He was about 28, a shortish, spare young man with a round face and moustache. Unlike his brother, he had never taken the slightest interest in politics - he had even refused to join the Komsomol. He had a passion for books and was addicted to the circus. As a child, he had once run away and joined a travelling circus.

His relations were naturally worried by his irresponsible ways and even pointed out that they could damage his father's career. But he remained incorrigible. When his father found himself in the Opposition, he thought it only proved how right he himself had been in his bored indifference to the regime. He did well at school but hesitated a long time over the choice of a career. In the end, he was trained as an architect.

When Trotsky was exiled in 1929, Stalin - in one of his unpredictable moments of generosity - allowed him to take his family and even his archives abroad. Sergei heard the news in some provincial town where he was working. He received an anxious message from his parents. Trotsky took the blackest possible view of the situation in Russia and foresaw the fate of all those who were connected with him. "Think of the worst possible thing you can imagine and multiply it by ten," he said to the friends who saw him off from Odessa. But Sergei was at the time in love with a girl who was unwilling to leave her family, and he refused to follow his parents abroad.

For a time it seemed as though his father's fears for him had been groundless. Not only did he escape the purges of the early thirties, but family friends who still had some for Stalin wanted be able to rewrite influence found him la job. Only in 1935, after the murder of Kirov, was he summoned by the authorities and asked to make a public repudiation of his father.

They explained that he had only to tell the truth - he had never got on with his parents or shared their views, and he had not accompanied them into exile. All he had to add was that he now regarded them as enemies of their country. He refused on the grounds that he had always been apolitical — this was the reason for his differences with his father — and he would certainly not join in hounding them now. He lost his job but was not arrested until some months later.

Brought to Moscow in the autumn of 1936, he immediately went on hunger strike as a protest against his arrest. But the investigation was completed within ten days.

He was sentenced to five years in a labour camp. In December, he arrived in Vorkuta and for the first time found himself among followers of his father. They filled him with admiration. "capitulated" the , there remained a While the majority had hard core of uncompromising Trotskyists, most of them in prisons and camps. They and their families had been rounded up in the preceding months and concentrated in three large camps - Kolyma, Vorkuta, and Norisk. Sergel gave me the first news I received of those in Vorkuta.

I was not surprised at the impression they had made on him. I had met several since my arrest. Most of those I knew were intellectuals to whom Trotsky's views - less cut and dried than Lenin's — had appealed from early on. The majority were experienced revolutionaries who had fought in the civil war but had joined the Opposition in the early twenties. A larger proportion than in other parties were members of national minorities, but all of them were fiery internationalists, intolerant of the very idea of local or Soviet nationalism and scarcely able to grasp the concept of nation.

Had the term "rootless Stalin's hands cosmopolitan" been invented by those whom it attracted were not then, it would certainly have been always made welcome. But their applied to the Trotskyists. gloomy courage was proof against Purists, they feared the con- all temptations and threats. tamination of their doctrine above all else in the world. This had been the Armenian Komsomol. He had the greatest obstacle to their received a three-year sentence which cooperation with other groups and, ran out in 1937. Every prisoner's even in the camp, they tended to identity card bore the date of his keep to themselves. They had in- release. One day, to my horror, he herited this attitude from Trotsky. took out his card and, calmly smilLenin could be hard or flexible as it ing, altered the date from 1937 to suited him. But Trotsky, even in ex- 1987. He explained that he did not le, with almost every door shut in of course expect to be alive by then, his face, could still use his time and but that as long as he lived he would his brilliant gifts on venomous remain a Trotskyist and would polemics with Western socialist therefore have to stay in prison. leaders. When I accused the Trot- Stalin was right, according to his skyists of sectarianism, they said lights, to keep the Trotskyists lockthat what mattered was to "keep ed up. As for them, all they had to the banner unsullied" do now was to bear witness by sufTheir fanaticism antagonised the fering and dying for the truth. majority of prisoners, and even politicians, they were "opting out of history" they replied: "That's what every opportunist tells us.

camp abominable, but his companions gave him a warm welcome for his father's sake and were themselves heartened by his interrogator. When he asked for news of him, the official said: "If his father sends a wagon-full of gold we might let him go." But this I remembered a former leader of was only a cruel joke. No such offer was made to Trotsky, and Sergei's fate must already have been decided when — perhaps in order to deprive his friends of the moral comfort of having a Trotsky among them - he was brought back from Vorkuta.

Many years were to pass before the world outside heard anything about their last, heroic stand and their death in the Northern forests. The main facts were published in Sotsialistichesky Vestnik in New York (No.10/11, 1961). - can only add the details i was able to piece together from the stories of Sergei and a few prisoners I met much later. That the extermination of the When I told such people that, as Trotskyists was decided on and carefully planned in Moscow is shown by the fact that the same system was followed in all three

----- pull-quotes -----

"The tracks were carefully covered

history as well as make it."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 435

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →