Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The tradesman cometh... back!

Socialist Organiser no. 433, 8 February 1990 · scan p. 12 · about 842 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

By Sleeper Any socialist discussion of A the present strike wave at Ford immediately faces terminological problem: we have no words to describe the prime movers in the dispute, except "tradesmen' "craftsmen' or 'skilled men'.

Somehow, 'craftspersons' doesn't sound quite right. The fact that we have no modern non-sexist terminology with which to describe these workers is less because, as a matter of fact, they are virtually all men, than because since the late '7Os the left has not had much cause to talk about these sort of workers at all.

Along with the Tories, the union bureaucracy and the Marxism Today crowd, most of the left assumed that the days of militant skilled workers waging guerilla war over differentials were numbered. Roy Fraser and British Leyland toolmakers in the late '70s were generally assumed to have represented the final death throes of an industrial dinosaur.

The comparison with the BL toolmakers did not go well with the AEU craft militant from Dagenham whom I spoke to.

"They were a very narrow, backward group who just wanted more for themselves at the expense of everyone else, " he protested. The revolt by electricians and craft grades at Ford is not like that at all, he insisted.

As he was a very helpful, friendly guy who I had phoned up rather late at night, - did not argue the point. But it struck me as significant that a good left-winger, involved in a dispute that largely revolves around the maintenance of differentials and the protection of traditional skilled status, should come out with that particular piece of CP-inspired demonology about the toolmakers.

In fact the similarities between the two disputes are highly instructive. In both, a relatively small, tightly-knit group of skilled workers feel themselves railroaded into agreements that may be OK for the majority of unskilled and semi-skilled grades but do not take into account traditional differentials and demarcations.

There are, of course, important differences between BL in 1977-79 and the present Ford dispute. The most obvious is that BL was broke while Ford is highly profitable.

Another is that the BL toolmakers were up against a Labour government and its Social Contract, while the Ford workers face a Tory government that, officially at least, has no truck with pay restraint and is supposed to encourage the idea of pay settlements reflecting the profitability of the company (which ought to put Ford workers in line for a 20% increase...). These differences explain why the Ford electricians and craft workers have yet to experience the savage onslaught from the union bureaucracy that was visited upon the BL toolmakers.

The Ford dispute actually has the official support of one trade union - the EETPU, expelled from the TUC two years ago, and widely denounced by the left as 'scabs' , a 'gaffers union', etc., etc. Paradoxically, the small pro-TUC breakaway electricians' union,, the EPIU, who are particularly strong in the Dagenham body plant, oppose the strike and are the main weakness in the solidarity of electricians and craft grades.

The EETPU's motives for its stance are, of course, entirely opportunist, but still, perhaps those groups on the left who were so eager to write off the EETPU as something akin to the straightforward scabs of the UDM, ought to reflect on the implications of the Ford situation.

The TGWU (representing the vast majority of production workers) will endorse Ford's 10.2% deal; the only question is whether their national automotive officer, Jack Adams, will choose to ignore the craft revolt or openly condemn it and call for the crossing of picket lines as he did in 1977, when together with Derek Robinson he helped break the BL toolmakers' strike.

The AEU's Jimmy Airlie is in a rather more difficult position, representing as he does both production and craft grades. At Monday's 'consultative' delegate conference of Ford shop stewards, Airlie ducked out of a clear decision one way or the other: he rejected demands for a fresh ballot for industrial action of skilled grades, but agreed not to sign Ford's agreement.

Airlie's refusal to sign actually amounts to very little, as the agreement has to be signed by all the Ford unions and the EETPU is already committed to rejection.

Meanwhile, the EETPU has seized the initiative while formulating the only clear and straightforward set of demands for the strike: 5% craft allowance (on top of the 10.2% national deal), and the rejection of Integrated Manufacturing Teams' for all trades.

The high degree of inter-dependence between Ford's European plants and the company's "Just in Time' policy for sourcing components give the electricians and craft workers tremendous power. Lay-offs can be expected, not only at the 21 British plants but also at Genk (Belgium), Valencia (Spain), Saarlovis and Cologne (Germany).

The issues may seem complicated to outside observers and the workers themselves may not always be clear in their objectives, but here we have a group of workers fighting for a better deal.

We must support them. Maybe we'll soon be talking about "craftspersons' after all.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 433

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →