Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A key lesson from

Socialist Organiser no. 434, 15 February 1990 · scan p. 7 · about 1,620 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

ENCTU irkers have rebelled against in pitalism. Their revolt vindicates i capitalism, but the workers" rolt against capitalism.

Even limited democracy of the rliamentary sort is won and susned only by workers' struggles. A ller democracy giving the masses the people real control over their es - including their economic cumstances — is possible only rough the working class replacing pitalism. Dignified, secure, cative lives for the majority are ssible only with working-class cialism, not with capitalism. Socialism means the substitution democratic planning for need in¡ad of the bankers' and areholders' bottom line as the iding principle of production. It ans conscious solidarity and operation instead of the freeirket law of devil take the hindist. It means movement towards : replacement of wage labour by : principle of "from each accorig to their abilities, to each accorig to their needs" . It means mocracy which covers economic ltes tof te means a "semiministration in place of privileged litarist, bureaucratic state chines. It means individual edom based on lifting the burden insecurity, poverty, servility and austing drudgery from the marity and given them access to ucation, culture, and the velopment of their creative ities. It means people usin nology, rather tnan technolog ing people.

The collapse of Stalinism alidates these ideals. In no way es it brand them as utopian or workable.

Socialism is possible. But it will t come automatically. It has to be ade by the working class. And for now the working class oks the confidence and clarity to srupt the triumphal parade of the urgeoisie. For now many workers Eastern Europe say they want no periments with some ideal new tem opposed both to Stalinism d capitalism; they want mething which works, something South African miners' union conference.

tried and tested, and they believe the market economy is it.

But it could never have been the case that the progress of the working class would be like the progress of the bourgeoisie, a gradual rise of wealth, culture, organisation and self-confidence under the old regime. The workers' struggle for self-liberation is a struggle with great zig-zags, tremendous leaps forward and terrible regressions. It cannot be otherwise with a class which is the basic slave class until its day of self-liberation.

The worst of those regressions was the triumph of Stalinism in one third of the globe. It corrupted, disoriented and demoralised most of two generations of worker activists.

The disorientation and demoralisation does not end with the collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe. In the short term it may get worse. Nor is Stalinism dead. It still rules a quarter of the world's people, in China. It may still make comebacks, though surely minor ones, in Europe.

Yet the revolts in Eastern Europe are not only inspiring examples of how the masses can make history against the rulers and exploiters; they are also a great step towards ridding the whole world workers' movement of the syphilis of Stalinism.

In every decade of this century, the workers in some country or another have shown their ability to organise as a potential ruling class, a force to remake society.. They have been defeated, and in most of those defeats Stalinism played a great role.

New workers' revolutionary struggles will arise, and Stalinism will be weaker. The struggles can win. Whether they win depends on what replaces Stalinism as a political influence in the workers' movement. That it will be some sort of socialist, cooperative or collectivist influence we can be sure; the position of the working class under capitalism guarantees that. Whether it is a clear revolutionary Marxist influence depends on us. We have a world to win. Ruth Cockroft and Cathy Nugent exa the experience of revolutions so far Who could have forese across the whole Eastern Europe awakening suddenly to an awareness of own strength?

In Eastern Europe the working class numbers millions. Prospects for socialism have been given an immense boost by the awakening of this giant army of millions of workers who will find no means of defending themselves except the tried and tested methods of trade union and political self-organisation as a class.

However, the East European working class is, at present, subordinate part of a "people's" movement which has no specifically working class politics. The politics of the broad popular movement include demands for an ill-defined "democracy" and for the "market". Most workers, when asked, say they want a socially responsible market and democratic freedoms which are far deeper, more substantial and more all-embracing than is the parliamentary democracy of the West.

Evidence suggests that by "democracy" workers express the ideas of running their own workplaces, of creating democratic structures in the newly emerging independent trade unions, and of writing, for themselves, laws which serve working people.

Workers not yet independent As yet the working class in Eastern Europe has not formed its own democratic class structures, workers' councils ('soviets').

In the past such alternative forms of working class democracy have appeared as the spontaneous product of uprisings in which mass working class movements are involved. Through these new democratic structures workers begin to articulate and fight for political demands as a united, politically independent class.

In the 1917 Russian Revolution, for example, there came into existence a "dual power" in which two forms of government emerged, one the organic form of working class power, the workers' councils ("soviets'), the other, the Provisional government, led by Kerensky, which aimed to stabilise a Russian bourgeois democracy.

Workers' Councils and mass strikes have already been the weapons of the working class in face of Stalinist oppression in Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia at various times in the last 35 years. Strikes have played a part in the East European revolutions. These weapons and means of working class selfmobilisation may again become central in the period ahead as workers have to begin to act as workers to defend themselves, as they surely will. But the reality now is proletarian support for vague ideas of "democracy" , and for pro-market governments. There is no "dual power", there is no mass revolutionary class-conscious workers' movement.

In contrast, to the working class, the majority of people involved in the East European revolutions, there is the minority of liberal intellectuals, the layer which has placed itself at the head of the people's movements. They articulate demands which have political clarity and are well defined in their championing of captalism. Sections of the bureaucracy agree with the dissident intelligentsia in advocating and promoting market capitalism and parliamentary democracy.

Unlike the working class, the intelligentsia has had room under Stalinism (even in spite of harsh repression) to generate a political programme, to become assured of its future political role and to gain the confidence to propagate its own ideology. The intellectuals gain their clarity and confidence from being the local representatives and understudies of the West European bourgeoisie, with all its immense wealth, experience and prestige.

Clearly, the intelligentsia have had some networks, loose organisations, and forums in which to develop ideas and politics before the revolutions. So have the various churches, who play a major role. The working class has had no such organisation.

The working class has not even had trade unions in which to organise independently, still less an arena in which to develop its own political and philosophical ideas through the free exercise of speech, writing and assembly.

In Eastern Europe (and the USSR) things are made even more difficult for the newly awakening working class movements by the Stalinist misuse of the words and ideas used by socialist movements to define and express the interests of the working class. The names, symbols, banners and objectives of the old socialists have been made hateful to millions of workers because of their misuse by the Stalinists to camouflage and try to justify their own anti-socialist rule over so many grim decades.

Revolutionary organisation The greatest vacuum in Eastern Europe and Russia has been the absence of a revolutionary party of the working class - a party which had analysed and learned from the age of Stalinism, without forgetting what capitalism was and is; a party which could oppose Stalinism without supporting capitalism West European-style - in short an organisation which would fight the ideas of the intellectuals, the bureaucrats and the churches and vindicate genuine socialism.

The differences between the new East European governments and the working class will accelerate as moves towards market mechanisms produce austerity, inflation and unemployment. Huge struggles are inevitable. But bitter history teaches us that the most heroic of workers' struggles cannot be victorious unless socialists have built a party of politically conscious militants, a party which has learned from the experience of workers throughout history, a party which can actively intervene in working class struggles and decisively change their nature by giving them a clarity of goals and methods they would otherwise lack - a clarity for the working class such as the intelligentsia in Eastern Europe has for capitalism.

Trotsky put the point like this:

*Events have proved that without a party capable of directing the proletarian revolution, the revolution itself is rendered impossible. The proletariat cannot seize power by a spontaneous uprising. Even in highly industrialised and highly cultured Germany the spontaneous uprising of the workers in November 1918 only succeeded in transferring power into the hands of the bourgeoisie. One propertied class can seize the power that has been wrested from another propertied class because it is able to base itself upon the riches, its cultural level and its innumerable connections with the old state apparatus. But there is nothing else that can serve the proletarict as the substitute for its own party."

(Lessons of October)

Turn to page 8

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 434

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →