Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

B SOCIALISM A key lesson fr

Socialist Organiser no. 434, 15 February 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,657 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

From page 7 Today, as events continue to unfold in Eastern Europe, as the bloody defeat of the embryonic Chinese workers' movement last summer goes down into history, as pro-bourgeois forces fill the political vacuum in Hungary, Poland, Czechoslovakia and East Germany, we have once again proof of the burning need for a revolutionary organisation.

Unfortunately the proot 1s negative proof. The newly reborn East European workers' movement is delivering state power to pro-bourgeois Stalinists and marketeers.

Those words by Trotsky above are all the more tragic because their correctness has been obvious for decades to all honest students of working class history.

Workers as revolutionaries Unlike the bourgeoisie, which germinates and grows in wealth and culture and becomes politically mature under the old feudal or neofeudal regime, where it already exists as an exploiting class - and to an extent can even do this under a decrepit, rotting Stalinism, in Poland for example - the working class has no such advantages. The working class is born and always remains a wage-slave class under capitalism. The role of the working class is that of wage slaves, that of the basic exploited class.

The bourgeoisie, when they were progressive on a world-historic scale, developed their own means of production and access to culture, education, and the institutions of the state, even before they took power. The bourgeois revolution can be indirect, and can even be delivered to the bourgeoisie by forces outside the immediate control of its own class.

The French Revolution was won by the sans-culottes, the radical plebeian masses, under the influence of the Jacobins. In contrast, the proletarian revolution can only be a conscious political act. It can only be an act of the working class itself. For the workers' revolution, politics dominates, because politics s the means by which the working class organises itself as a conscious force — a "class for itself", as Marxists put it - and then proceeds to win, by political action, its own economic emancipation.

The creation of a classless society and the development of the consciousness of the working class so that it understands its own historic interests cannot, as we have seen, be the result of spontaneous rebellions alone. The contradictory reality is one of uneven development in the consolidation of the workers' movement and in the development of ideas within the working class which correspond to its interests. The effects of Stalinism It is even more complex and contradictory in the USSR and Eastern Europe now, because the peculiarities of Stalinism. For ex ample, in Eastern Europe now some of the best and most heroic working-class militants have suicidal illusions in free market economics, and believe that parliamentary democracy of the West European sort is effective self. rule for the working class majority Workers who live in countries such as Britain have learned the contrary.

Workers who rebel against market capitalism have only to go for the opposite of market capitalism to arrive at some notion - however crude, underdeveloped, and ultimately inadequate - of a viable working-class alternative, what might be called democratic collectivism. Those instinctive rebel ideas are not the same thing as scientific awareness of society and politics. Such clarity has to be fused with the spontaneous working-class struggles by the activity of Marxists who have adequately theorised from the whole world-wide experience of the working class and made a scientific overview bourgeois society and of the evoluion of human society in general But spontaneous workers revolt against market capitalism does lead naturally and easily towards Marxist ideas, however. Workers in struggle learn with astonishing rapidity.

In Eastern Europe, when workers obey the rebel's gut instinct to overthrow and negate the system that oppresses them, the natural untutored impulse is to go for the system which in the West seems to breed both freedom and prosperity.

The phenomenon parallels what we see in the West, where good working-class militants have often blindly and ignorantly supported Stalinism in the East because it seems to be the opposite of what they faced immediately in their own conditions. Today, in Eastern Europe, the reflex rejection of the immediate system and the embracing of its seeming opposite is an overwhelming mass movement.

In practice it makes workers who want real, effective self-government when they embrace democracy, and freedom from the dictats of bungling and grotesquely inefficient state bureaucrats when they support the market, prey to liberal intellectuals, turncoat bureaucrats and conniving political priests who do not want any of the things the workers want, and most of whom will actually conspire and if necessary fight to stop the workers getting what they want.

A Marxist organisation is irreplaceable in such conditions if the working class is to defend itself in even the most minimal way - an organisation that does not start with a blind negation and inversion of Stalinism, but can see Stalinism in its place in history and knows also about that other system of working-class exploitation and oppression within the forms of freedom and democracy - in short, an organisation which is a true memory of the working class and can thus help the masses of newly roused workers to hammer out an independent working-class outlook and programme which corresponds to their real interests and to the desires they express as "democracy" and "the market"

Class and ideas The working class does not possess privileged access to culture, arts and science. Workers do not possess leisure time in which to develop ideas. Everywhere the workers' movement is pervaded by alien class ideology, by the ideas of the ruling class.

A variant of that domination by the ruling class is when rebel workers take the motto "my enemy's enemy is my friend" and accept as their answer to their immediate class enemy the alien ideas of that enemy's enemy. They take on a negative rather than positive imprint of their own ruling class, but an imprint nonetheless.

It is not true that the Stalinist enemies of capitalism, or the capitalist enemies of Stalinism, are our friends! Both the pro-Stalinist Arthur Scargill and the pro-capitalist Lech Walesa are terrible examples of what such politics can do to people who want to be working-class militants.

We need independent working-class politics, and only Marxism can generate consistently independent working-class politics.

Although economic Polish Socialist Party (DR) protest in Poland is an instinctive rebellion of the working class, it is not in itself enough to create stable revolutionary socialist consciousness or to generate an adequate working-class strategy. The Bolsheviks welded together a party of revolutionaries which attempted to articulate an independent set of working-class ideas to guide the spontaneous rebellion. This meant the merging into a whole of the "conscious" role of the Bolsheviks - who suggested ideas to the class, generalised the results of the creative innovation of parts of the class, making them available to the whole class, workers' liberty East and West.

We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism.

We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under SUBSCRIBE Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post. Rates (UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for year.

Name.

Address.

Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose Send to: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA and so on - with all levels of working-class struggle and organisation.

The sad thing now about the wonderful movement of the East European, and increasingly of the Russian, working class, is that the workers have to begin almost from scratch, learning from immediate experience, with too little in the way of the accumulated and codified working-class experience which a pre-existing organisation of Marxists would be able to contribute. Years of Stalinist repression annihilated socialist militants and all but uprooted and obliterated the workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recalleble at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.

Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles wor dwide, including the struggle of genuine traditions of socialism and of unfalsified Marxism.

Our class in Eastern Europe, after the long night of Stalinism has lifted, is a class almost without a long-term memory. It will for this reason act against its own interests, or fail to act for its interests, and may have to pay dearly as a result.

Not for a very long time has there been clearer proof that the work of (for now) small groups of Marxists - which outsiders usually dismiss as a waste of time and life — is no idle activity, but an irreplaceable part of the fight for working-class self-emancipation.

workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.

We stand:

For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class-based women's movement.

Against racism, deportations and tion controls.

For equality for gays.

For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.

For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.

For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, ond militant against capitalism.

We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet th paper's deficit. Our policy : democratically controlled -/ our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.

Scan page 9

SOV

----- pull-quotes -----

WHERE WE STAND Socialist Organiser stands for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 434

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →