Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

De Klerk must move fast

Socialist Organiser no. 434, 15 February 1990 · scan p. 5 · Bob Fine · about 966 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Watching on TV Nelson Mandela emerge from twenty six years of captivity, I must confess to finding an unmistakeable lump involuntarily growing in my throat, and probably linking me to many millions of other viewers.

There must be a whole generation of young activists for whom the words "Free Mandela" accompanied or sometimes even induced entry into left politics. And now his personal sacrifice is over, he is free and the myth may at last become the man.

I say this not without personal reservations. I remember my own dismay at what I felt to be a cult of a personality which was constructed around his name, if my memory is right, in the early 1980s, and which had a damaging impact on the political culture of the liberation movement. The elevation of Mandela was a symbol of the aspirations of a downtrodden people but it also expressed what the "The perils of Glasnost in Africa are 1 10 less than in the Soviet Italians call the "leaderismo" which , permeated liberation.

Mandela's release is a major step forward for the struggle against apartheid — not just for the ANC but for struggle as a whole. This is not primarily because of Mandela's vaunted personal qualities -though I found the reality of Mandela more positive than the myth and his performance impressive - but because the new political situation represents the breaking down of huge barriers which for years have stood in the way of the development of the working class.

Most of the pundits — Snow on "Newsnight" was a dramatic example - altogether misinterpreted Mandela's speech as simply an intransigent re-assertion of the armed struggle and the demand for a unitary, democratic, non-racial South Africa. After saluting the ANC, the Communist Party and the armed struggle of the Umkonto We Sizwe, what Mandela did was build a bridge to the suspension of the armed struggle in favour of negotiations with the government.

What he said was that the initiation of the armed struggle in 1961 was defensive, that it continues to be necessary as a defensive struggle today, but — this was the crucial bit - that he looked forward to the creation of conditions which would allow for the suspension/end of the armed struggle. He then spelt out those conditions, which were also the conditions for substantive negotiations with the government: first, the lifting of the state of emergency and second, the release of all and not just some of the political prisoners.

It is entirely conceivable that agreement with the government could be reached on both these issues. Indeed Van de Maerwe, the architect of the De Klerk strategy, immediately responded that problem of defining political prisoners could be resolved in discussions. The lifting of the state of emergency is also on the cards — and would leave the "security forces" with enormous powers intact. The other ANC condition which I did not hear mentioned was "troops out of the townships" - I am not clear if this precondition has been dropped. It is also interesting that the ANC's leading spokesperson, Tabo Mbeki who is very much on the glasnost wing of the Communist Party), endorsed what Mandela had to say on this matter.

Mandela offered a number of other bridges towards negotiation. He described De Klerk as "a man of integrity" . He defined his own role in negotiations with De Klerk and other government ministers as designed for the "normalisation of the political process" . He finished his speech with an extract from his famous speech in the dock in 1964, saying that he stood implacably against white domination but also Mandela: free at last against black domination and for a non-racial democracy. This formulation opens the door for negotiating some kind of "minority rights" for whites.

The most cryptic part of Mandela's speech was when he said that "as a lawyer and a disciplined member of the ANC" he stood by all the strategies and the tactics of the ANC. He also affirmed the principle that leaders of the liberation movement should be democratically accountable to and elected by the organisation they represent. He and Mbeki certainly seem to be in accord.

For the government, Van de Maerwe did not rule out the possibility of a joint ANCNationalist government. It seems to me that the Nationalists have to move very fast, since it will be very difficult for them either to backtrack or to stand still at this stage. On the extreme right of white politics, the hounds are baying. Television shots of the police behaving in their normal animal fashion and of the Nazi AWB mouthing off about their own armed struggle, are testimony of the dangers of a right military backlash against the government. The perils of 'glasnost' in South Africa are no less than in the Soviet Union.

On the left of the liberation movement, there is likely to emerge strong criticism of the abandonment of the armed struggle and of the switch from non-collaboration to negotiation. We should avoid this temptation. First, the armed struggle should not be seen as the mark of revolutionism or socialism in the anti-apartheid movement.

Second, negotiations should not be equated with lack of conviction or sell-out. Thirdly, the move to negotiation and participation - the two current buzz words — offers a potentially more favourable terrain for working class struggle than we have seen for some years.

Hopefully the left will avoid a simple reflex negation of the new turn in liberation politics. What is needed rather is the immediate development and articulation of a working class political voice. The base for this has necessarily to come from what are at present by far the largest organisations of the working class: the independent unions in COSATU and NACTU

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 434

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →