Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Sinn Fein and the Protestants

Socialist Organiser no. 434, 15 February 1990 · scan pp. 5–7 · Patrick Murphy · about 1,994 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

VORTHLAND There was a certain amount of soul-searching at last week's Ard Fheis (annual conference) of Sinn Fein in Dublin.

On the surface, of course, Gerry Adams clung to the thin straw provided by Peter Brooke a few months ago when he admitted that the IRA could not be defeated. But underneath there was none of the heady optimism of the early 1980s. The Republican movement faces serious problems and the leaders clearly know it.

First, the 'armed struggle' is leading nowhere. It cannot be defeated, but equally it cannot win. Meanwhile it is wearing down the nationalist community more than the transient regiments of the British Army. The problem was highlighted by the latest victim of IRA action, a young Nationalist attending the annual Bloody Sunday rally in Derry in the immediate up to the conference.

Second, Sinn Fein's election strategy is floundering. The party's Northern voters are shifting to the SDLP or abstaining in noticeable numbers. In the South they have never had a significant vote. Adams blamed the abstentionist policy for this and changed it at the 1986 Ard Fheis. He advised the party then not to expect immediate success at the next election, it would be the 'election after next' when results would really improve. In fact that election was held in June 1989; there was a clear revival of left wing votes but Sinn Fein's vote declined sharply (from 1.9% to 1.2%!)

Finally, Adams demonstrated at least some awareness that Sinn Fein need to consider its attitude and approach to the minority community in Ireland, the Northern Protestants.. He repeated the claim, made at the previous conference, that he had met with representatives of the Protestant community to explain Sinn Fein's strategy and policy'. The nature and significance of these talks is difficult to divine. Adams, understandably, couldn't name the 'representatives, though he hinted that they were part of mainstream Unionism.

The discussion will continue with *'as wide a spectrum of Unionist opinion as possible' ', because Sinn Fein is 'morally bound to seek dialogue as part of the search for peace among our people' . On the other hand Adams made it clear that he thought it very unlikely that 'any sizeable section of the working class Protestants in the North will desert "Any move away straightforward communalism and the Unionist parties while with Britain remains'.

There are encouraging aspects to these developments, though they are very limited. Clearly the Sinn Fein leadership want to reassure the Protestants or be seen to do so. Any move away from straightforward communalism and Catholic nationalism is to be welcomed. These revelations by Adams were received with no opposition; in fact they were apparently welcomed, sug gesting a mood of concern about the issue in the Republican movement. All of this places Sinn Fein head and shoulders above its sympathisers on the British left. So why am I so guarded in my optimism?

Essentially because this concern with Protestant fears and identity makes absolutely no difference to Sinn Fein and IRA practice on the ground. It is a negotiating plan; there 1s no connection with Republican strategy. This is not a minor, nitpicking complaint. No more depressing evidence of the chronic communalism of Sinn Fein politics can be imagined than the declaration by the IRA last week that all workers at Shorts Engineering factory are legitimate targets because they work mainly on defence contracts. Shorts mainly employ Protestants, in fact it is notorious for discrimination in employment. Under pressure from cIVil rights campaigners and the FEA it is now employing more Catholics.

To make its workers military targets is a piece of sectarian lunacy, certain to destroy any degree of unity that does exist on the factory floor. It is, however, characteristic of Sinn Fein and IRA strategy. To conduct an armed struggle against anyone vaguely connected with security work in Northern Ireland is simply to declare war on the vast bulk of Protestants. No amount of talks with Unionist representatives will alter the effect that this 'war' has on the ground.

A serious political campaign for working class unity and an agreed democratic solution is simply not compatible with a war on all those supporting British rule because the Protestant community at the moment overwhelmingly supports the union with Britain.

Perhaps the Republicans can use their talks with Protestants to face that reality. The existence of a distinct Protestant community, within a British-created statelet but without the firm guarantees of British government support which they enjoyed in the past amounts to a unique combination in Irish history. It is in fact the biggest challenge Irish nationalism has ever faced. Even within its own tradition, however, the challenge can be met, but only by discarding the strategy of armed struggle against Britain in favour of a political struggle to unite the Irish working-class around a democratic solution.

Scan page 6

SOCIALISM ..• Means 6 SOCIALISM A socialist manifesto from the editorial board of Socialist Organiser Today the bourgeoisie can march in triumph right across Europe. ExStalinists, ex-socialists, exMarxists, ex-radicals join the loyal crowds.

But beyond the cheering squads, off the thoroughfares, out of the limelight, grow bitterness and anger, lacking only confidence to turn into rebellion.] As the economy of the free market and private profit spreads in Eastern Europe, the exuberant joy of the democratic revolutions will turn into the hard, set, strained faces of the workers on the streets of Poland's cities. There, where the drive towards capitalist orthodoxy has gone furthest in Eastern Europe, the workers have their living standards cut by up to two-thirds in the course of one month, and a sudden rise of unemployment.

In the western advanced capitalist countries there is now a permanent pool of over 30 million unemployed. Growing numbers are not only unemployed but destitute. London and New York, the two greatest centres of the new fortunes grabbed in the money markets and stock exchanges in the 1980s, have 75,000 homeless apiece. Beggars line their streets.

The misery of the minority is an index of the insecurity of the majority. Industries and enterprises move from boom to slump at feverish speed; almost no worker can be sure of their livelihood; almost no working-class family is untouched by the wild gyrations that periodically scoop thousands out of the workforce and hurl them on to the dole queues.

Inequality and exploitation are increasing everywhere. In the United States, real wages have been stagnant or declining since the early 1970s. In those countries where wages have risen, incomes from exploitation have risen much taster.

In Latin America and Africa there are not tens, but hundreds of millions of unemployed. Rich Western banks demand their interest payments; the local exploiters who squandered the money borrowed from the banks pass on the bill to the workers and peasants. They have forced down workers' living standards by an average of 25 per cent in many countries. The majority lose whatever slight progress out of poverty they made over previous decades; great numbers suffer malnutrition; sizeable minorities starve.

Capitalism does develop the productive forces. It does draw millions out of xpand their ural squalor. educate them, horizons, develop their ambitions. Taunting and shi iddy though its promises are, they lever society out of stagnation.

But the essence of capitalism is the confiscation of the creative powers of the workers by the capitalists, and the trashing of those workers for whose labour mand. It pulls the workers into more productive, more concentrated, more cooperative, more technically-equipped labour, and at the same time pushes them away from participating in the creative possibilities of the technology they create.

Fifty years ago the capitalist free market was utterly discredited as a way of regulating production and distribution. It created chaos and capitalism, it that, smand sd"

tainable and defensible.

In the 1950s and "60s the defenders of capitalism began to hope and to claim that such "management" could cure all the essential ills of capitalism, and provide for security, increasing equality, and stable democracy. In the 1970s and '80s all those claims for capitalist state economic management were thoroughly discredited. But now the argument has turned full circle: the free market is the banner which leads the bourgeoisie's new triumphal parade.

Relatively free trade on a world scale does offer better prospects for capitalism than a world of trade blocs, which is the only alternative in a system of nation states and private profit. Today that relatively free world market is being used by the capitalists as a sharp weapon of restructuring.

Nationalisation in the West turns out to have been merely a method for capitalism to put some largescale industries under state protection when they were considered nationally essential, discarded once they are no longer so. State welfare is shown to have been a hand-out which capitalism conceded in a boom period, but will take back in time of economic difficulty, when it can get a sufficient reserve army of workers fit to work without such expense.

For the destructive purposes of the bourgeoisie, the free market works quite well. Yet the best use of new technology demands more education and training, freer flow of information, more social investment. It demands planning and cooperation.

The free market produces just the same evils that it always produced. Capitalism has not rediscovered some lost magic. It has not conquered its ills. It has not solved its inner conflicts. The world regime of relatively free trade, on which its recent successes depend, is vulnerable, not secure. It has been under pressure from protectionism for two decades now. The stock exchange crash of October 1987 gave warning of how unstable its financial balances are. A similar crash affecting the dollar could send the whole world into a huge slump. The lives of millions could be wrecked by the fluctuations of millionaires greedy gambles with pieces of col works, more so today than ever in oured paper: that is how capitalism The collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe does not vindicate capitalism. Stalinism was never the working class alternative to capitalism. It was not made by the working class. The Russian Revolution was made by the working class; but the Stalinist structure was erected only on the grave of that revolution, only by crushing all the organisations of the working class and in the first place crushing the Bolshevik party which had led the revolution.

That crushing, in one form Or another, was inevitable if the workers' revolution remained isolated in backward Russia; the Bolsheviks knew that and predicted it. The reason why it remained isolated was the lack of revolutionary workers' parties like the Bolshevik in Western Europe.

Stalinism is not the achievement of workers" struggle, of socialism, of Bolshevism. It represents the defeat of workers' struggles, of socialism, and of Bolshevism, both in the USSR and in all other Stalinist countries, where the Stalinist regimes were imposed on the working class by bureaucratic military machines.

"The triumph of Stalinism in one third the globe...corru pted and demoralised mosi of two generations of worker activists.

Stalinism is an ugly sibling of capitalism, not its successor. Inequality; exploitation; alienation of the creative powers of labour and of human solidarity; domination by a small privileged minority; irresponsible destruction of the environment in pursuit of narrow economic goals - the characteristic evils of capitalism are reproduced under Stalinism, and to them is added a hideous totalitarian regime similar to the worst of capitalist tyrannies.

Where Stalinist regimes have introduced job security in place or capitalism's characteristic insecurity of employment, they have accompanied it with equally harassing forms of insecurity for the worker - routinely, goods and services can be got only by bribery, stringpulling, the black market, or queuAs East European workers will find, a great deal of what they rebelled against in the Stalinist systems was no more than an exaggerated and twisted form of what

Scan page 7

SOCIALISM 7

----- pull-quotes -----

Catholic nationalism is to be welcomed."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 434

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →