New Labow purge threatened
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 1
workers liberty
John O'Mahony
When he was deselected as parliamentary candidate by his local Labour Party in Birkenhead, Frank Field MP threatened to resign and force a by-election.
This would have allowed the Tories and their press to launch a new carnival of denunciation of the Labour Party, helping them to undo the recent growth of electoral support for Labour.
Instead of standing up to Field, the leaders of the Labour Party decided to allow themselves to be blackmailed by him. As his reward for threatening to do serious damage to the Party, they agreed to start moves to change the result of the Birkenhead reselection.
It was not difficult to find supporters of the semi-banned Militant tendency in the Birkenhead Labour Party who could be exhibited as part of a left-wing 'conspiracy' against Field - and thus to begin to reopen the question of who should be the Labour candidate in Birkenhead at the next election. Field produced a ridiculously inaccurate and libellous 'dossier' on the left in Birkenhead and the whole Wirral district, and the Labour Party leaders duly agreed to investigate.
At its meeting last Monday, 19th, Labour's Organisation SubCommittee decided that the Party's Director of Organisation, Joyce Gould, should continue to pursue inquiries into seven members of Birkenhead Labour Party to determine whether or not they are associated with Militant. She will investigate allegations of "intimidation" at the Birkenhead Labour Party's General Committee Joyce Gould will also be investigating supporters of Socialist Organiser in the neighbouring Wallasey constituency. That was one of Field's demands.
According to the Independent (20 February), "The party's organisation sub-committee agreed to investigate whether Socialist Organiser, another far left grouping, should, like Militant, be banned from Labour Party membership.
Ms Gould's preliminary inCarry feat and Wiser ORGANISER vestigation found evidence of its influence in the Wallasey party, and the sub-committee will attempt to establish whether it has policies incompatible with Labour's, or organises itself as a party within a party".
During the last general election, Field provided the Tory press on Merseyside with witch-hunting copy against Wallasey Labour candidate Lol Duffy. When asked by the press, he specifically refused to advise Wallasey voters to vote Labour, saying he had "no advice"
Lol Duffy increased Labour's vote by one of the biggest percentages in the whole country, and needed only 279 votes to win against Tory minister Lynda Chalker.
Frank Field is, to pur it politely, an arrogant media-cosseted man who has got up the noses of a lot of middle-of-the-road Merseyside Labour Party members. He is anything but a 'moderate'. On some questions he belongs to Labour's loopy tendency.
see centre pages For Workers' Liberty Eest and Wes Solidarity Saturdsy 27 Januery ORGANISER Students' struggle sparks workers' re BeT 11 The issues on 11 The left and the sues on 11 SUPAngrinıg for spichalsm since Oçtober 1978 Kick out the Tories!
1L Socialist Liverpool.
DEFY THE LAW!
SUPPORT THE MINERS!
BAN TH, RISK Stop the racists cashing in!
Scan page 2
the revelations about the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad.
Best Midlands Serious Crime Squad (SCS) forced confessions out of suspects, forged statements, and tried to incriminate solicitors.
These are the allegations now being investigated, following the Squad's dissolution. Over 50 police officers involved in the Squad have been moved to desk jobs, and everyone who had been in control of it over the last three years 'shifted sideways' Senior police chiefs may have lied to appeal courts to cover for the Squad's activities.
But the most famous case of such forced confessions will not be investigated. The case of the Birmingham Six remains unexamined by the enquiry, not to speak of the appeal courts. The enquiry deals strictly with the period since the introduction of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) in 1984.
Last week's World in Action detailed horrific evidence against the SCS.
Clifford Jones was arrested in 1986 for involvement in a burglary in Birmingham. He was denied a solicitor.
Later forensic examination proved that two pages of his statement, in which he confessed to the crime, could have been added after the rest, in which he had, denied all involvement. As a result he was acquitted. But the officers responsible, who are also at the centre of allegations concerning the Brimingham Six, faced no disciplinary proceedings. Indeed one, Detective Sergeant Hornby, was awarded the Oueen's Police Medal.
According to police evidence, it took a total of fourteen minutes for Jones' statement to be written and read back to him. Yet when the police were asked to write the confession out in court, the writing alone took 21 minutes. Their evidence was completely discredited.
Glen Lewis is now in prison after confessing to burglary and robbery. He confessed, he said, after being threatened with a hypodermic needle, and in fact only signed blank sheets which were later filled out by the same officers as Jones' heard before the discrediting Jo Jones's case. Solicitors believe that if Lewis' case had been heard later, he never would have been convicted.
Paul Dandy tried to kill himself after being charged with a robbery he did not commit. The prosecution withdrew charged against him after a forensic test proved that two pages of his statement had been rewritten. There have been no prosecutions of police officers.
After the Dandy case, the SCS agreed to hand over the transcripts of controversial interviews for examination. Mysteriously, between the police headquaters and the of ficers of Birmingham Crown Prosecution Services, the papers were lost.
Hasan Khan was arrested in Caernarvon for a robbery in Birmingham, in which he was also alleged to have run through a shopping centre firing a gun. Not only do several witnesses claim he was in Caernarvon at the time, he had also just had two toes amputated!
His statement was taken by one officer in a police car. The statement contains only six minutes' worth of what was supposedly a 45 minute interview, therefore cannot very accurate.
World in Action detailed other cases, too, alleging torture and other malpractice by the SCS. One doctor confirmed that Harry Treadaway had sustained injuries likely to have been caused by attempted suffocation with a plastic bag• Ronald Bolden was arrested in 1987 in a part of Birmingham where a burglary had taken place. He was interviewed by two officers also involved in the Jones case and incriminated. Police claimed he offered them a bribe of £10,000.
Police also tried to incriminate Bolden's solicitors who had been to see another man, Paul Fitzsimmons about his own dealings with the Squad. Fitzsimmons was then in prison. He was later visited by Squad officers and told that he would be rearrested upon his release, unless he claimed that Bolden's solicitors had tried to bribe him to give evidence in their favour. The particular solicitor identified by the Squad, Paul Baker, was later proved to have been in a different part of the country at the time.
Following this case, the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad was disbanded.
Since the begining of the investigation into the Serious Crime Squad, West Midlands police have given misleading information to solicitors and the appeal court.
Solicitors for John Edwards were told by the police that none of the officers involved in his case were under investigation. In fact the officer in charge of the case was.
It was the same with the case of Anthony Wellington.
A jedge hearing the appeal of two men charged with robbery was promised in a letter signed by an assistant chief constable that the investigation was in any case not concerned with forced confessions. Yet this is precisely what is at stake in two cases under investigation, Jones's and Dandy's.
In other words, senior policemen have lied to the court.
One of the striking aspects to the affair of the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad is that much of their track-covering was incredibly inept. Clearly, forced and forged confessions were so much a part of their staple routine that they either saw no point in making a convincing attempt to disguise what they were doing, or had long since forgotten how to.
And SO the revelations about them had implications not only of the Birmingham Six. Other Serious Crime Squads, like the one in London responsible for jailing Winston Silcott for the murder of PC Blakelock, are certainly just as bad. The shit is only starting to hit the fan.
A key issue is that it is possible for the police to get convictions on the basis of confessions alone. In many legal systems, including for example in Scotland, this is not possible. As well as a confession to the police, there must be some corroborating evidence before a jury can convict.
In England, not only is it possible to get a conviction on the sole basis of confession in a police interrogation cell: the right to silence is increasingly under threat. The Tories OT THEM most to make it possible for tes prosecution inferences from a defendant's exercise of his or her right to silence.
At the moment, if someone refuses to say anything, this can't be held against them in court. This right to silence is based on what is supposedly central to British law that the burden of proof is on the prosecution: you are innocent until proven guilty.
So the very rights that the people Eastern Europe are fighting for due process under law - are beTwo victims of th Seymour Williams o confess' after ing taken away by dians of 'freedom' And they must know that the rot runs very, very deep. At its core is the police force's unaccountability No-one elects them; no one can control them. It is very difficult for outsidrs even to investigate them. Following all the malpractice of the West Mildand SCS, there have been some minor disciplinary proceedings, but little else. Officers the Poll Tax held its firs conference on Saturday 3 February Supported by 15 Labour councillors the conference was attended delegates from Labour Party branches council worker unions, other unions anti-poll tax unions, student organisa tions and tenants associations fron across the city. It has sparked off thi most effective and democratic campaig: against the poll tax and its effects or jobs and services so far in Manchester.
Use TIEN uI place, bir businesses will find their rates bills cut: by 31% - about £57m a year — which means an extra E170 slapped on ever: adult's poll tax bill. On top of this, i levy of £71 per person has been imposer on everyone by the government, to func the safety net' scheme, and to keep the voters in Tory marginals - and That cher - happy.
This means that each person has te fork out £241 per year before any local services have been paid for.
An 'acceptable' poll tax rate of £444 is likely to be set by Manchester City Council, yet a rate of £712 would be necessary to maintain services at their present level. As a result, 3,000 council workers will be sacked, and huge cuts in already skeletal frontline services made - and that's on the basis of 95% collection rate. On top of this, council tenants face a f6 a week rent rise.
A previous campaign, Justice for Manchester, supported by the Council trade unions, the Labour Party and Labour Council, did a good job in highlighting the injustices of the poll e West Midlands Serious Crime Squad -very and rack omen - wno were torcea Ilofel and Damial Cuick a supergrass tip-off guilty of forging confessions have just been given different jobs, or perhaps fined a few hundred pounds.
There have been no prosecutions.
The more investigations there are, or course, the better: the more the police are subject to public scrutiny, the more leverage there is to impose more democratic accountability on them.
Equally, public tax. However, its opposition to non-payment and non-implementation strategies, and its domination by trade union bureaucrats, meant it was largely ineffectual. For example, it organised a delegation to London to argue against the amount that Manchester had to pay into the "safety net' scheme. But instead of getting rid of it, or lowering it, the Tories actually increased Manchester's contribution from £56 to £71 a head!
Also, the mass rally Justice for Manchester called on 23 January was cancelled at short notice. The reason why is still a mystery. Rumour has it, however, that Graham Stringer (leader of the council), knowing about the Labour Against the Cuts and Poll Tax Campaign and the ever-growing support from many organisations for mass non-payment, was concerned that the rally could turn into a resistance movement far too confrontational for the council's nervous disposition.
The 3 February conference could start where Justice for Manchester left off. Judging from the comments from the delegates, it is obvious that frustration at the council's passive stand is massive, and there is support for a more active campaign.
The campaign shoud turn this frustration and anger into a positive and active force against the Tories.
The aims and demands of the campaign, as adopted at the conference, are:
• Support the campaign of mass non-payment • Call upon the council and the trade unions not to implement the poll tax • No more cuts - demand adequate central government funding to provide the services we need • Any system to replace the rates must be based on the ability to pay • No rent increases Further activities were also planned. Firstly, a mass lobby of the city council's budget meeting on 28 February. Secondly, it was agreed that the conference should be recalled regularly. It was also agreed that the organisational meetings, which are held regularly, police is now at its lowest perhaps ever in British history, certainly since World War Two. The labour movement needs to discuss alternative, more democratic methods of policing.
Do we need a separate self-contained, professional force at all? Or is it time to start thinking about systems of policing genuinely based on communities themselves?
should be open to anyone wanting become involved in the campaign.
Speakers from the campaign will address Labour Party ward meetings throughout Manchester to explain the aims of the conference and involve activists on the ground.
The conference opened up the possibility of building a united, democratic campaign against cuts in working conditions and council services, and against the poll tax.
9 am Wednesday Called by Labour jainst the Cuts ar Manchester Socialist Irganiser Public Meetin abour Councils and th fight for socialism Monday 5 March7.30pm Manchester Town Hall peakers: Pete Keenleysid i John Clegg (Mancheste Councillor)
Scan page 3
ight pushes for wit Socialist Organiser IR PARTY
----- pull-quotes -----
Turn to page 3 the
ORGANISER BENN SAYS: SOCIALIST
STOP ORGANISER ALL COA
deep Clive Bradley looks at
rayal PIOLL TAX anchester's Labou M Against the Cuts and