Two souls of socialism
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
was very sorry to hear about the death of Hal Draper, but pleased to see SO giving some prominance to 'AL"s perceptive appreciation of this fine American Marxist.
Draper's pamphlet, "The Two Souls of Socialism' ', made a big impression on me when I first read it nearly 20 years ago. It is a compelling (and highly readable) case for working class self-activity combined with consistent democracy, as central and irreplaceable in the creation of socialism.
Draper argues that the distinction between working class #socialism from below" and the various forms of elitist "socialism from above" , is a more important and fundamental line of divide than the formal nametags that socialists may give "reform" vs "revolution", themselves and each other "Leninist" vs "Libertarian"", "Trotskyist" vs "Stalinist", etc. Not, Draper stresses, that these categories are irrelevant (he himself was firmly on the "revolution/ Lenin/Trotsky" side), but that such categories are often misused. "Socialism from below" is the litmust test for the genuineness of revolutionary pretentions.
As 'AL' notes, Draper was often described as a "Shachtmanite" because of his support for the "bureaucratic collectivist" theory of the USSR and the other Stalinist states. But unlike many anti-Stalinist American socialists (including Shachtman himself) Draper never became cynical or right-wing.
James P Cannon always a shrewd judge of character) once described Draper as something like "the eternal Young Socialist" - a great compliment from a factional opponent who nevertheless recognised enthusiasm, commitment and honesty. In tact my only criticism of 'AL"s piece is that it tends to overlook Draper's long history of practical involvement as an activist in the Workers' Party and, later, the Independent Socialist League.
Happily, Draper, lived long enough to see events in Russia and Eastern Europe confirm at least some of his most fundamental beliefs.
McDonough Birmingham